The Rules Committee puts Mamdani's five Planning Commission picks and its Board of Correction nominee back on the agenda Nov. 19, two days before the Council's deadline
The committee heard all six on Nov. 9 and laid them over. The Nov. 19 meeting precedes that afternoon's stated meeting, the last before the 30-day window on the Planning nominations closes. Julie Stein's ethics waiver requests were still pending as of her testimony.
The Council's Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics, chaired by Sandra Ung, has scheduled a meeting for 10:30 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, our records show. Its agenda lists the same six appointments it heard on Nov. 9: Mayor Zohran Mamdani's five nominees to the City Planning Commission and the Council's own pick for the Board of Correction, Martha King.
Why it matters to residents: starting in January, the Planning Commission gets the final say on qualifying affordable housing projects in 12 "fast track" community districts, under charter changes voters approved last year. It also reviews the changes the Council makes to rezonings, such as the two Forest Hills applications the Land Use Committee sent back to it Tuesday.
This is a follow-up to our Nov. 10 story on the nominees' hearing.
Who is on the agenda
- Anthony Crowell (M 93), reappointment.
- Kenneth Knuckles (M 94), reappointment as vice chair.
- Julie Stein (M 95), executive director of the Union Square Partnership.
- Margaret Anadu (M 96), founder of an investment firm.
- Meenakshi Srinivasan (M 97), former chair of the Landmarks Preservation Commission and the Board of Standards and Appeals.
- Martha King (T2026-2639), former executive director of the Board of Correction, nominated by the Council.
Our records show four of the Planning nominations and King's appointment as laid over on Nov. 9; Stein's record lists no action from that day, though she testified. An agenda listing does not guarantee a vote; items can be laid over again.
Advertisement
The timing
City Limits has reported that the Council has 30 days after a Planning Commission nomination is formally submitted to act. The five were referred to the committee on Oct. 22, which points to about Nov. 21. The committee meets the morning of the Council's Nov. 19 stated meeting, the last one scheduled before then.
King's appointment works differently: the Council names three of the board's nine members itself. Our records list her item with a Nov. 12 introduction date, the day of this week's stated meeting.
Open questions from the hearing
Stein's waivers. Stein told the committee on Nov. 9 that two requests were pending with the Conflicts of Interest Board: one to let her keep dealing with city agencies and officials in her business improvement district job, and one covering the district's possible expansion (1:25:03). She said she expected both to be approved. We found no public notice of a decision as of Wednesday.
The Council's role. Land Use chair Kevin C. Riley and others asked how the commission will handle neighborhood concerns now that the Council has no formal vote on some applications. Gale A. Brewer, whose Upper West Side community board is one of the 12 fast-track districts, said she was "so angry" about the designation (3:16:13).
Advertisement
King on ICE and jail deaths. King told Minority Leader David M. Carr she would not support changing local law to let the Correction Department cooperate with ICE detainers, and Deputy Speaker Nantasha M. Williams pressed her on deaths in custody, as we reported. The Council's Immigration Committee takes up two detainer bills the next day, Nov. 20, a week after a federal judge ordered the city to answer an ICE subpoena for Bronx shelter records.
What's next
If the committee approves any of the six on Nov. 19, the full Council could vote that afternoon. The video and transcript of the Nov. 9 hearing are on our meeting page.