On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilLand Use

Council committees approve all four land-use items: the Forest Hills rezonings go back to City Planning with deeper affordability, Studio 54 heads to the full Council

The Zoning Subcommittee voted 6-0 and the Land Use Committee 9-0 on Tuesday. Lynn Schulman announced an agreement with the co-op next to the 389-apartment Queens Boulevard tower. Because the Council changed the two Forest Hills applications, they return to the Planning Commission before a final vote.

The Council's Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises and its Committee on Land Use approved all four land-use applications on their calendars Tuesday, Nov. 10, our records show. The subcommittee voted 6-0, with no abstentions, and held the vote open for a member who had not yet arrived (9:59). An hour later, the full Land Use Committee voted 9-0 on all four items together (4:46).

Why it matters to residents: these votes shape what can be built on specific blocks in Forest Hills, Midtown and the South Shore of Staten Island. Two of the four will not reach the full Council right away, because the Council changed them.

This is a follow-up to our Tuesday story, written before the votes.

The two Forest Hills rezonings: approved with changes

Both are in Lynn C. Schulman's district, and the Council made the same change to each. Subcommittee chair Farah N. Louis said the Council is removing Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Option 2 and adding Option 3, so the affordable apartments would be priced for households earning an average of 40% or 60% of the area median income (1:40). Option 2 sets its affordable units at a higher average income.

  • 100-12 Queens Boulevard (LU 150 and 151): a rezoning from R7-1 to R9X for a building of about 389 apartments, up to 97 of them permanently affordable, Louis said. Schulman, who had said at the October hearing that she wanted a written agreement with the Fontaine, the co-op behind the site, before anyone voted, said Tuesday that the developer "reached an agreement with the abutting co-op" to "invest significant resources to mitigate project impacts" (2:07). She said the developer also committed to keep the character of the retail space, is talking with current tenants about returning, with "a heavy emphasis" on the drugstore, and agreed to strengthen the required stormwater retention plan. She put the affordable apartments at about 100. The terms of the co-op agreement were not described at the meeting.
  • 108-05 68th Road (LU 148 and 149): a rezoning from R1-2A to R7A for a mixed-use building with about 33 apartments, up to eight affordable, and about 12,000 square feet for a daycare center, Louis said. Schulman said the negotiations had been "so smooth" that she did not prepare remarks (9:13).

Because the Council modified them, both go back to the City Planning Commission. Our records list each as "Approved with Modifications and Referred to CPC." Under the City Charter, the commission reviews whether the changes need more environmental or land-use review before the Council takes its final vote. The commission is the same body whose five nominees are before the Council's Rules Committee.

Studio 54: on to the full Council

LU 153 and 154, from Roundabout Theatre Company, amend the Theater Subdistrict rules and grant a special permit so the bonus floor area earned by rehabilitating the theater can be transferred to other sites in the district. Carl Wilson said the change "doesn't just stop at Studio 54" and creates a tool "the entire theater district can use" to pay for capital work in old, constrained buildings (6:03). Schulman added that she was probably the only member old enough to have gone to Studio 54 in its heyday (9:38).

South Richmond open space: on to the full Council

LU 152, from the Department of City Planning, corrects designated open space boundaries at three sites in the Special South Richmond Development District, changes Louis described as fixing boundaries modified in 2023. Frank Morano supports it, she said. At the October hearing, Morano had asked for assurance that the correction would not create new development rights.

Our records list both the Studio 54 and South Richmond items as "Companion Pending Approval by Council."

What's next

The full Council meets Thursday, Nov. 12 and Thursday, Nov. 19. Its Nov. 12 agenda had not been posted when we checked Wednesday morning, so we can't yet say whether the Studio 54 and South Richmond items are on it. The Forest Hills items will come back after the Planning Commission acts. Both meeting pages have the video and a searchable transcript.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime