On My Block · NYC Politics

CourtsImmigration

A federal judge orders the city to answer an ICE subpoena for Bronx shelter records. The Council's immigration hearing on detainer limits is Nov. 20

Judge Lewis Kaplan ruled that a special master will screen residents of the Bruckner shelter in Mott Haven and pass ICE only those with serious criminal histories. The city says it is evaluating next steps. Two Council bills to limit cooperation with immigration agents get their first hearing next week.

A federal judge in Manhattan ruled Friday, Nov. 6, that the city must comply with a subpoena from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement for information about residents of the Bruckner shelter in Mott Haven, the Bronx, Scripps News reported. Under the order from District Judge Lewis Kaplan, a special master will identify residents with certain serious criminal histories and give only those names to ICE.

"The City has not shown that producing this list would be unduly burdensome," Kaplan wrote, according to Scripps. Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration said it was "evaluating next steps."

Why it matters to residents: the city's sanctuary laws limit what agencies share with federal immigration authorities. This order sets out when a court can make the city hand over records anyway, and it comes as the Council prepares to consider bills that would tighten those limits.

What the order says

According to Scripps and an account in The Mary Sue based on Gothamist's reporting:

  • ICE first asked for the names and birth dates of everyone staying at the shelter. The agency agreed to the special master, which narrowed the request.
  • An ICE officer's sworn statement said the investigation would look for residents with histories of crimes including murder, manslaughter, rape, robbery, assault, grand larceny and burglary.
  • The city had called an earlier request "a fishing expedition" and argued the subpoena was political. Kaplan found little support for that, The Mary Sue reported.
  • ICE began sending subpoenas for shelter residents' information in August 2025, before Mamdani took office, and has issued four.

The New York Immigration Coalition urged the city to appeal, saying that sharing data for civil immigration enforcement is illegal under local law, according to The Mary Sue. We found no report of an appeal as of Wednesday.

The shelter

The Bruckner site, a converted warehouse with about 2,200 beds, opened in February 2025 and took in men moved from the Randall's Island tent site, according to The Mary Sue. At the Committee on Immigration's March 25 hearing, a question to the administration noted that the last remaining migrant shelter was planned to close by the end of 2026, sending "roughly 2,000 plus people" into the rest of the shelter system (1:27:28). Mott Haven is in Elsie Encarnación's district.

Earlier this year, Carmen N. De La Rosa asked an administration official at a March 2 Technology Committee hearing what the city's policy is when an agency receives a federal subpoena for data. The official said they would have to defer to the Law Department and agencies' lawyers (43:04).

The Council's Nov. 20 hearing

Encarnación chairs the Immigration Committee, which holds an oversight hearing on immigration enforcement in the city on Friday, Nov. 20, at 10 a.m. Its agenda lists:

  • Int. 1077, from Encarnación, limiting when the NYPD may hold someone on a civil immigration detainer.
  • Int. 1078, also from Encarnación, limiting communication between the Correction Department and federal immigration authorities.
  • Int. 739, from Shahana K. Hanif, requiring agency training and published plans on immigration enforcement.
  • T2026-2544, a resolution asking Albany to pass the BUILD Act on immigrant legal defense.

At the Rules Committee on Nov. 9, Minority Leader David M. Carr called the city's detainer policy "the very definition of non-cooperation" while questioning the Council's Board of Correction nominee, as we reported.

What's next

Kaplan gave the parties 14 days to propose how the special master will be appointed and paid, according to coverage of the order. Members of the public can testify at the Nov. 20 hearing in person or online.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime