On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilJails

The Council's Board of Correction pick is questioned on ICE detainers and jail deaths. Two bills to limit detainer cooperation get a hearing Nov. 20

Martha King, a former executive director of the jail oversight board, told Minority Leader David Carr she would not support changing local law to let the Correction Department cooperate with ICE. The Immigration Committee hears Elsie Encarnación's detainer bills later this month.

The Council's nominee for the Board of Correction, the nine-member panel that sets minimum standards for city jails and investigates deaths in custody, told the Rules Committee on Monday that she would not back a change in local law to let the Correction Department hand people over to federal immigration agents on a detainer request.

The nominee, Martha King, ran the board's staff as executive director from 2015 to 2019 and now chairs the board of the Correctional Association of New York, which monitors state prisons, she testified. If appointed, she would fill the rest of a term that ends Feb. 1, 2029 (3:54). The board has nine members: three named by the mayor, three by the Council and three by the mayor on nominations from the courts.

Why it matters to residents: the board writes the rules for conditions on Rikers Island and in the borough jails that are meant to replace it, and it reports on each death in custody. Rikers is now run day to day under a federal court-appointed remediation manager, NY1 reported in January, which makes the board's reports one of the few public windows on what is happening inside.

What members asked

ICE detainers. Minority Leader David M. Carr asked whether the department should keep refusing ICE detainer requests (14:45). King said the department should follow the laws set by the Council and the mayor, and that she would not advocate changing them. Asked about people with prior convictions, she said she understood the department is required to communicate with federal authorities about people convicted of felonies, though not misdemeanors, and said she is not a lawyer. When Carr asked for her own view on people with prior convictions, she said, "No, I don't think they should be handed over" (16:12). Carr said current local law, which is being challenged in court, requires a judicial warrant, and called the policy "the very definition of non-cooperation." King said she sees the city as following the law (17:27).

Deaths in custody. Deputy Speaker Nantasha M. Williams said 15 people died in city custody in 2025 and seven have died so far this year (23:20). King said the board should look across deaths for repeated failures, not only investigate each one, and publish that broader accounting (23:45).

The Nunez findings. Shekar Krishnan cited the 2025 report in the Nunez case, the long-running federal lawsuit over Rikers conditions, on staffing and operational failures and asked how the board can make sure its recommendations are carried out. King said the board has escalating responses to noncompliance that it should use consistently (44:09).

Chris Banks asked about the borough-based jails and the risk of delays and cost overruns (18:34). Linda Lee asked about mental health care at Rikers (34:25), and Simcha Felder pressed King on her answer about solitary confinement (38:30).

Where the appointment stands

The committee did not vote. Our records list the appointment, T2026-2639, with a Nov. 12 date, the day of the next stated meeting, so it could come to the full Council then if the committee acts first. The same hearing also took up Mayor Zohran Mamdani's five City Planning Commission nominees; our story on that part is here.

The detainer bills on Nov. 20

The Committee on Immigration, chaired by Elsie Encarnación, holds an oversight hearing on immigration enforcement in the city on Friday, Nov. 20, at 10 a.m. Its agenda includes:

  • Int. 1077, from Encarnación with 14 sponsors, to limit when the NYPD may hold someone on a civil immigration detainer.
  • Int. 1078, also from Encarnación with the same 14 sponsors, to limit communication between the Correction Department and federal immigration authorities.
  • Int. 739, from Shahana K. Hanif with eight sponsors, requiring agency training and published plans on immigration enforcement.

Both Encarnación bills were introduced Sept. 24 and have not had a hearing. A broader Hanif bill, Int. 209, which would let people sue over detainer cooperation and has 22 sponsors, is not on the agenda.

The hearing follows Mamdani's Nov. 2 letter threatening to sue if ICE keeps staging operations in city park lots. As of our last check, no suit had been reported as filed.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime