Mamdani's five Planning Commission picks face the Council: no vote yet, one nominee awaiting ethics waivers, and members worried about their shrinking role
At Monday's Rules Committee hearing, members pressed the nominees on infrastructure, neighborhood plans and the new fast-track housing review. Julie Stein disclosed two pending Conflicts of Interest Board waiver requests. The committee has not scheduled a vote.
The five people Mayor Zohran Mamdani wants on the City Planning Commission spent Monday morning before the Council's Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics, chaired by Sandra Ung. Members asked how the commission will treat neighborhoods now that voters have moved more land-use power from the Council to the commission. The committee took no votes, and no members of the public signed up to speak, according to our meeting record, which has the video and a searchable transcript.
Why it matters to residents: starting in January, the commission gets the final say on qualifying affordable housing projects in 12 "fast track" community districts, under charter changes voters approved last year. Question 3, which passed last week in unofficial results, gives it the last word on some city land sales too. The people on the commission now decide more of what gets built on your block.
This is a follow-up to our Nov. 4 story on Question 3 and the nominations.
The nominees
- Anthony Crowell (M 93), reappointment. The dean of New York Law School has served on the commission since 2022. He said he would ensure the commission "remains highly attentive to the voices of council members" after the charter changes (1:11:17).
- Kenneth Knuckles (M 94), reappointment as vice chair. He said his membership spans five mayoral administrations (1:30:15).
- Julie Stein (M 95), executive director of the Union Square Partnership, the area's business improvement district.
- Margaret Anadu (M 96), a former Goldman Sachs partner who founded an investment firm. She said she believes in transit-oriented development, partly because she is "the rare Texan who doesn't know how to drive" (1:28:26).
- Meenakshi Srinivasan (M 97), former chair of the Landmarks Preservation Commission and of the Board of Standards and Appeals, who said she has worked 36 years as a planner (1:16:12).
The ethics waivers
Stein told the committee that two waiver requests are pending with the Conflicts of Interest Board (1:25:03). One would let her keep dealing with city agencies, community boards and Council members in her Union Square Partnership job. The second covers the partnership's possible expansion of the 14th Street-Union Square business improvement district. She said she would not appear before the commission or the Department of City Planning in that process and would recuse herself from any commission matter involving it. Both requests are still under review, she said, and she expects them to be approved. Crain's also reported the disclosure.
Advertisement
What members asked
Ung opened by asking whether the nominees support pairing new housing with commitments for infrastructure and community investment, the "points of agreement" the Council has long negotiated in rezonings, and who will do that work now that the Council has no formal role in some applications (1:31:40). The nominees said they support linking density to infrastructure. One said the new process puts "a greater responsibility" on commissioners to make sure concerns raised by community boards and borough presidents are resolved (1:34:29).
Kevin C. Riley, who chairs the Land Use Committee, said he is working on a neighborhood plan for White Plains Road and asked what role neighborhood plans should play (1:45:44). He then asked Knuckles what would make him vote against a housing proposal. Knuckles said he would vote no if he concluded a project "does not enhance the community," citing too few affordable units, a weak environmental review or a scale out of step with the area (1:48:11).
Gale A. Brewer said her Upper West Side community board is one of the 12 fast-track districts and that she was "so angry" about it (3:16:13). She argued her district has almost no vacant land and asked whether the commission would allow demolition in historic districts. One nominee answered that the designation can feel "punitive" but said the hope is that it leads to a frank discussion of why some districts have produced less housing (3:18:25).
Earlier in the hearing, members questioned a separate nominee, Martha King, for the Board of Correction. We cover that exchange here.
What's next
The committee must vote before the full Council can act. City Limits has reported that the Council has 30 days after a nomination is formally submitted. The nominations were referred on Oct. 22, which points to about Nov. 21. The Council's next stated meetings are Nov. 12 and Nov. 19.