On My Block · NYC Politics

City PlanningAppointments

Council confirms four of Mamdani's Planning Commission picks and Martha King for the Board of Correction. Five members voted no on most of them

Anthony Crowell drew one no vote; Kenneth Knuckles, Margaret Anadu and Meenakshi Srinivasan drew five. King, who told the Council she would not let the jails honor ICE detainers, was approved 41-6. Julie Stein's nomination remains withdrawn.

The City Council on Thursday, Nov. 19, approved four of Mayor Zohran Mamdani's five nominees to the City Planning Commission and its own pick for the Board of Correction, Martha King. Each was voted on separately from the rest of the day's business, and each drew opposition from the same group of five members, according to the minutes.

Why it matters to residents: starting in January the Planning Commission gets the final say on qualifying affordable housing projects in 12 "fast track" community districts, under charter changes voters approved last year. The Board of Correction sets minimum standards for city jails, including Rikers Island.

This follows our Thursday story on the mayor's withdrawal of a fifth nominee, Julie Stein, hours before the vote.

The votes

  • Anthony Crowell (M 93), reappointed: 46-1, with one abstention. Phil Wong voted no and Minority Leader David M. Carr abstained.
  • Kenneth Knuckles (M 94), reappointed: 43-5. No votes: Joann Ariola, Carr, Frank Morano, Inna Vernikov and Wong.
  • Margaret Anadu (M 96): 42-5, with Darlene Mealy abstaining. Same five no votes.
  • Meenakshi Srinivasan (M 97): 42-5, Mealy abstaining. Same five no votes.
  • Martha King, Board of Correction (M 100): 41-6, Mealy abstaining. The same five plus Simcha Felder, who said during the roll call that he voted yes on everything except King.

Three members were not there: Ty Hankerson and Sandy Nurse were absent and Vickie Paladino was on medical leave.

The committee vote

That morning the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics, chaired by Sandra Ung, approved all five, 8-1, with Carr the only no, and approved Crowell 8-0 with Carr abstaining, according to its minutes.

Explaining his vote, Carr said Crowell is dean of New York Law School and that he himself is enrolled there. He called Crowell "an excellent appointee" who has served on the commission since 2022 but said he would abstain "out of an abundance of caution," and vote no on the others (2:41). He gave no reason for the no votes.

What King told the Council

At her Nov. 9 hearing King told Carr she would not support changing local law to let the Correction Department cooperate with ICE detainers, as we reported. The Council's Immigration Committee hears bills on Friday that would tighten those limits further (our story).

Stein

Stein's nomination (M 95) is still listed as laid over in committee. In a letter dated Nov. 19, the mayor asked the Council to withdraw it "for the time being" and said he would resubmit it "in the near future." At her Nov. 9 hearing Stein said two ethics waiver requests tied to her job at the Union Square Partnership were pending (1:25:03). We found no public decision on them as of Friday morning.

What's next

City Limits has reported that the Council has 30 days after a Planning nomination is formally submitted to act. The four votes came Thursday, ahead of the roughly Nov. 21 mark that applied to nominations referred Oct. 22. A resubmitted Stein nomination would start the process again.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime