On My Block · NYC Politics

City PlanningAppointments

Mamdani pulls Julie Stein's Planning Commission nomination 'for the time being' as the Council's Rules Committee takes up his other four picks

A letter dated Thursday asks the Council to withdraw Stein's name and says the mayor will resubmit it. She told the committee Nov. 9 that two ethics waiver requests tied to her business district job were still pending.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani has asked the City Council to withdraw his nomination of Julie Stein to the City Planning Commission, according to a letter to Speaker Julie Menin dated Thursday, Nov. 19, and filed on Stein's Legistar record, M 95.

"I hereby ask the City Council to withdraw this name from consideration for the time being," the letter says. "I look forward to resubmitting Ms. Stein's nomination in the near future." It gives no reason. Copies went to Stein, Deputy Mayor for Housing and Planning Leila Bozorg and Planning Commission Chair Sideya Sherman.

The agenda for Thursday's 10:30 a.m. meeting of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics, reprinted Nov. 19, now lists four of the mayor's five nominees and the Council's Board of Correction pick, Martha King. Stein's nomination is no longer on it.

Why it matters to residents: starting in January the Planning Commission gets the final say on qualifying affordable housing projects in 12 "fast track" community districts, under charter changes voters approved last year. Who sits on it shapes what gets built on your block.

This follows our Nov. 11 story on the committee's plans for Thursday.

The ethics waivers

Stein is executive director of the Union Square Partnership, the business improvement district for Union Square and 14th Street. At the committee's Nov. 9 hearing she said two waiver requests were pending with the Conflicts of Interest Board (1:25:03): one to let her keep dealing with city agencies, community boards and Council members in her partnership job, and one covering the partnership's possible expansion of the 14th Street-Union Square district. She said she expected both to be approved and would recuse herself from any commission matter involving the expansion, as we reported.

The mayor's letter does not mention the waivers, and we found no public decision on them as of Thursday morning. We are not drawing a connection the letter does not make.

Who is still on the agenda

  • Anthony Crowell (M 93), reappointment. The dean of New York Law School has served on the commission since 2022.
  • Kenneth Knuckles (M 94), reappointment as vice chair.
  • Margaret Anadu (M 96), founder of an investment firm.
  • Meenakshi Srinivasan (M 97), former chair of the Landmarks Preservation Commission and the Board of Standards and Appeals.
  • Martha King (M 100), the Council's nominee for the Board of Correction, who told members on Nov. 9 she would not support changing local law to let the Correction Department honor ICE detainers (our story).

All five were laid over after the Nov. 9 hearing, our records show. An agenda listing does not guarantee a vote.

The timing

City Limits has reported that the Council has 30 days after a Planning Commission nomination is formally submitted to act on it. The nominations were referred to the committee Oct. 22, which points to about Nov. 21. Thursday's 1:30 p.m. stated meeting is the last one scheduled before then. The committee, chaired by Sandra Ung, meets at 250 Broadway. Its members are Shaun Abreu, Chris Banks, David M. Carr, Elsie Encarnación, Shekar Krishnan, Linda Lee, Kevin C. Riley and Nantasha M. Williams, according to the agenda.

What's next

  • Thursday: the committee can vote on the four remaining Planning nominees and King; any it approves could reach the full Council that afternoon.
  • Later: the mayor says he will resubmit Stein's nomination "in the near future." He gave no date.

The video and transcript of the Nov. 9 hearing are on our meeting page.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime