On My Block · NYC Politics

ImmigrationLegislation

Amended ICE detainer bills would drop the city's 'violent or serious crime' exception. They get a hearing Friday after three earlier rounds stalled

Int. 1077-A and 1078-A would let the NYPD and the Correction Department honor a civil immigration detainer only with a judge's warrant for a purpose unrelated to immigration. The Council's analysts estimate no cost. Earlier versions were filed in 2021, 2022 and 2024.

The City Council's Committee on Immigration meets at 10 a.m. Friday, Nov. 20, for an oversight hearing on immigration enforcement in the city. On its agenda are two bills from the committee's chair, Elsie Encarnación, that were rewritten this month: Int. 1077-A, on the NYPD, and Int. 1078-A, on the Department of Correction.

Why it matters to residents: these bills decide what happens when someone in police or jail custody, who would otherwise walk free, is the subject of a federal request to hold them for immigration agents.

This follows our Nov. 12 story on the hearing and a state deadline for local detainer agreements.

What city law says now

According to the current law text shown in the bills (language the amendments would delete is bracketed), the NYPD and the Correction Department may hold someone past their release time on a civil immigration detainer only when federal agents bring a judicial warrant and a database search shows the person has been convicted of a "violent or serious crime" from a long list in the law, or is a possible match on the federal terrorist watch list.

What the amended bills change

The proposed texts, dated Nov. 9 and posted to Legistar with plain-language summaries, would:

  • strike the "violent or serious crime" list and the terrorist-watch-list exception from both laws;
  • allow a detainer to be honored only if federal agents present a warrant from a federal judge or magistrate and the warrant is "for a law enforcement purpose not related to immigration enforcement";
  • say outright that an administrative warrant signed by an immigration agent will not be honored;
  • for the NYPD, extend the same limits to officers spending on-duty time or department resources communicating with immigration agents or helping transfer someone to their custody;
  • for the Correction Department, bar staff from sharing information such as release dates and court dates in response to federal immigration inquiries, and from transporting anyone into federal custody for civil immigration enforcement.

Both would take effect 60 days after becoming law. The Council's Finance Division estimates no cost for either, saying the agencies would use existing resources. The Office of Management and Budget did not provide an estimate.

A long line of earlier versions

The bills' own drafting notes list predecessors: Int. 2352 and 2351 in 2021, Int. 184 and 185 in 2022, and Int. 395 and 396 in 2024. None became law. The current versions were introduced Sept. 24. Int. 1077-A lists 20 Council sponsors and Int. 1078-A lists 21 plus Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, according to the proposed texts.

The other items

  • Int. 739, from Shahana K. Hanif: agencies would train employees and contractors on the city's limits on helping immigration enforcement and publish their protocols.
  • Res. 729, from Public Advocate Williams: backs the state BUILD Act, on immigrant legal defense.

The backdrop

  • A federal judge on Nov. 6 ordered the city to answer an ICE subpoena for records on residents of a Bronx shelter, with a special master screening the list, Latin Times reported. The judge gave the parties 14 days to propose how the special master would be appointed and paid, which points to about Friday.
  • Under the state's Local Cops, Local Crimes Act, local agreements to hold people for immigration authorities solely on civil violations must end; any still in place after Nov. 25 are void, according to the same report.
  • At the Rules Committee's Nov. 9 hearing, the Council's Board of Correction nominee, Martha King, told Minority Leader David M. Carr she would not support changing local law to let the Correction Department cooperate with ICE detainers, as we reported.

What's next

Friday's meeting is a hearing; an agenda listing does not mean a vote. The amended bills would need a committee vote, then the full Council, then the mayor's signature or 30 days without action. The Council's next stated meeting is Dec. 3.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime