On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilStated Meeting

Council passes surveillance pricing ban 44-5, veterans tax break 49-0 and new property tax rates 41-8

The roll calls from Thursday's stated meeting are now posted on Legistar. Six bills head to Mayor Zohran Mamdani, and Studio 54's rebuild won final approval.

The City Council on Thursday, Nov. 12, passed Speaker Julie Menin's ban on surveillance pricing 44-5, voted 49-0 to fully exempt the homes of permanently and totally disabled veterans from city property tax, and adopted this year's amended property tax rates 41-8, according to the roll calls posted on the Council's Legistar site by Friday morning.

Two members, Kamillah Hanks and Darlene Mealy, were recorded absent on every roll call. Every item put to a final vote passed.

Why it matters to residents: six bills now go to Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who has 30 days to sign or veto them. The tax vote sets what one- to three-family homeowners and commercial owners pay for the year that began July 1.

A note on the record: the Council held Thursday's meeting under a new Legistar meeting number. The meeting we linked in our preview now reads "This record no longer exists" on Legistar. The votes are filed under meeting 22860.

The contested votes

  • Surveillance pricing, Int. 891-A, 44-5. Joann Ariola, David M. Carr, Frank Morano, Vickie Paladino and Inna Vernikov voted no. The bill bars businesses from using algorithms and personal data to charge different customers different prices for the same thing, starting one year after it becomes law. Our story has what it allows and bans.
  • Property tax rates, Res. 723 through 726, 41-8 each. The same five voted no, joined by Simcha Felder, Phil Wong and Susan Zhuang. The resolutions lower the cap on how fast any class's share of the tax can grow to 0.3% and reset the rates: 19.972% for one- to three-family homes and 10.859% for commercial property. Our story compares the roll call with June's.

The unanimous votes

All of these passed 49-0, most on the consent roll call:

  • Int. 1051-A, from Morano: a full property tax exemption on the primary home of veterans the VA rates permanently and totally disabled by service. The final fiscal note cut the cost estimate to $5.1 million a year, from $12.9 million (our story).
  • Int. 488-A, from Vernikov: an annual housing department report on veterans applying for and getting Mitchell-Lama apartments under the veterans preference.
  • Int. 928-A, from Carr, the minority leader: a permanent LGBTQ+ liaison at the Department of Veterans' Services.
  • Int. 178-A, from Harvey D. Epstein: a liaison, a website and data collection for owners converting offices and other buildings into housing (our story).
  • Int. 202-A, from Jennifer Gutiérrez: deadlines for the Department of Transportation to install safety measures outside schools (our story).
  • Res. 737 and 738, approving the Studio 54 zoning change and special permit in Carl Wilson's district, and Res. 736, correcting open space maps in the Special South Richmond Development District (our story).
  • M 101, from Wong, calling up a sidewalk cafe application at 60-01 70th Ave. in Ridgewood for Council review.

Two resolutions passed by voice vote: Res. 163-A, from Nantasha M. Williams, naming the fourth week of November "The Shangri-Las Week," and Res. 560, from Paladino, asking Congress to let veterans use VA-backed loans for co-ops.

What went back or was put off

The Council formally approved the two Forest Hills rezonings, at 108-05 68th Road and 100-12 Queens Boulevard, with changes and sent them back to the City Planning Commission, as its Land Use Committee recommended Tuesday. They return for a final vote after the commission acts.

The Council's pick for the Board of Correction, Martha King (M 100), was referred to the Rules Committee, which takes up her appointment and the mayor's five Planning Commission nominees on Thursday, Nov. 19.

Before the votes

Menin opened her pre-meeting news conference with a moment of silence for the eight people killed in Wednesday's building collapse on Flatbush Avenue, in Farah N. Louis's district (our story). She also highlighted a new bill from Louis on vacant rent-stabilized apartments, one of dozens introduced Thursday.

What's next

The new bills join seven others from Oct. 22 that are still on the mayor's desk (our tally). The video of the stated meeting had not been posted to our meeting page Friday morning. The full Council meets next on Thursday, Nov. 19, at 1:30 p.m.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime