On My Block · NYC Politics

FlatbushBuildings

Flatbush collapse kills eight next to an excavation site; a Council bill on stop-work inspections has had no hearing

The city had halted demolition on the neighboring lot in March. Int. 1039, introduced Sept. 10, would make inspectors return every two weeks to such sites.

Eight people, two of them children, were killed Wednesday, Nov. 11, when a three-story apartment building at 1321 Flatbush Ave. collapsed into a neighboring lot where workers were excavating for a new building, according to the Fire Department's count reported by 6sqft and CBS New York. At least 17 people were hurt, including firefighters.

The building, near Bedford Avenue in Flatbush, is in the district of Council Member Farah N. Louis. The Fire Department ended its search Thursday afternoon. The Buildings Department and the police are investigating the cause, and Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez has opened a criminal investigation, according to 6sqft.

Why it matters to residents: the Buildings Department had stopped work on the neighboring lot earlier this year over missing protections for adjacent buildings. A bill pending at the Council since Sept. 10 would change how the department follows up on stop-work orders.

What the record shows about the site

The Buildings Department issued a stop-work order on the neighboring lot in March, during demolition of a one-story building, because required protections such as netting and sheds were missing, a department spokesperson told Gothamist. In April, an inspector found demolition had continued in violation of the order and issued another penalty, Gothamist reported. The order was lifted in May after the department found the conditions corrected, 6sqft reported.

The developers held an active permit for excavation and foundation work. Plans filed in September for a nine-story building had not been approved, Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said, according to Gothamist.

The collapsed building itself had open housing code violations. Gothamist counted 98 open violations, including unsafe wiring and missing smoke detectors; a tenant organizer cited 61 open violations from the housing department, 6sqft reported. Whether either set of conditions contributed has not been determined.

What officials have said

"A tragedy of this magnitude demands a comprehensive and thorough investigation."

Mayor Zohran Mamdani, as reported by Gothamist, Nov. 12

Mamdani said the Buildings Department was "commencing sweeps" of sites tied to the companies involved, about 100 properties, Gothamist reported. The city and the Red Cross opened a reception center for affected residents at the Flatbush YMCA, 1401 Flatbush Ave., 6sqft reported.

Speaker Julie Menin opened Thursday's pre-meeting news conference with a moment of silence. "Council Member Farah Louis represents that community, and I've been in close touch with her as her office remains on the ground," Menin said, according to her prepared remarks.

What the Council has on file

Int. 1039, from Ty Hankerson, would require the Buildings Department to inspect sites with major renovations that are under a stop-work order at least once every two weeks until the problem is fixed. Each visit would include an inspector from the unit that issued the order and at least two from related units, according to the bill's summary. It has 12 sponsors and was referred to the Committee on Housing and Buildings, chaired by Pierina Ana Sanchez. Our records show no hearing.

The bill is written for "major renovations," and it is not clear from the text whether it would reach a demolition and excavation job like the one on Flatbush Avenue. The record does not show what inspections followed the March order beyond the April penalty.

Sanchez sponsored the 2024 law, passed after the partial collapse of a Bronx building on Billingsley Terrace, that requires the department to run a proactive structural inspection program, PoliticsNY reported at the time.

What happens next

Our records showed no bill introduced in response to the collapse as of Friday morning, and no hearing scheduled on it. The Committee on Housing and Buildings meets Tuesday, Nov. 17, on homeownership, and on Friday, Nov. 20, with the Fire and Emergency Management Committee for an oversight hearing on residential fires.

The mayor's office has directed people who want to help to the Mayor's Fund to Advance New York City's emergency relief fund, 6sqft reported.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime