On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilConsumer Protection

Surveillance pricing ban passes 44-5: what Int. 891-A bans, what it allows and when it starts

Five members voted no. Fines run up to $1,000 per customer or sale, a first offense can be fixed within 30 days, and the ban starts a year after it becomes law.

The City Council on Thursday, Nov. 12, passed Speaker Julie Menin's ban on surveillance pricing, 44-5, barring businesses from using algorithms and customers' personal data to charge different people different prices for the same goods or services.

Joann Ariola, David M. Carr, Frank Morano, Vickie Paladino and Inna Vernikov voted no, and Kamillah Hanks and Darlene Mealy were absent, according to the roll call on Legistar. The bill, Int. 891-A, takes effect one year after it becomes law.

Why it matters to residents: the bill covers online and in-store prices for goods and services sold in the city. It does not ban sales, coupons or loyalty discounts that are offered openly to everyone who qualifies.

"When corporations use algorithms and personal data to charge different people different prices for the same products, it's unethical and worsens our affordability crisis."

Speaker Julie Menin, Council release, Nov. 12

Mayor Zohran Mamdani said, "When corporations use your personal data to decide what you pay, you only stand to lose," City & State reported. Companies including Uber, whose services the bill covers, have opposed it, the outlet reported.

What it bans

The bill defines surveillance pricing as prices "set completely or in part by an algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods or services." No business may set or adjust a listed price, or the price a customer pays, that way.

A business that uses personal data for discounts must keep procedures letting customers ask what data was considered and how, and must hand those records to the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection on request.

What it still allows

The amended bill spells out discounts that remain legal, as long as they are offered the same way to everyone who meets the posted terms:

  • Sales, flash sales, end-of-season sales, bulk and subscription pricing, price matching and rebates, if available without using personal data.
  • Loyalty and rewards program discounts for people who sign up, including tiers based on past purchases, if that purchase history is not combined with other personal data.
  • Discounts for groups a customer chooses to identify with, such as veterans, active duty service members, seniors, teachers or employees, or birthday discounts.
  • On online marketplaces, some discounts based only on a customer's purchase history, including one-time discounts for new customers and delivery fee discounts.

The bill does not apply to insurance, credit decisions based on credit reports, or prices required or expressly authorized by federal or state law. Pricing by securities brokers and investment advisers based on assets or account relationships is also excluded.

Penalties

Violations carry civil penalties of up to $1,000 each, and each consumer or transaction counts separately. The city can also seek restitution and damages for customers.

For a first violation, the department must notify a business before bringing a case. The business then has 30 days to show it has fixed the problem and repaid affected customers. Menin said in her pre-meeting remarks that the provision was meant "to protect small businesses."

What it costs

The Finance Division's fiscal note estimates $356,258 a year for four new positions at the consumer protection department: an attorney, two investigators and a community associate. The first, partial year would cost $207,818.

How it got here

Menin introduced the bill May 14. The Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, chaired by Harvey D. Epstein, approved the amended version 10-0 Thursday morning, with Ariola among the yes votes. Ariola then voted no at the full Council. The roll call does not say why.

The state Legislature has passed its own ban, the One Fair Price Act, which awaits Gov. Kathy Hochul's signature, City & State reported.

What happens next

The bill goes to the mayor, who has 30 days after it reaches him to act. If it becomes law in December, the ban would start in December 2027.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime