On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilProperty Taxes

Council adopts new property tax rates 41-8: homes drop to 19.972%, commercial rises to 10.859%

Simcha Felder, Phil Wong and Susan Zhuang joined the five members who opposed June's rates. The 0.3% cap shifts about $266 million off small homes.

The City Council on Thursday, Nov. 12, adopted amended property tax rates for the year that began July 1, cutting the rate on one- to three-family homes to 19.972% and raising the commercial rate to 10.859%. Each of the four resolutions passed 41-8, according to the roll calls posted on Legistar.

The resolutions lower this year's cap on how fast any property class's share of the tax can grow, from the 5% in state law to 0.3%. By our calculation from the resolution figures, that moves about $266 million of the $39.9 billion levy off small homes and about $283 million onto commercial property.

Why it matters to residents: the rate is what you pay per dollar of taxable assessed value. Your bill also depends on your assessment and exemptions. A lower rate than June's does not by itself mean a lower bill than last year.

Who voted no

Eight members voted against all four resolutions: Joann Ariola, David M. Carr, Simcha Felder, Frank Morano, Vickie Paladino, Inna Vernikov, Phil Wong and Susan Zhuang. Kamillah Hanks and Darlene Mealy were absent.

That is three more no votes than in June. When the Council first set this year's rates on June 30 (Res. 546), the vote was 46-5: Ariola, Carr, Morano, Paladino and Vernikov voted no. Felder and Wong voted no in June only on the class share certification, which passed 43-7. Zhuang voted yes on both in June, as we reported Thursday.

The roll call does not say why members voted as they did. The stated meeting video had not been posted to our meeting page Friday morning.

Earlier Thursday, the Finance Committee approved the four resolutions 13-2. Morano and Wong voted no; Alexa Avilés and Mealy were absent, according to the committee's minutes.

The rates

The tax-fixing resolution, Res. 726, sets these rates, compared with June's and last year's:

  • Class 1, one- to three-family homes: 19.972%, down from 20.909% in June. Last year: 19.843%.
  • Class 2, apartment buildings, co-ops and condos: 12.423%, down from 12.440%. Last year: 12.439%.
  • Class 3, utilities: 11.119%, up from 11.108%. Last year: 11.108%.
  • Class 4, commercial: 10.859%, up from 10.658%. Last year: 10.848%.

Against June's rate, a home pays about $94 less a year for every $10,000 of taxable assessed value. Commercial property pays about $201 more for every $100,000.

The total levy did not change: $39,885,078,591, the amount the Council set in June.

Why the Council did it

A state law signed Sept. 25 let the Council choose a cap below 5% for this year only, if it acted by Dec. 1. Without a change, the Finance Division's committee report said, the Class 1 rate would have been 5.4% higher than last year's, which, "coupled with assessment increases," would mean "significant increases" in homeowners' bills.

The trade-off is in the shares. Class 4's share of the levy rises from 37.6732% to 38.3834%, while Class 1's falls from 14.8692% to 14.2025%, according to the adopted resolutions.

The four resolutions were sponsored by Finance Chair Linda Lee, who represents parts of eastern Queens. Speaker Julie Menin said before the meeting that they "will set the City of New York's real property tax rates for Fiscal Year 2027," according to her prepared remarks.

What happens next

State law requires the city to recompute bills at the new rates and send amended bills where bills have already gone out. The Department of Finance has not yet said publicly when those will arrive.

Homeowners with questions about their bill can contact the Department of Finance through 311. The Finance and Housing committees hold a joint hearing on homeownership, including a bill on automatic enrollment in property tax payment plans, on Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 11 a.m.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime