On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilImmigration

A Council resolution against ICE staging in private parking lots is set for Nov. 19, the day before the Council's immigration enforcement hearing

Harvey Epstein's resolution follows the mayor's October letter to garage owners and his Nov. 2 threat to sue over ICE parking in city parks. Separately, a state law voids local civil detainer agreements after Nov. 25, and the city has not said whether it will appeal the Bronx shelter subpoena order.

Our records list a new resolution, T2026-2806, for introduction at the Council's Nov. 19 stated meeting. From Harvey D. Epstein, with Alexa Avilés, Shekar Krishnan and Amanda C. Farías, it "opposes the practice of federal immigration authorities using parking facilities as staging locations for enforcement actions anywhere in the five boroughs" and calls on private operators to refuse.

Why it matters to residents: the city's own rules keep federal immigration agents off city property without a judicial warrant, but they do not reach private garages and lots. A resolution would not change that; it would put the Council on record.

This follows our Wednesday story on the Bronx shelter subpoena and the Council's Nov. 20 hearing.

What the resolution cites

The resolution's findings, which are the sponsors' account, list:

  • an April procurement notice from ICE seeking up to 150 parking spaces in Hudson Square, near its Varick Street office;
  • reports that agents used bank parking lots on Northern Boulevard in Queens;
  • a Morton Street garage arrangement in Manhattan that ended in May after residents contacted the company, and protests over suspected ICE parking in a Harrison Street garage in Tribeca in August;
  • the Hudson River Park Trust's parking contract with the Department of Homeland Security, which lapsed at the end of June;
  • the shooting of Oscar Belgal by federal agents in Marble Hill, after which residents said agents had been staging from a nearby private lot.

What the mayor has done

On Oct. 15, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and more than 100 city and state elected officials signed a letter asking garage and lot owners not to rent, lend or allow ICE to use their property. "I am asking every garage and lot owner in this city to stop giving them that option," Mamdani said, the Bronx Times reported. The owner of the Marble Hill lot said it had not known ICE was using it, and Target, a tenant there, said it had no formal agreement with the agency, according to the Bronx Times.

On Nov. 2, Mamdani wrote to Homeland Security and ICE leaders demanding that agents stop using city-owned lots at Van Cortlandt Park and along 111th Street at Flushing Meadows Corona Park, and warning of legal action, amNY reported. A Homeland Security spokesperson said ICE's use of public parking lots is authorized under federal law and standard practice, according to amNY.

The state deadline

Separately, under the state's Local Cops, Local Crimes Act, signed May 27, local governments must end any agreement to hold people for federal immigration authorities solely on civil violations; agreements still in place after Nov. 25 are void, the Latin Times reported. Detention tied to federal criminal charges, court orders or judicial warrants is exempt. At least 15 sheriff's offices have sued over the law, the outlet reported.

The shelter subpoena

As of Thursday morning we found no report that the city had appealed Judge Lewis Kaplan's Nov. 6 order to answer ICE's subpoena for records on residents of the Bruckner shelter in Mott Haven. A city spokesperson had said the administration was "evaluating next steps." Kaplan gave the parties 14 days to propose how the special master who screens the list will be appointed and paid, which points to about Nov. 20.

The Nov. 20 hearing

The Committee on Immigration, chaired by Elsie Encarnación, holds its oversight hearing on immigration enforcement at 10 a.m. Friday, Nov. 20. The agenda lists her two bills limiting NYPD detentions on civil immigration detainers and Correction Department communication with federal immigration authorities, Shahana K. Hanif's training and planning bill, and Res. 729, backing the state BUILD Act on immigrant legal defense. The parking resolution is not on that agenda.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime