Wednesday, March 4, 2026, 11 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 3
Committee: Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises
The Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises, chaired by Council Member Farah Louis, held three public hearings. LU 41 concerns a zoning text amendment at 325 Avenue of the Americas to permit outdoor café seating in a covered through-block galleria (Sixth-and-a-Half Avenue), presented by the applicant's attorney and public affairs advisor, who declined a Community Board 5 request for public restroom signage. LU 42 and 43, presented by NYC Parks, would de-map a portion of the Allen Street mall as right-of-way, map it as parkland to enable a concession with a public restroom, and amend the zoning text to keep Allen Street's wide-street designation. LU 38-40 concerns the 20 Barry Street industrial rezoning and special permit in Williamsburg for a mixed commercial/industrial building; Council Member Restler voiced support while pressing on industrial-space leasing, union jobs, park support, bike safety, and the local BID. No members of the public testified on any item; all three hearings were closed and all items were laid over.
0:12 Good morning everyone good
0:12 morning and welcome to today's
0:13 New York City Council hearing
0:16 for the subcommittee on zoning
0:18 and franchises if you would
0:19 like to testify you must fill
0:21 out an appearance card with
0:23 one of the sergeant at arms in
0:24 the back of the room even if
0:25 you signed up already online
0:26 at this time please silence
0:29 all electronic devices police
0:30 silence all electronic devices
0:32 and no 1 approach a dais at
0:34 any time during this hearing
0:35 chair we are ready to begin
0:40 good morning and welcome t
0:41 othe meeting of the
0:42 subcommittee on zoning and
0:44 franchises I am council Farah
0:46 lewis chair of the
0:48 subcommittee this morning I
0:49 joined by a council members
0:51 car uh Thomas Henry Sanchez
0:57 Justin Sanchez Elsie
0:58 Encarnación Amanda Farías Lynn
1:01 shuman never forget all right
1:04 everybody today we are holding
1:05 three public hearings on the
1:07 following proposals 20 barry
1:09 street and industrial rezoning
1:11 and Council Member wrestlers
1:13 district allan street d
1:14 mapping and Council Member
1:15 marz district and 13 25 avenue
1:19 of the americas tax amendment
1:20 and Council Member district we
1:22 are also scheduled to hear a
1:24 residential rezoning known as
1:27 the hamilton avenue but this
1:28 proposal is laid over and will
1:30 be heard at a future date this
1:32 meeting is being held in
1:35 hybrid format members of the
1:36 public who wish to testify and
1:38 then testify in person or via
1:40 zoom members of the public
1:42 wishing to testify remotely
1:44 register by visiting the New
1:45 York City Council web site at
1:48 www dot dot nyc dot g
1:50 backslash land use to sign up
1:53 or for those of you here in
1:55 person please see one of the
1:57 sergeants at arms to prepare
1:58 and submit a speaker card
2:00 members of the public also
2:01 view a live stream broadcast
2:03 of the meeting at the
2:05 council's website where you
2:06 when you are called to testify
2:07 before the subcommittee if you
2:09 are joining us remotely you
2:11 will remain muted until
2:12 recognized by myself to speak
2:15 when you are recognized your
2:16 microphone will be unm util
2:17 will limit public public
2:18 testimony to two minutes per
2:20 witness if you have additional
2:22 testimony that would like that e
2:25 subcommittee to consider or if
2:27 you have written testimony
2:28 that you would like to submit
2:30 instead of appearing in person e
2:32 testimony at counsel that and
2:35 why the n y c dot gov written
2:38 testimony be submitted up t
2:40 othree days after the hearing
2:42 is closed please indicate the
2:43 l you number and or project
2:46 name in the subject line of
2:47 your email we request that
2:49 witnesses joining us remotely
2:50 remain in the meeting until
2:52 excused by the chair as
2:54 council members have questions e
2:57 attending today's meeting this
2:58 is a government proceeding and
3:00 decorum must be observed at
3:03 all times members of th
3:04 epublic are acts to not speak
3:06 during the meeting unless you
3:08 are testifying the witness
3:10 table is reserved for people
3:11 who are called to testify and
3:14 no video recording or
3:15 photography is allowed from
3:19 the witness table
3:20 . Further members of the
3:21 public not present audio or
3:24 video recordings as testimony
3:26 but submit transcripts of such
3:29 recordings at this to the
3:31 sergeant at arms for inclusion
3:32 in the hearing record
3:34 . I will now open the public
3:36 hearing on lewd number 41
3:40 regarding 325 avenue u of the
3:42 avenue of the americas text
3:45 amendment proposal in midtown
3:47 manhattan and council
3:49 maloney's district the
3:49 proposal is from an existing
3:52 restaurant located next to the
3:53 next to a covered public
3:55 passageway known as the
3:57 galleria and the restaurant is
3:59 seeking to legalize its
4:02 outdoor cafe seating in the
4:04 galleria the galleria in
4:05 question is the covered public
4:08 passageway known as six and a
4:12 half avenues mid block between
4:15 sixth seventh avenues
4:16 currently outdoor cafe seating
4:17 is not allowed in such
4:20 passageways for anyone wishing
4:21 to testify regarding this
4:22 proposal remotely if you have
4:24 not already done so you must
4:26 register online by visiting
4:27 the council's website at
4:30 counsel dot land use for
4:33 anyone with us in person
4:34 please see one of our sergeant
4:36 at arms to submit a speaker
4:37 card if you prefer to submit
4:39 written testimony you can
4:41 always do so by emailing it t
4:43 olanos testimony at counsel dot
4:48 first fine we've been joined
5:03 by council members salam and
5:05 Felder I now call the
5:07 applicant panel for this
5:09 proposal which consists of neo
5:11 weissberg and travis terry
5:14 counsel please administer the
5:17 affirmation good morning could
5:17 you please raise your right
5:18 hand and state your name for
5:21 the record
5:21 . Neil weisberg travis terry
5:24 do you swear to dove open
5:26 nothing that you swear t
5:28 odelhi to tell the truth for
5:30 nothing but the truth in your
5:31 testimony this morning and
5:32 your response to council
5:34 member questions I do thank
5:36 you you begin we also had a
5:38 powerpoint oh okay great swipe
5:41 the unscored okay good good
5:42 good morning chair lewis
5:44 councilmembers my name is neil
5:45 weisberg of the law firm seif
5:47 r shah and I appear before you
5:48 on behalf of La grande boo
5:50 zuri who operates a restaurant
5:54 within 325 avenue of the
5:56 americas three block galleria
5:58 next slide please.
6:02 The site is located between
6:03 west 53 and west 54 stree
6:08 tapproximately mid mid block in
6:10 a there is a through block
6:13 galleria and the galleria was
6:15 part of a floor area increase
6:18 to construct the 35 storey
6:19 office building on the site in
6:21 19 90 this all occurred the
6:25 part of the galleria which is
6:26 6800 square feet however in 1
6:34 996 City planning commission
6:35 amended the text of the zoning
6:37 resolution and it does not
6:38 grant any bonuses for three
6:41 block galerias and any of the
6:43 regulations that regulated
6:44 through black galleries were
6:46 amended and and removed and
6:48 under the current zoning
6:51 resolution open air cafes or
6:52 tables and chairs for
6:54 accessory restaurants within
6:54 privately owned public spaces
6:57 are only permitted in areas
6:58 that are open to the sky and a
7:01 three block galleria has it
7:03 covered roof and therefore a
7:05 text amendment is required t
7:07 oallow these within the privatec
7:10 spaces there are only two
7:12 other sites that are subject
7:13 to this text amendment there
7:15 both within six and a half
7:17 avenue one is at 1 35 west 2
7:20 0west 52 street and one is at
7:22 12 85 avenue of the americas
7:24 and it's important important
7:25 to note that if a restaurant
7:28 within those other public
7:30 three block galerias they
7:31 would need to seek City
7:33 planning certification as is
7:34 the case with our application
7:35 as well we are concurrently
7:37 seeking the certification from
7:40 City planning next slide
7:42 please and next slide please
7:44 so the proposed action will
7:46 permit an open air cafe
7:48 totaling about 1080 squar
7:51 efeet they will contain 5
7:53 7tables and 114 chairs most of
7:56 them adjacent to La grande boo e
8:00 north side of the plan and
8:03 then a there will be fiv
8:05 etables in front of the kaiseki
8:08 room restaurant which is
8:08 located on the south of the
8:10 through block galleria next
8:15 slide please.
8:16 Although this is not subject
8:18 to your approval the also
8:20 seeks a modification to the
8:22 original certification from 19
8:27 90 and also will institute
8:29 numerous improvements t
8:30 othrough black galleria
8:33 including movable planters
8:35 benches trash receptacles heat
8:37 lamps lighting fits features
8:39 and New decorative pavement
8:40 next slide please.
8:43 So this picture really tells
8:45 the story of how this through
8:47 block gallery has changed on
8:49 the left is before La grande
8:52 boo began operating within the
8:55 three block galleria when they
8:55 took hold of the spaces as
8:56 tenant they did all these
8:58 major improvements including
9:00 the beautiful wood paneling
9:01 and the chandeliers and the
9:04 decorative payment
9:04 . So they made a real
9:06 improvement to this site the
9:10 three block galleria before
9:11 legrain boo removed moved in
9:12 was really unused and
9:15 neglected and now it's an
9:17 active lively and vastly
9:18 improved space next slide
9:20 please
9:21 . This is the text amendment
9:22 that we are requesting and the
9:24 areas of text amendment are
9:27 underlined and basically it
9:28 just states that open air
9:30 cafes now can seek a
9:31 certification from City
9:35 planning and that certain
9:37 obstructions are permitted
9:38 including movable planters and
9:40 the fact that an open air cafe
9:42 does not need to be opened t
9:44 othe sky the City planning
9:46 unanimously approved the
9:48 application community board
9:50 five was in favor of the
9:52 application provided there was
9:54 signage that indicated that
9:55 the restrooms could be used by
9:57 the public by the public and
10:00 I'm going to ask travis t
10:02 oexplain that that this has
10:03 been discussed and we
10:04 discussed this the City
10:06 planning was not in favor of
10:07 this request and approve the
10:09 application unanimously and
10:10 I'll hand it over to travis t
10:12 oaddress the community board
10:15 five's concerns.
10:15 Thank you neal and thank you e
10:19 members of the City Council on
10:20 travis terry I serve as a
10:22 public affairs advisor to the
10:24 applicant um just a quick
10:25 thing on the restrooms which
10:27 was brought up by manhattan
10:28 manhattan commuter board to to
10:30 say that we do appreciate and
10:32 acknowledge manhattan
10:32 community board five's request
10:34 to post signage regarding
10:36 public restroom access at the
10:37 restaurant we did give this
10:39 request some thought some
10:41 thoughtful internal
10:42 consideration however after
10:45 careful discussion though we
10:47 are always willing to allow
10:48 non patrons access to the
10:50 bathrooms upon requests it's
10:51 our practice today we did not
10:54 feel comfortable movement
10:55 adding the signage at this
10:57 point are team x when we
10:59 talked to staff the staff
11:01 expressed some significant
11:03 concerns relative to safety
11:03 and operational impact
11:05 specifically public restroom
11:06 signage can encourage
11:07 individuals who are not
11:08 patrons to enter the
11:09 restaurant are bathrooms are
11:11 internal into the into the
11:12 restaurant they're not
11:14 external um but we but we did
11:16 not want patrons enter the
11:17 restaurant solely to use the
11:19 facilities which as as I noted
11:22 our staff felt could have some
11:24 safety concerns and for the
11:25 patrons of the
11:28 . Restaurant additionally
11:29 broadly promoting the restroom
11:30 availability could attract
11:32 some increased foot traffic
11:33 traffic that we're not the
11:34 restaurant just simply is not
11:37 equipped to manage as you know n
11:41 today's environment is quite
11:43 challenging and managing the
11:45 access beyond our current
11:46 practice of permitting upon
11:47 request bathroom access could
11:49 create some additional some
11:50 additional staffing and
11:51 monitoring and maintenance
11:52 burdens that could be costly
11:53 and difficult to sustain um
11:55 with that.
11:55 Just one thing I want t
11:56 onote as well this study as I
11:59 mentioned requires a
11:59 certification from City
12:01 planning and that
12:02 certification is required
12:02 every three years
12:04 . And we're here to answer any
12:05 questions yes thank you that's
12:06 the end of your presentation
12:08 yes.
12:08 All right thank you
12:09 . So I have a couple of
12:11 questions and then I'll open
12:12 it up to my colleagues ah you
12:14 mentioned one other galleria
12:16 in the area but I wanted t
12:18 oknow how many galleries exist
12:19 in manhattan or elsewhere that
12:23 now qualify to have outdoor
12:24 cafe seating in the galleria
12:26 so right now none qualify ok.
12:28 As far as we know there's
12:29 only two other
12:30 . Locations through this six
12:31 and a half avenue all right
12:36 beyond signage what design
12:37 measures are you proposing t
12:40 omake sure the public is aware
12:42 that the gallery remains open
12:43 and accessible to the public.
12:44 So there is signage at each
12:48 entrance indicating that this
12:49 is a publicly accessible
12:51 privately owned space your
12:53 typical pop signage is at both
12:55 entrances on west 53 and west
12:57 54 street but what design
12:58 measures what are the designs
13:01 . Like what are the design
13:03 measures
13:04 . That were the improvements
13:06 that we're seeking or the
13:08 signage this De signage is
13:10 we're not anticipating any
13:17 other.
13:17 To improve the public's
13:19 access to the spates regarding
13:21 the design so there's the
13:22 signage part which you've
13:23 answered that question but
13:24 we're talking about the design
13:27 part
13:27 . For the the slide might
13:28 slide might help because it
13:29 tgalleria that's not going to
13:34 change that's going to.
13:35 Be permanent
13:36 . It's just the restaurant
13:38 only can is only a portion of
13:40 it I got it and
13:41 . During the City planning
13:43 certification process t
13:44 oapprove open air cafes in
13:46 probably in public spaces
13:47 there's certain minimum with
13:48 requirements so the public has
13:49 access from each eugen and we
13:51 comply with all of.
13:53 Those and we've the
13:55 restaurant is also invested in
13:56 the space with the building
13:57 owner to make sure that it's
13:59 more beautiful and more
14:02 acceptable days having
14:03 completely transformed if I
14:04 can bring up that other
14:05 . Photo again trump that slide
14:06 of the before and after okay
14:08 hmm thank you
14:10 . Do any of my colleagues have
14:13 questions.
14:13 Council Member in knesset hi o
14:17 . I know you mentioned that
14:19 the community board was
14:22 opposed because of the
14:25 restrooms that seems like the
14:26 borough president as well
14:27 . The borough president
14:30 approved with a with a
14:30 condition that we look at the
14:33 potential rest signage for the
14:35 public restrooms
14:35 . And so that would still be a
14:37 no for for for that even
14:39 though this is a public space
14:40 the seating would only be for
14:43 people that are using the
14:46 restaurant right the restrooms
14:47 are currently available upon