Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises

Wednesday, March 4, 2026, 11 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 3

Committee: Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises, chaired by Council Member Farah Louis, held three public hearings. LU 41 concerns a zoning text amendment at 325 Avenue of the Americas to permit outdoor café seating in a covered through-block galleria (Sixth-and-a-Half Avenue), presented by the applicant's attorney and public affairs advisor, who declined a Community Board 5 request for public restroom signage. LU 42 and 43, presented by NYC Parks, would de-map a portion of the Allen Street mall as right-of-way, map it as parkland to enable a concession with a public restroom, and amend the zoning text to keep Allen Street's wide-street designation. LU 38-40 concerns the 20 Barry Street industrial rezoning and special permit in Williamsburg for a mixed commercial/industrial building; Council Member Restler voiced support while pressing on industrial-space leasing, union jobs, park support, bike safety, and the local BID. No members of the public testified on any item; all three hearings were closed and all items were laid over.

Transcript

0:12 Good morning everyone good

0:12 morning and welcome to today's

0:13 New York City Council hearing

0:16 for the subcommittee on zoning

0:18 and franchises if you would

0:19 like to testify you must fill

0:21 out an appearance card with

0:23 one of the sergeant at arms in

0:24 the back of the room even if

0:25 you signed up already online

0:26 at this time please silence

0:29 all electronic devices police

0:30 silence all electronic devices

0:32 and no 1 approach a dais at

0:34 any time during this hearing

0:35 chair we are ready to begin

0:40 good morning and welcome t

0:41 othe meeting of the

0:42 subcommittee on zoning and

0:44 franchises I am council Farah

0:46 lewis chair of the

0:48 subcommittee this morning I

0:49 joined by a council members

0:51 car uh Thomas Henry Sanchez

0:57 Justin Sanchez Elsie

0:58 Encarnación Amanda Farías Lynn

1:01 shuman never forget all right

1:04 everybody today we are holding

1:05 three public hearings on the

1:07 following proposals 20 barry

1:09 street and industrial rezoning

1:11 and Council Member wrestlers

1:13 district allan street d

1:14 mapping and Council Member

1:15 marz district and 13 25 avenue

1:19 of the americas tax amendment

1:20 and Council Member district we

1:22 are also scheduled to hear a

1:24 residential rezoning known as

1:27 the hamilton avenue but this

1:28 proposal is laid over and will

1:30 be heard at a future date this

1:32 meeting is being held in

1:35 hybrid format members of the

1:36 public who wish to testify and

1:38 then testify in person or via

1:40 zoom members of the public

1:42 wishing to testify remotely

1:44 register by visiting the New

1:45 York City Council web site at

1:48 www dot dot nyc dot g

1:50 backslash land use to sign up

1:53 or for those of you here in

1:55 person please see one of the

1:57 sergeants at arms to prepare

1:58 and submit a speaker card

2:00 members of the public also

2:01 view a live stream broadcast

2:03 of the meeting at the

2:05 council's website where you

2:06 when you are called to testify

2:07 before the subcommittee if you

2:09 are joining us remotely you

2:11 will remain muted until

2:12 recognized by myself to speak

2:15 when you are recognized your

2:16 microphone will be unm util

2:17 will limit public public

2:18 testimony to two minutes per

2:20 witness if you have additional

2:22 testimony that would like that e

2:25 subcommittee to consider or if

2:27 you have written testimony

2:28 that you would like to submit

2:30 instead of appearing in person e

2:32 testimony at counsel that and

2:35 why the n y c dot gov written

2:38 testimony be submitted up t

2:40 othree days after the hearing

2:42 is closed please indicate the

2:43 l you number and or project

2:46 name in the subject line of

2:47 your email we request that

2:49 witnesses joining us remotely

2:50 remain in the meeting until

2:52 excused by the chair as

2:54 council members have questions e

2:57 attending today's meeting this

2:58 is a government proceeding and

3:00 decorum must be observed at

3:03 all times members of th

3:04 epublic are acts to not speak

3:06 during the meeting unless you

3:08 are testifying the witness

3:10 table is reserved for people

3:11 who are called to testify and

3:14 no video recording or

3:15 photography is allowed from

3:19 the witness table

3:20 . Further members of the

3:21 public not present audio or

3:24 video recordings as testimony

3:26 but submit transcripts of such

3:29 recordings at this to the

3:31 sergeant at arms for inclusion

3:32 in the hearing record

3:34 . I will now open the public

3:36 hearing on lewd number 41

3:40 regarding 325 avenue u of the

3:42 avenue of the americas text

3:45 amendment proposal in midtown

3:47 manhattan and council

3:49 maloney's district the

3:49 proposal is from an existing

3:52 restaurant located next to the

3:53 next to a covered public

3:55 passageway known as the

3:57 galleria and the restaurant is

3:59 seeking to legalize its

4:02 outdoor cafe seating in the

4:04 galleria the galleria in

4:05 question is the covered public

4:08 passageway known as six and a

4:12 half avenues mid block between

4:15 sixth seventh avenues

4:16 currently outdoor cafe seating

4:17 is not allowed in such

4:20 passageways for anyone wishing

4:21 to testify regarding this

4:22 proposal remotely if you have

4:24 not already done so you must

4:26 register online by visiting

4:27 the council's website at

4:30 counsel dot land use for

4:33 anyone with us in person

4:34 please see one of our sergeant

4:36 at arms to submit a speaker

4:37 card if you prefer to submit

4:39 written testimony you can

4:41 always do so by emailing it t

4:43 olanos testimony at counsel dot

4:48 first fine we've been joined

5:03 by council members salam and

5:05 Felder I now call the

5:07 applicant panel for this

5:09 proposal which consists of neo

5:11 weissberg and travis terry

5:14 counsel please administer the

5:17 affirmation good morning could

5:17 you please raise your right

5:18 hand and state your name for

5:21 the record

5:21 . Neil weisberg travis terry

5:24 do you swear to dove open

5:26 nothing that you swear t

5:28 odelhi to tell the truth for

5:30 nothing but the truth in your

5:31 testimony this morning and

5:32 your response to council

5:34 member questions I do thank

5:36 you you begin we also had a

5:38 powerpoint oh okay great swipe

5:41 the unscored okay good good

5:42 good morning chair lewis

5:44 councilmembers my name is neil

5:45 weisberg of the law firm seif

5:47 r shah and I appear before you

5:48 on behalf of La grande boo

5:50 zuri who operates a restaurant

5:54 within 325 avenue of the

5:56 americas three block galleria

5:58 next slide please.

6:02 The site is located between

6:03 west 53 and west 54 stree

6:08 tapproximately mid mid block in

6:10 a there is a through block

6:13 galleria and the galleria was

6:15 part of a floor area increase

6:18 to construct the 35 storey

6:19 office building on the site in

6:21 19 90 this all occurred the

6:25 part of the galleria which is

6:26 6800 square feet however in 1

6:34 996 City planning commission

6:35 amended the text of the zoning

6:37 resolution and it does not

6:38 grant any bonuses for three

6:41 block galerias and any of the

6:43 regulations that regulated

6:44 through black galleries were

6:46 amended and and removed and

6:48 under the current zoning

6:51 resolution open air cafes or

6:52 tables and chairs for

6:54 accessory restaurants within

6:54 privately owned public spaces

6:57 are only permitted in areas

6:58 that are open to the sky and a

7:01 three block galleria has it

7:03 covered roof and therefore a

7:05 text amendment is required t

7:07 oallow these within the privatec

7:10 spaces there are only two

7:12 other sites that are subject

7:13 to this text amendment there

7:15 both within six and a half

7:17 avenue one is at 1 35 west 2

7:20 0west 52 street and one is at

7:22 12 85 avenue of the americas

7:24 and it's important important

7:25 to note that if a restaurant

7:28 within those other public

7:30 three block galerias they

7:31 would need to seek City

7:33 planning certification as is

7:34 the case with our application

7:35 as well we are concurrently

7:37 seeking the certification from

7:40 City planning next slide

7:42 please and next slide please

7:44 so the proposed action will

7:46 permit an open air cafe

7:48 totaling about 1080 squar

7:51 efeet they will contain 5

7:53 7tables and 114 chairs most of

7:56 them adjacent to La grande boo e

8:00 north side of the plan and

8:03 then a there will be fiv

8:05 etables in front of the kaiseki

8:08 room restaurant which is

8:08 located on the south of the

8:10 through block galleria next

8:15 slide please.

8:16 Although this is not subject

8:18 to your approval the also

8:20 seeks a modification to the

8:22 original certification from 19

8:27 90 and also will institute

8:29 numerous improvements t

8:30 othrough black galleria

8:33 including movable planters

8:35 benches trash receptacles heat

8:37 lamps lighting fits features

8:39 and New decorative pavement

8:40 next slide please.

8:43 So this picture really tells

8:45 the story of how this through

8:47 block gallery has changed on

8:49 the left is before La grande

8:52 boo began operating within the

8:55 three block galleria when they

8:55 took hold of the spaces as

8:56 tenant they did all these

8:58 major improvements including

9:00 the beautiful wood paneling

9:01 and the chandeliers and the

9:04 decorative payment

9:04 . So they made a real

9:06 improvement to this site the

9:10 three block galleria before

9:11 legrain boo removed moved in

9:12 was really unused and

9:15 neglected and now it's an

9:17 active lively and vastly

9:18 improved space next slide

9:20 please

9:21 . This is the text amendment

9:22 that we are requesting and the

9:24 areas of text amendment are

9:27 underlined and basically it

9:28 just states that open air

9:30 cafes now can seek a

9:31 certification from City

9:35 planning and that certain

9:37 obstructions are permitted

9:38 including movable planters and

9:40 the fact that an open air cafe

9:42 does not need to be opened t

9:44 othe sky the City planning

9:46 unanimously approved the

9:48 application community board

9:50 five was in favor of the

9:52 application provided there was

9:54 signage that indicated that

9:55 the restrooms could be used by

9:57 the public by the public and

10:00 I'm going to ask travis t

10:02 oexplain that that this has

10:03 been discussed and we

10:04 discussed this the City

10:06 planning was not in favor of

10:07 this request and approve the

10:09 application unanimously and

10:10 I'll hand it over to travis t

10:12 oaddress the community board

10:15 five's concerns.

10:15 Thank you neal and thank you e

10:19 members of the City Council on

10:20 travis terry I serve as a

10:22 public affairs advisor to the

10:24 applicant um just a quick

10:25 thing on the restrooms which

10:27 was brought up by manhattan

10:28 manhattan commuter board to to

10:30 say that we do appreciate and

10:32 acknowledge manhattan

10:32 community board five's request

10:34 to post signage regarding

10:36 public restroom access at the

10:37 restaurant we did give this

10:39 request some thought some

10:41 thoughtful internal

10:42 consideration however after

10:45 careful discussion though we

10:47 are always willing to allow

10:48 non patrons access to the

10:50 bathrooms upon requests it's

10:51 our practice today we did not

10:54 feel comfortable movement

10:55 adding the signage at this

10:57 point are team x when we

10:59 talked to staff the staff

11:01 expressed some significant

11:03 concerns relative to safety

11:03 and operational impact

11:05 specifically public restroom

11:06 signage can encourage

11:07 individuals who are not

11:08 patrons to enter the

11:09 restaurant are bathrooms are

11:11 internal into the into the

11:12 restaurant they're not

11:14 external um but we but we did

11:16 not want patrons enter the

11:17 restaurant solely to use the

11:19 facilities which as as I noted

11:22 our staff felt could have some

11:24 safety concerns and for the

11:25 patrons of the

11:28 . Restaurant additionally

11:29 broadly promoting the restroom

11:30 availability could attract

11:32 some increased foot traffic

11:33 traffic that we're not the

11:34 restaurant just simply is not

11:37 equipped to manage as you know n

11:41 today's environment is quite

11:43 challenging and managing the

11:45 access beyond our current

11:46 practice of permitting upon

11:47 request bathroom access could

11:49 create some additional some

11:50 additional staffing and

11:51 monitoring and maintenance

11:52 burdens that could be costly

11:53 and difficult to sustain um

11:55 with that.

11:55 Just one thing I want t

11:56 onote as well this study as I

11:59 mentioned requires a

11:59 certification from City

12:01 planning and that

12:02 certification is required

12:02 every three years

12:04 . And we're here to answer any

12:05 questions yes thank you that's

12:06 the end of your presentation

12:08 yes.

12:08 All right thank you

12:09 . So I have a couple of

12:11 questions and then I'll open

12:12 it up to my colleagues ah you

12:14 mentioned one other galleria

12:16 in the area but I wanted t

12:18 oknow how many galleries exist

12:19 in manhattan or elsewhere that

12:23 now qualify to have outdoor

12:24 cafe seating in the galleria

12:26 so right now none qualify ok.

12:28 As far as we know there's

12:29 only two other

12:30 . Locations through this six

12:31 and a half avenue all right

12:36 beyond signage what design

12:37 measures are you proposing t

12:40 omake sure the public is aware

12:42 that the gallery remains open

12:43 and accessible to the public.

12:44 So there is signage at each

12:48 entrance indicating that this

12:49 is a publicly accessible

12:51 privately owned space your

12:53 typical pop signage is at both

12:55 entrances on west 53 and west

12:57 54 street but what design

12:58 measures what are the designs

13:01 . Like what are the design

13:03 measures

13:04 . That were the improvements

13:06 that we're seeking or the

13:08 signage this De signage is

13:10 we're not anticipating any

13:17 other.

13:17 To improve the public's

13:19 access to the spates regarding

13:21 the design so there's the

13:22 signage part which you've

13:23 answered that question but

13:24 we're talking about the design

13:27 part

13:27 . For the the slide might

13:28 slide might help because it

13:29 tgalleria that's not going to

13:34 change that's going to.

13:35 Be permanent

13:36 . It's just the restaurant

13:38 only can is only a portion of

13:40 it I got it and

13:41 . During the City planning

13:43 certification process t

13:44 oapprove open air cafes in

13:46 probably in public spaces

13:47 there's certain minimum with

13:48 requirements so the public has

13:49 access from each eugen and we

13:51 comply with all of.

13:53 Those and we've the

13:55 restaurant is also invested in

13:56 the space with the building

13:57 owner to make sure that it's

13:59 more beautiful and more

14:02 acceptable days having

14:03 completely transformed if I

14:04 can bring up that other

14:05 . Photo again trump that slide

14:06 of the before and after okay

14:08 hmm thank you

14:10 . Do any of my colleagues have

14:13 questions.

14:13 Council Member in knesset hi o

14:17 . I know you mentioned that

14:19 the community board was

14:22 opposed because of the

14:25 restrooms that seems like the

14:26 borough president as well

14:27 . The borough president

14:30 approved with a with a

14:30 condition that we look at the

14:33 potential rest signage for the

14:35 public restrooms

14:35 . And so that would still be a

14:37 no for for for that even

14:39 though this is a public space

14:40 the seating would only be for

14:43 people that are using the

14:46 restaurant right the restrooms

14:47 are currently available upon