City CouncilConsumer Protection
The Council's ban on prices set from your personal data comes up for a committee vote Thursday, five months after its hearing
Speaker Julie Menin's Int. 891, now amended, would bar businesses from using algorithms and personal data to charge different people different prices, with carve-outs for loyalty programs and disclosed discounts. A similar state bill passed in June and still awaits the governor.
The Council's Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, chaired by Harvey D. Epstein, meets at 11 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 12, with one item on its agenda: a proposed amended version of Int. 891, Speaker Julie Menin's bill to prohibit "surveillance pricing." The full Council's stated meeting is at 1:30 p.m. the same day.
Why it matters to residents: the bill targets prices that change based on who you are, not what you're buying. Menin's examples at the June hearing were a sports jersey that costs one shopper $50 and a friend $30 at the same store at the same time, and roommates leaving a bar who each get a different quote for the same ride (8:28).
What the amended bill says
The proposed Int. 891-A, dated Nov. 4 and posted Nov. 9, defines surveillance pricing as pricing "set completely or in part by an algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods or services." It would:
- Bar any business or its vendors from setting prices that way, advertising them, or collecting or selling personal data to do it.
- Allow "bona fide" discounts that are generally available, such as sales and price matching, and "custom" discounts for loyalty program members, for groups like veterans, seniors or teachers who identify themselves, and based on a shopper's purchase history with that same business, as long as they are disclosed.
- Exclude insurance, credit decisions and pricing required by state or federal law. Location data a customer shares to calculate a trip or delivery is not counted as personal data.
- Require businesses that use custom discounts to tell customers, on request, what personal data was used and how.
- Set civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation, counted per consumer or transaction, and let the city seek restitution in court. Small local businesses, with fewer than 15 locations nationally, get 30 days to fix a first violation before the city can bring a case.
- Take effect one year after it becomes law.
What the hearing showed
At the June 17 hearing, Consumer and Worker Protection Commissioner Sam Levine said the administration supported the bill (20:11) and asked the Council to add a private right of action, so consumers could sue on their own. The amended bill does not include one. He said enforcing this bill and a companion would take about eight additional positions (27:14), and that the department had not received complaints about surveillance pricing, in part because consumers usually can't tell when it happens (28:18). The Council's fiscal estimate for the original bill put the cost at about $255,000 a year for an attorney, an investigator and an IT specialist.
Advertisement
Business groups told the committee the bill was unnecessary given the state legislation and would discourage discounts, the NYC Food Policy Center reported.
The companion, Int. 892 from Majority Leader Shaun Abreu, would bar grocery stores from raising an item's price more than once in 24 hours. It was heard the same day and is not on Thursday's agenda.
The state bill
In June, the state Legislature passed the One Fair Price Act, S.8623B/A.9349B, which also bans surveillance pricing, the Attorney General's office announced. Gov. Kathy Hochul has not acted on it; we found no report of a signature as of Wednesday. Levine told the Council the city and state bills were drafted "with knowledge of the other" (28:00).
What's next
The bill has 19 sponsors, including the Speaker. If the committee approves it Thursday, it could go to the full Council the same afternoon; the stated meeting's agenda had not been posted when we checked Wednesday morning.