On My Block · NYC Politics

EducationLegislation

A technical failure interrupts the specialized high school test. A Council bill to give the exam on a school day has waited 277 days

The Education Department says students who could not finish Saturday's SHSAT will be rescheduled automatically, with details due by Monday night. Council Member Susan Zhuang and other officials asked for an investigation of the vendor.

Some eighth and ninth graders could not get into or finish the Specialized High School Admissions Test on Saturday, Nov. 14, because of a technical problem reported by the test's vendor, Pearson, Gothamist reported. The Education Department did not say how many students were affected or what went wrong.

Testing went ahead on Sunday, Nov. 15, as planned, the department said.

Why it matters to residents: the test is the only factor for admission to Stuyvesant, Bronx Science and Brooklyn Tech, and the city uses it for five other specialized schools. Families with a child who sat for it Saturday need to know whether and when to test again.

What the department said

According to Gothamist:

  • Students who could not finish will be rescheduled automatically. Families were to get details by the end of the day Monday, Nov. 16.
  • Rescheduling will not affect a student's score or admission chances.
  • Students who did submit a test Saturday may retake it if they choose.
  • Chancellor Kamar Samuels said, "I understand and share the frustration of our students and families," and that the vendor "assured me the issue has been corrected."

The test is given digitally under a five-year, $17 million contract with Pearson approved by the Panel for Educational Policy in 2024, Gothamist reported. Pearson did not respond to Gothamist on Saturday.

What officials said

Susan Zhuang, Assembly Member William Colton and other Brooklyn officials asked for "a thorough, transparent investigation" in a joint statement, Gothamist reported. "Accountability cannot be outsourced," they said, adding that under mayoral control "the buck stops with City Hall and DOE leadership."

What the Council has pending

Three bills would change how students prepare for or take the test. None has had a hearing:

  • Int. 608, from Rita C. Joseph, would require the department to plan for giving the test on a school day instead of a weekend. It has 15 sponsors, including Zhuang, and was introduced Feb. 12, 277 days ago.
  • Int. 546, from Oswald J. Feliz, would require a plan to offer test prep to all middle school students. It has six sponsors.
  • Int. 485, from Sandra Ung, would require a plan for an after-school test prep pilot. It has five sponsors.

No bill on the test's vendor or how the test is delivered is pending. The closest is Int. 608, which asks only for a plan to move the test to a school day; it would not change the vendor or the digital format. A broader debate over specialized high school admissions, and two resolutions asking Albany to change the state law that requires the test, are in our earlier story.

What's next

  • Watch for the department's rescheduling notice to families.
  • The Education Committee meets Wednesday, Nov. 18, on school buses (our preview), and Thursday on a dental care bill. Neither agenda lists the test.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime