On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilEducation

School bus oversight hearing Wednesday: a bill would make the city post every late, early and missed bus each month

Lincoln Restler's Int. 835 would publish GPS-based arrival data by vendor, route and stop. The Education Committee also votes Thursday on a dental care information bill.

The City Council's Committee on Education holds an oversight hearing on school bus service at 1 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, in the Council Chambers at City Hall, according to its agenda. It will also hear a bill to publish detailed bus performance data and a resolution, added to the agenda Nov. 13, on bus contracts.

Why it matters to residents: when a bus is late or never comes, children miss class, therapy and meals, and parents miss work. The bill would let families see how often a route or bus company runs late.

What the dashboard bill would require

Int. 835, from Lincoln Restler, was introduced April 16 and has 11 sponsors, including Education Chair Eric Dinowitz. This is its first hearing. Under the bill text, the Department of Education would report to the speaker and post online each month, using data from bus tracking systems "including but not limited to systems operated by Via":

  • every recorded arrival time and other route-level timing data;
  • the number and share of on-time, early and late arrivals at each stop, school and home, and how many minutes early or late each was;
  • every time a bus failed to stop or arrive as scheduled;
  • scheduled versus actual ride times for students;
  • how often a driver was logged in to the tracking system at the start of a route.

The bill defines on time for a school arrival as between 30 and five minutes before the school day starts, and for a home arrival as within 10 minutes of the scheduled time. The data would be broken out by bus company, route, stop, school level, borough and school district, including Districts 75 and 79, and by whether a route serves general or special education students. An office chosen by the mayor would run a public dashboard. As introduced, the bill would take effect 120 days after becoming law, with the first monthly report due three months after that.

What auditors found

A December 2025 audit by the comptroller's office, then led by Brad Lander, found that the Education Department did not systematically use GPS or complaint data to oversee bus companies and relied mainly on investigating individual complaints. It counted 154,376 complaints in the 2023–24 school year, up from 84,849 two years earlier.

Curb-to-school routes, which serve students whose special education plans call for them, made up 99% of the problem runs bus companies reported, the audit found. Those routes cost about $1.23 billion for 56,446 students in 2023–24, or about $21,719 per student, compared with about $6,761 per student on stop-to-school routes.

The resolution

Res. 735 calls on Albany to pass S.1018/A.8440, which would amend the state education law on contracts for transporting schoolchildren. Its text and sponsors had not been posted on our site Saturday.

Thursday: a vote on dental care information

At 11 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, the committee meets again to vote on Int. 259-A, from Shekar Krishnan. The amended bill would have the Health Department work with the Education Department to create materials on the importance of dental care and fluoride, which schools would post or send to students and parents, according to its summary. It was heard Oct. 20 with the Higher Education Committee and has 22 sponsors. If approved, it could go to the full Council that afternoon.

Thursday is also the deadline Speaker Julie Menin and Krishnan gave Google to answer questions about AI tools in school accounts (our story).

What's next

Parents and students can testify at Wednesday's hearing in person or send written testimony to testimony@council.nyc.gov. Complaints about a specific bus can be filed with the Education Department's Office of Pupil Transportation.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime