On My Block · NYC Politics

Public HousingHousing

NYCHA closes $209 million in financing to renovate Seward Park Extension. Council members have pressed for data on how these conversions turn out

The Lower East Side development's two buildings, home to more than 650 residents, move to private management under the PACT program. At Council hearings this year, members asked about resident surveys and repair requests that vanish from NYCHA's system after a conversion.

The New York City Housing Authority has closed on $209 million in financing to renovate Seward Park Extension on the Lower East Side, amNY reported. The deal closed Nov. 5. The development's two buildings are home to more than 650 residents.

The project is part of NYCHA's PACT program, which moves developments to the federal Project-Based Section 8 program so private partners can borrow against the rent to pay for repairs. NYCHA still owns the land; a private company runs the buildings day to day.

Why it matters to residents: PACT is now one of the main ways NYCHA pays for major repairs. After a conversion, tenants deal with a private manager instead of NYCHA for repairs, and their repair requests move out of NYCHA's system.

What the deal pays for

According to amNY:

  • Apartments: new kitchens and bathrooms, flooring, energy-efficient appliances, plumbing fixtures, and washers and dryers.
  • Heating and cooling: new systems with in-unit controls, through NYCHA's Clean Heat for All program.
  • Buildings: new plumbing pipes and water lines, mechanical systems, lobbies and entrances, windows and brick repairs.
  • Access: lifts, accessible bathrooms and more accessible mailboxes.
  • Community center: upgrades and a backup generator for heating, cooling and refrigeration during outages. Catholic Charities will run social services from a new office.

The partners are Essence Development, MDG Design + Construction and Wavecrest Management, which will manage the property. amNY did not give a construction schedule.

What Council members have asked

The development is in the district of Christopher Marte.

At the Committee on Public Housing's budget hearing on March 24, Marte told NYCHA officials he had seen them "recently at Seward Park Extension" and asked whether the agency paid for what he called marketing events to present PACT to residents (1:00:15). NYCHA said it has no formal marketing budget and that staff from its real estate team handle engagement.

Marte then asked NYCHA to post its resident surveys and ballots online so the public can see what residents are asked before they vote (1:01:12). An official said the surveys ask about the experience of construction and satisfaction afterward, have not been posted, and would be posted once there is enough data (1:01:37). Marte said satisfaction can change months after a conversion, when "some of these buildings and apartments start falling apart" (1:02:13).

On Sept. 22, the committee's chair, Chris Banks, opened an oversight hearing on repair requests at NYCHA and PACT developments (meeting page). He said residents complain that their open work orders disappear from NYCHA's system when a development converts (2:16), and that it is unclear what happens to them afterward (2:44). He also noted that NYCHA's public work order data goes back only one year (2:56).

What's next

  • Residents should get notice from the new manager about construction schedules and how to request repairs.
  • The Public Housing Committee will question NYCHA on PACT again at its preliminary budget hearing in March. No committee bill on PACT repair data is pending in our records.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime