On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilSchools

Menin and Krishnan ask Google whether city students will keep Search without AI; answers due Nov. 19

The letter follows Google's Nov. 3 change to school accounts. A Council resolution backing a state ban on most classroom AI before high school has had no hearing.

Speaker Julie Menin and Council Member Shekar Krishnan, who represents Jackson Heights and Elmhurst and chairs the Committee on Oversight and Investigations, sent Google's chief executive a letter Thursday, Nov. 12, asking whether New York City public school students will be able to keep using Google Search without opting into the company's generative AI tools. They asked for written answers by Thursday, Nov. 19, according to a Council release issued Friday.

The letter follows a Nov. 3 announcement by Google about how its tools work on school-managed student accounts. It collides with the city's own policy: in September, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels announced a one-year moratorium on student-facing generative AI from 2-K through eighth grade, Chalkbeat reported.

Why it matters to residents: Google Search is a basic research tool on many students' school Chromebooks. If schools cannot get Search without AI features, the city may have to choose between its moratorium and access to the tool.

What Google changed, and what is disputed

Google said Nov. 3 that Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search would be off by default for school-managed K-12 student accounts until administrators turned them on, according to a summary of the coverage. Early reports said schools that rejected AI would also lose Search. Google then said administrators could turn on Search separately from Gemini.

The dispute that remains is about AI built into Search itself. Turning off Gemini does not remove AI Overviews or AI Mode from Search results, and Google's controls do not offer an AI-free Search, according to the same report.

The Council release says a Google representative told The New York Times the company cannot separate its products from AI, including Search.

"The City Council will not permit Google or any private firm to abuse its market power to force its products into classrooms, particularly those that utilize AI."

Speaker Julie Menin and Council Member Shekar Krishnan, joint statement, Nov. 13

Google has said it believes well-designed AI can support learning, according to the Nov. 8 report. The Council release does not include a response from the company.

What the letter asks

The letter asks Google to say in writing:

  • whether city schools and students can keep using Search without "AI Mode," "AI Overviews" or other student-facing generative AI tools, and if not, why not;
  • what safeguards ensure schools have "genuine choice" about adopting AI;
  • what Google is doing about inaccurate AI answers to students; and
  • whether Gemini or other Google classroom AI products collect student data, how it is used and stored, and whether Google earns revenue from it.

It points to YouTube Kids as an example of Google building a separate product for younger users.

What the Council has on file

Res. 658, from Phil Wong, with Alexa Avilés and Lincoln Restler as co-sponsors, calls on Albany to pass S.10133/A.9190, which would prohibit most use of artificial intelligence in classrooms before high school. It was introduced Sept. 24 and referred to the Committee on Education. Our records show no hearing.

Council members have introduced about a dozen other AI bills this term, including chatbot privacy rules and an office of AI oversight, our records show. None is specific to schools.

What happens next

Google's answers are due Nov. 19. The letter is a request, not a subpoena; the release does not say what the Council will do if Google does not respond. The Committee on Education's next meeting, on Wednesday, Nov. 18, is an oversight hearing on school bus service.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime