On My Block · NYC Politics

EducationOversight

467 students still had no school bus route in mid-November, the Education Department told the Council. The bus data bill was laid over

About 2,000 students started the year without a route, a deputy chancellor said. The department backs the intent of Lincoln Restler's monthly dashboard bill but wants a workable timeline, and the bus contracts run through 2028.

About 2,000 students began this school year without an assigned bus route, and 467 still had none as of Wednesday, Nov. 18, a deputy chancellor told the City Council's Committee on Education at an oversight hearing that afternoon. Most of them have individualized education programs that require transportation, Chalkbeat reported.

Kevin Moran, the Education Department's deputy chancellor for school operations, gave the 467 figure when the committee's chair, Eric Dinowitz, asked how many eligible students remained without service, CBS New York reported. Families of students without routes were given prepaid rideshare while the department worked to place them, he said.

Why it matters to residents: the system carries about 150,000 students a day, many of them children with disabilities whose school day and therapy sessions depend on the bus showing up on time.

This follows our Nov. 14 preview of the hearing.

What officials and members said

According to Chalkbeat, CBS New York and NY1:

  • Moran said every route that lacked a driver on the first day now has one, and that some gaps came from transportation requests filed after the Aug. 6 deadline. He cited a parent survey showing nearly 90% satisfaction last year. "The idea here is to get to no late buses," he said, CBS reported.
  • More than 350 students were waiting for the paraprofessionals their education plans require on the bus, Chalkbeat reported.
  • Education officials cited a 31% increase over four years in students who need curb-to-school service, NY1 reported.
  • Dinowitz called unreliable service a "perennial issue" and described a constituent whose bus arrives an hour before dismissal.
  • Lincoln Restler said nearly 90,000 routes were delayed last school year, about 500 per school day, and 56,000 students faced delays of more than an hour, Chalkbeat reported.
  • Lynn C. Schulman said, "When contracts aren't renegotiated, things fall through the cracks," NY1 reported.

The city spent $2.1 billion on student transportation in fiscal 2026, up from $1.46 billion five years earlier, and budgeted $2.28 billion for this year, according to Chalkbeat.

The bills

  • Int. 835, from Restler, with 15 sponsors in all: a public dashboard of early, late and missed pickups and drop-offs, posted monthly. The department supports the bill's intent but wants a feasible reporting timeline, Chalkbeat reported. Our records show it was heard and laid over Wednesday; no vote was taken.
  • Res. 735, from Julie Won: calls on Albany to pass S.1018/A.8440, on contracts for transporting schoolchildren. It was also laid over.

The contracts

The current bus contracts expire at the end of the 2027-28 school year, NY1 reported. A state bill could allow renegotiation with protections for employees, according to NY1. A statement from the New York School Bus Contractors Association said contracts "can be modernized and strengthened through existing frameworks."

Chalkbeat also reported that a December 2025 audit by the city comptroller found the department could have assessed $44.3 million in GPS-tracking penalties against bus companies for 2024-25 but assessed $1.7 million. Moran said drivers now log into the tracking app about 93% of the time.

What's next

Int. 835 needs a committee vote before the full Council can take it up, and the sponsor and the department are still negotiating its timeline. Our meeting page will have the video and transcript when they are posted.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime