On My Block · NYC Politics

HousingLegislation

The housing chair says City Hall missed its own deadline on her Safer Homes Act. The housing commissioner promises a response 'hopefully before Thanksgiving'

Int. 657 would replace the city's old Third Party Transfer foreclosure program. At the same hearing, members pressed for a renewal of the tax cap that keeps HDFC co-ops affordable, which ends in 2029.

Housing Chair Pierina Ana Sanchez ended the administration's portion of Tuesday's homeownership hearing with a question about a bill that was not on the agenda: her Safer Homes Act, Int. 657.

The administration, she said, has had the Council's "red line," its marked-up draft of the bill, since Mayor Zohran Mamdani took office, and committed to returning comments by mid-November, "which I define as November 15. It is November 17" (2:51:02). She asked when the Council would get them and whether the bill is still a priority.

"We affirmatively support the bill," Housing Preservation and Development Commissioner Dina Levy answered, calling it "complicated" and saying officials have been discussing how it would work with the city's new land bank (2:51:30). She said she would follow up with the Law Department and hoped to deliver the comments "before Thanksgiving, before we break next week," adding that the delay "is not an indication of any lack of support" (2:52:02).

Why it matters to residents: the Third Party Transfer program lets the city foreclose on distressed buildings with unpaid taxes and hand them to new owners. It has been criticized for taking homes and co-ops that were not in distress, and the Council wants to rebuild it before it is used again.

This follows our coverage of Tuesday's hearing on payment plans and the 2027 lien sale.

What the Safer Homes Act would change

Sanchez laid out the bill at its only hearing, on March 9 (meeting record):

  • It ends the "block pickup" rule, under which one qualifying property on a block could pull in its neighbors (5:31).
  • Buildings would be chosen through an index meant to pick "the worst of the worst." She cited a 2019 Council audit that found more than half the properties in one round were not distressed (6:00).
  • Notice requirements would be stricter, with more outreach and protections for owner-occupied homes and HDFC co-ops, and residents could team up with qualified groups to apply for ownership.
  • Owners could no longer exit just by paying; they would need corrective action plans showing repairs are underway (7:31).

Our records show Int. 657 was introduced Jan. 29 with Sanchez as prime sponsor and now lists 41 sponsors. It was laid over on March 9 and has had no action since.

The co-op tax cap

Majority Leader Shaun Abreu, whose Upper Manhattan district he said has the city's highest concentration of HDFC co-ops, told officials the "DAMP" property tax cap that many of these limited-equity co-ops rely on expires in 2029 with no certainty about renewal. He said banks are reluctant to lend without knowing future tax bills (20:01).

Abreu's Res. 9 calls on Albany to pass A.2707B/S.880B, the HDFC Fairness, Preservation and Affordability Act. Sanchez said its state sponsors are Sen. Robert Jackson and Assembly Member Al Taylor (2:14:43).

Levy said "we agree there is a fairly urgent need" to renew the cap (2:15:00). She described "very positive" talks with the state sponsors, and said HPD has recommended renewal rules that keep the co-ops affordable and allow modest yearly maintenance increases so they do not fall into financial trouble (2:15:30).

Many co-op shareholders who testified later in the day urged the Council to pass Res. 9, according to the hearing's public record.

Where things stand

  • Res. 9: amended by the committee Tuesday and laid over, our records show. Resolutions are not binding; the tax cap is set in state law.
  • Int. 657: waiting on the administration's comments. The Council's last stated meeting before Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 19.
  • Land bank: the Council approved the mayor's appointment of Lisa Garcia to the land bank board in September, as we reported. Levy linked the timing of the Safer Homes Act to how that new entity will work.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime