The Finance Department tells the Council it wants tax payment plans to stay opt-in, and lays out its changes for the 2027 lien sale
At Tuesday's nearly five-hour homeownership hearing, officials said they could not support automatic enrollment as written, could not price it, and would not have the staff for it. They also said 3,859 properties with senior or disability exemptions owe back taxes.
The city's Finance Department told two Council committees on Tuesday that it supports the goal of a bill to put struggling homeowners into property tax payment plans automatically, but not the bill as written. "We do feel that payment plans should be opt in," First Deputy Commissioner Jeffrey Shear said (58:02).
The joint hearing of the Committees on Finance and on Housing and Buildings, "Advancing Homeownership Opportunity and Protection," ran nearly five hours and took no votes. Our meeting record has the video and a searchable transcript.
Why it matters to residents: overdue property taxes and water bills can end up in the city's lien sale, where a private trust buys the debt, adds interest and fees and can eventually foreclose. City Hall has said it will hold one more sale in mid-2027. How easy it is to get into a payment plan before then decides who stays off the list.
This follows our Tuesday preview of the hearing.
Advertisement
The automatic enrollment bill
Int. 1084, from Crystal Hudson, would have the department enroll eligible homeowners in the lowest-cost city payment plan, with at least 60 days' notice and a right to opt out. Finance Chair Linda Lee questioned officials on it:
- Counting the plans. Lee said the department set up 4,746 payment plans in 2025, including 4,573 standard plans and 40 reduced-interest plans, and Shear confirmed the figures (55:02).
- "Lowest cost." Shear said picking the lowest-cost plan "sounds straightforward," but a longer plan lowers each payment while adding interest (56:00). He said the department does not know enough about owners to choose for them and worried that owners enrolled without consent could default and face enforcement (57:01).
- Small debts. Some owners are a few months behind and owe a few hundred dollars. "For the former group we frankly don't think it makes sense to enroll them," Shear said; for owners deeper in debt, "we very much want to" (1:01:02).
- Cost and staff. Asked what the staffing and technology would cost, he said there was no estimate available (1:02:30). Asked whether current staff could handle an opt-out system, the answer "for the record" was no (2:12:30).
- A middle path. Shear suggested an application where owners give the department their information so it can suggest the best plan (59:30).
Lee also asked about homeowners with the senior and disability exemptions, who she said qualify for a payment plan that lowers interest. Shear said 3,859 properties with those benefits have outstanding property taxes and that a report on the size and age of the debt would come "within the next couple of weeks" (1:03:31).
What changes for the 2027 sale
Housing Chair Pierina Ana Sanchez asked why a sale was not needed in 2026 but is in 2027 (47:31). The administration's witnesses listed changes (49:01):
- foreclosure on owner-occupied one- to three-family homes only once the debt reaches $70,000 or 15% of market value;
- a higher water and sewer threshold for two- and three-family homes, from $3,000 to $5,000 overdue more than a year, with single-family homes still exempt;
- earlier help for owners who used the sale's "easy exit" option in 2025.
Deputy Finance Commissioner Annette Hill added (51:33) that the at-risk list will go to nonprofit partners before the 90-day notice period, that notices will warn about deed theft, and that properties whose owners have died will be held out of the sale for two years. Asked what share of owners the city expects to get off the list, officials said they were "just in the planning stages" (54:00).
Other numbers from the hearing:
- In the last sale, 3,144 owners of one- to three-family homes got off the list by enrolling in a payment plan, and no homeowner lost a home to a tax lien foreclosure in the past year, the department told Lee (2:11:51).
- Selvena N. Brooks-Powers said liens sold on small homes in her southeast Queens district rose from 44 in 2021 to 102 in 2025 (1:32:21). A Finance official attributed the citywide rise partly to the four-year gap between sales (1:35:30).
- Housing Preservation and Development Commissioner Dina Levy said the outreach contract is $2 million for one year, with the Center for NYC Neighborhoods bringing on 15 to 20 local groups and promising eight contacts with each affected homeowner (2:17:02).
What's next
- The bills were heard, not voted on. Lee said the Council wants to keep "flushing out" Int. 1084 with the department (2:14:00).
- The department's report on exemption holders with back taxes is due to the Council in the coming weeks.
- The 90-day notice list for the 2027 sale is expected in late February or early March.