The amended property tax rates are posted: one- to three-family homes would drop to 19.972%, commercial would rise to 10.859%
The Council's 0.3% class share cap moves about $266 million of this year's $39.9 billion levy off small homes and about $283 million onto commercial property, by our calculation from the resolutions. The Finance Committee and full Council take them up Thursday.
The texts of the four resolutions that would redo this year's property tax split were posted ahead of the Finance Committee's 11 a.m. meeting Thursday, Nov. 12, and they include the new rates. When we first wrote about the plan on Tuesday, only the titles were public.
Why it matters to residents: the city divides its property tax among four classes. The rates below are what each class pays per dollar of taxable assessed value. Your own bill also depends on your assessment and any exemptions, so a lower rate does not by itself mean a lower bill than last year.
The new rates
The amended tax-fixing resolution, Res. 726, sets these rates for the fiscal year that began July 1, compared with the rates the Council adopted on June 30 (Res. 546) and last year's:
- Class 1, one- to three-family homes: 19.972%, down from 20.909% in June. Last year: 19.843%.
- Class 2, apartment buildings, co-ops and condos: 12.423%, down from 12.440%. Last year: 12.439%.
- Class 3, utilities: 11.119%, up from 11.108%. Last year: 11.108%.
- Class 4, commercial property: 10.859%, up from 10.658%. Last year: 10.848%.
The prior-year figures come from the rate history attached to the resolution as Exhibit C. For a home, the drop from June's rate works out to about $94 less a year for every $10,000 of taxable assessed value. For commercial property, the increase is about $201 a year for every $100,000.
Advertisement
The total levy does not change: $39,885,078,591, the same amount the Council set in June. What changes is how it is shared.
Who pays what share
The resolutions certify new "adjusted base proportions," each class's share of the levy:
- Class 1: 14.2025%, down from 14.8692% in June
- Class 2: 39.0535%, down from 39.1050%
- Class 3: 8.3606%, up from 8.3526%
- Class 4: 38.3834%, up from 37.6732%
Applied to the full levy, that moves about $266 million off one- to three-family homes and about $21 million off Class 2, and puts about $283 million more on commercial property and about $3 million more on utilities. Those are our calculations from the resolution figures, before refunds and uncollectible taxes.
Why the Council is doing this
State law caps how much any class's share can grow in a year at 5%. A law Gov. Kathy Hochul signed on Sept. 25 lets the Council pick a lower cap for this year only, if it acts by Dec. 1. According to the Finance Division's committee report on Res. 723, without a change the Class 1 rate would have been 5.4% higher than last year's, which, "coupled with assessment increases," would mean "significant increases" in homeowners' bills. With the 0.3% cap, the report says, the rates for Classes 1, 3 and 4 end up 0.6%, 0.1% and 0.1% above last year's, and Class 2's 0.1% below.
Advertisement
Last year, the Council used the same kind of state permission to set a 1% cap.
The June vote
The June rates passed 46-5. Vickie Paladino, Joann Ariola, Inna Vernikov, David M. Carr and Frank Morano voted no. The class share certification passed 43-7, with Phil Wong and Simcha Felder also voting no. Thursday's roll call will show whether any of those votes change.
What's next
The four resolutions, sponsored by Finance chair Linda Lee, are listed for introduction at the 1:30 p.m. stated meeting, where they could be adopted the same day. The law requires the city to reset rates and send amended bills where bills have already gone out. We will update with the votes.