On My Block · NYC Politics

ImmigrationLegislation

NYPD tells the Council it hasn't honored an ICE detainer in a decade. The administration backs the 'spirit' of the detainer bills while its lawyers review them

At Friday's immigration hearing, the NYPD's top legal official described new patrol guide rules for ICE encounters, and the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs said the Law Department is reviewing Int. 1077-A and 1078-A. Carmen De La Rosa pressed the department over its handling of the Marble Hill shooting.

The City Council's Committee on Immigration heard the amended "Cut Ties with ICE" detainer bills on Friday, Nov. 20, along with testimony from the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs and the NYPD. No votes were taken.

Why it matters to residents: the bills would write into law limits on when police and jail staff can hold someone for immigration agents. The hearing showed how far current practice already goes, and that the administration has not yet taken a final position on the text.

This follows our Thursday preview of what the amended bills change.

The administration's position

The commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs said the administration was "pleased to express our support for the spirit of the legislation being considered today" (50:16). On Int. 1077-A and Int. 1078-A, both from committee chair Elsie Encarnación, the commissioner said the administration supports limiting the use of local resources for federal immigration enforcement and that the Law Department is reviewing both bills (51:01).

Asked later to be clear about Int. 1077-A, an administration witness repeated that they support "the spirit of the bills" and are reviewing them with the Law Department (1:46:30). Encarnación replied that she looked forward to the administration fully supporting them.

The commissioner also said the administration supports training staff under Int. 739, from Shahana K. Hanif, noting that much of that work began under the mayor's Executive Order 13.

What the NYPD said

Michael Gerber, the NYPD's deputy commissioner for legal matters, said the department has "not honored [a] civil immigration detainer in a decade, not one" (1:02:30). He said:

  • Rules that were in an operations order are now in the patrol guide, making them permanent. The core principle, he said, is that officers do not do immigration enforcement or assist with it (1:06:00).
  • Any 911 call that references immigration enforcement now triggers a notification so executives oversee the response.
  • An officer asking someone about immigration status is "a flagrant violation of department policy" and would be investigated (1:05:02).
  • Int. 1077-A would remove a provision in city law allowing a 48-hour hold pending a judicial warrant, but he said a state appellate ruling already bars such holds and the department has followed it for years, so the cost of holding people for immigration enforcement is "zero" (1:25:32).

The commissioner's testimony listed other steps under Executive Order 13: quarterly NYPD reports on detainer requests, a policy barring outside agencies from non-public areas of NYPD property, a new Parks Department policy for workers when non-local law enforcement tries to use park property, and a letter from the mayor and more than 100 elected officials asking more than 700 parking lot and garage owners not to rent space to ICE (46:00).

Marble Hill

Carmen N. De La Rosa, who represents Marble Hill, questioned the department about the night of the Oct. 8 shooting there involving ICE agents, saying she watched officers escort agents to their cars (1:47:02). The NYPD witness said officers told agents who were standing around the scene to leave, and later moved protesters away from departing vehicles "not in coordination with ICE" but to keep people from being hurt (2:00:00). He said five people were arrested outside the hospital and declined to discuss the treatment of a congresswoman-elect, citing an active investigation. The two said they saw events differently.

What's next

Our records list 24 sponsors for Int. 1077-A and 26 for Int. 1078-A; a majority of the 51-member Council is 26. They still need a committee vote, which could come with further changes, then the full Council. The Council's last two stated meetings of the year are Dec. 3 and Dec. 17. Public testimony, which ran for more than an hour after the agency panel, is on the meeting page.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime