On My Block · NYC Politics

HousingPublic Safety

Flatbush collapse: city inspectors halt work at sites tied to the project's engineers and contractors. The Council's stop-work inspection bill still has no hearing

Gothamist counted at least five stop-work orders; THE CITY found more. A tenant of the collapsed building has sued, saying he reported cracks weeks earlier. Int. 1039 has waited since September.

A week after 1321 Flatbush Ave. collapsed into the excavation next door, killing eight people including two children, city inspectors are working through the other jobs of the companies and engineers behind that project, and some of those sites have been shut down.

Why it matters to residents: Mayor Zohran Mamdani has said the sweep covers about 160 projects across the city. If one is on your block, it may now be under a stop-work order.

This follows our Nov. 14 story on the criminal investigation and what the Buildings Department told the Council about excavation deaths.

What the sweep has found so far

The Buildings Department has not released results. A spokesperson told THE CITY the sweep was continuing and results would be released soon. Two news organizations pieced together what they could:

  • Gothamist found at least 24 sites in four boroughs linked to the project's two engineers and counted at least five projects fully or partly halted between Nov. 12 and Nov. 17. The reasons included unsafe scaffolding, a worker without a harness, loose netting over a school playground and a contractor who blocked an inspector. Only one of the five involved excavation.
  • THE CITY reported partial stop-work orders at two Queens sites tied to the project's engineering firm, and records of earlier violations at sites tied to the demolition contractor, including a full vacate order in Brooklyn after bricks fell into a neighboring yard.
  • The Buildings Department has ordered soil put back along the north side of the Flatbush excavation "in the interest of public safety," a spokesperson told THE CITY. The south side, where the building fell, is untouched while investigators work.

The developer had approval for a three-story building and had filed plans in September for nine stories, which had not been approved, both outlets reported.

The lawsuit

A tenant of 1321 Flatbush sued on Monday in state Supreme Court in Brooklyn, Gothamist reported. The suit names the building's owner, the developer's companies, the general contractor, the excavation subcontractor, the structural engineer and the special inspection firm, and says the tenant reported cracks near the entrance weeks before the collapse. Gothamist also reported that the building went through the city's tax lien sale process at least five times in the past decade.

The Department of Buildings, the Department of Investigation and the Brooklyn District Attorney are investigating. No cause has been announced.

The Council

Int. 1039, from Ty Hankerson, would require inspectors to return every two weeks to sites under certain stop-work orders. It was introduced Sept. 10 and lists 13 sponsors, including Farah N. Louis, who represents the area around the collapse. Our records still show no hearing.

The Committee on Housing and Buildings, chaired by Pierina Ana Sanchez, meets Thursday to vote on two other bills, one of which would have the Buildings Department email owners about open permits. Neither Thursday's nor Friday's agenda lists the collapse. At Tuesday's homeownership hearing, Mercedes Narcisse mentioned "what happened on Flatbush Avenue" while asking about development and sinking basements in flood zones (1:26:50), and several members of the public raised it in testimony, according to our meeting record.

What's next

  • Thursday, Nov. 19: the Council's stated meeting, the next chance for members to introduce bills responding to the collapse. Introductions are not posted ahead of time.
  • Sweep results: the Buildings Department says they are coming. We will report them when released.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime