Flatbush collapse: prosecutors join the inquiry, and three weeks earlier the Buildings Department told the Council most site deaths came from digging
The Brooklyn DA is working with the Buildings Department and the Department of Investigation. At an Oct. 21 hearing, the department said five of eight construction deaths last fiscal year involved soil work.
The Brooklyn District Attorney's office has opened a criminal investigation into Wednesday's collapse of 1321 Flatbush Ave., working with the Department of Buildings and the Department of Investigation, District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said Friday, according to The New York Times. Eight people were killed, including two children, when the three-story building fell into an excavation next door.
Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said the city has hired an outside engineering firm for an independent report and is examining about 160 building sites tied to the companies behind the neighboring project, which he did not name, the Times reported.
Why it matters to residents: the collapse happened beside an active excavation, and the Buildings Department told the Council last month that most construction deaths it recorded in the last fiscal year were tied to that kind of work.
This follows our Friday story on the collapse and a pending Council bill on stop-work inspections.
Advertisement
What officials said Friday
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani: "If we find anyone that has violated the law, we will hold them fully accountable," according to the Daily News.
- Tigani: the developers were seeking approval for a nine-story building with a cellar. "They don't have approval for a nine-story building," he said, according to the Daily News.
- Attorney General Letitia James: "The families in this community deserve answers about what led to this collapse." She warned of scams aimed at people trying to help, Brooklyn Paper reported.
- Speaker Julie Menin: the department has "an 8 to 9 percent vacancy rate," and "we must and we will ensure that every single one of those positions is immediately filled," according to Brooklyn Paper. She said the Council would provide money for more inspectors and strengthen building codes.
- Farah N. Louis, who represents the area, pointed to records showing "a building with nearly 100 open violations sitting next to an excavation site," Brooklyn Paper reported. The Daily News counted 98 open violations at 1321 Flatbush, including unsafe wiring and missing smoke detectors, and said it was unclear whether any played a role.
- Public Advocate Jumaane Williams said the building's owner had appeared on his worst landlords list several times, according to Brooklyn Paper.
The Daily News reported that full vacate orders remained for 1322, 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Ave., and that residents of other nearby buildings could return home.
What the Buildings Department told the Council in October
On Oct. 21, the Committee on Housing and Buildings, chaired by Pierina Ana Sanchez, held an oversight hearing on construction safety. Sanchez opened by noting that deaths on construction sites "consistently hover around eight per year" (2:24).
Asked about the eight deaths in fiscal year 2026, which ended June 30, a department official said "five of those eight were related to soil work" (1:38:39), and explained that this usually means digging out a basement or cellar and the underpinning and excavation support that go with it (1:39:25). Only two of the eight sites required a construction superintendent, the official said, which Sanchez took to mean most were smaller jobs (1:40:14).
Officials also testified that:
Advertisement
- the department had 609 inspectors and an overall vacancy rate of 8% (23:43);
- a proactive team inspects buildings next to construction sites to find "high risk" neighbors and make sure the work next door is not affecting them (40:32).
At a March 24 budget hearing, Sanchez described a contractor whose Bronx demolition site had a wall collapse earlier this year and who had been cited seven times for violating an active stop-work order (39:03), and the mayor's management report showed 2,683 stop-work orders in the first four months of fiscal 2026, up 20% (42:52). Gothamist has reported that the Flatbush project team had ignored earlier department orders.
What the Council has pending
Int. 1039, introduced Sept. 10, would require inspectors to return every two weeks to sites under certain stop-work orders. Our records still show no hearing. No new bill responding to the collapse had been introduced as of Saturday; the next chance is the Council's stated meeting on Thursday, Nov. 19.
What's next
The Housing and Buildings Committee meets Tuesday, Nov. 17, on homeownership, and Friday, Nov. 20, jointly with the Fire Committee on residential fires. Neither agenda lists the collapse. The city has directed people who want to help to the Mayor's Fund to Advance New York City.