A new report says childcare costs push New York parents out of work. The Council looks at the city's early childhood contracts Dec. 2
The 5Boro Institute estimates parents who left jobs lose $1.7 billion a year in income. The city's 2-K program opened 2,000 seats this fall and aims for 12,000 next fall. Here is what officials and budget analysts have told the Council.
About one in four New York City parents who changed their work after having children left the workforce altogether, according to a survey released Tuesday by the 5Boro Institute at Citizens Union and Boston Consulting Group, Gothamist reported. The report estimates those departures cost families about $1.7 billion a year in lost income.
The report lands two weeks before the Council's Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education holds an oversight hearing on the city's contracts for early childhood services, Wednesday, Dec. 2, at 1 p.m. at 250 Broadway (agenda).
Why it matters to residents: the city is building toward free care for children under 5, starting with 2-year-olds. The pace depends on state money, on providers the city pays through contracts, and on whether those payments arrive on time.
What the report found
According to Gothamist, the survey of about 3,000 parents found:
Advertisement
- About 15% changed their work situation after becoming parents; most changed hours, and 25% of those left work. Of parents who left or lost jobs, 73% were women and 43% earned under $50,000.
- Childcare averages $21,000 a year in the city, more than a third of the budget of households earning under $50,000.
- Free care of 35 hours a week could generate up to $6.5 billion a year in economic value, which the authors say matches or exceeds the cost.
- 22% of unemployed parents said free childcare would let them return to work.
The report offers no comparison with earlier years or other cities, Gothamist noted.
What the city has told the Council
At the subcommittee's Oct. 7 hearing on 2-K, the executive director of the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education said (6:00):
- Gov. Kathy Hochul committed $73 million for the first year of 2-K, for at least 2,000 children this fall, and $425 million for the second year, to reach 12,000 children in fall 2027.
- The mayor and governor have committed to reach every 2-year-old whose family wants a seat by fall 2029 (6:30).
- Parents pay an average of $26,000 a year for full-time care for a 2-year-old (7:00).
- This fall's seats are in school districts 6 in Manhattan, 10 in the Bronx, 18 and 23 in Brooklyn and 27 in Queens. Next fall's expansion will include District 31, all of Staten Island (8:32).
- 2-K is offered only through community-based centers and licensed family childcare programs, not in public school buildings (9:32).
At the same hearing, the administration said the early childhood workforce "must double" for universal care and that wage inequities with home-based educators are "a problem we know we must address head on" (52:41).
The money question
In June, the Independent Budget Office told the Finance Committee that close to 110,000 children receive city childcare vouchers, with more than 25,000 on a waitlist because the application portal had been closed since 2025, and that the city faces a funding shortfall for vouchers starting in fiscal 2028 (1:12:44).
Advertisement
Gothamist reported that the Mamdani administration estimates universal childcare will cost $6 billion a year.
Late payments
Early childhood providers have told the Council that late city payments force them to take on interest and late fees and strain payroll, including at a Jan. 30 Education Committee hearing (1:16:13). In February, the Council enacted Int. 203, requiring reports on payments to early childhood providers.
What's next
- Dec. 2, 1 p.m.: Early Childhood Education Subcommittee, chaired by Jennifer Gutiérrez, on contracts for early childhood services. Anyone can testify in person or in writing to testimony@council.nyc.gov.
- The city has not announced which districts besides Staten Island get 2-K seats in fall 2027.