Friday, January 30, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 3
Committee: Committee on Education
The Committee on Education, chaired by Council Member Eric Dinowitz, held its first hearing of the session on Introduction 203, sponsored by Council Member Jennifer Gutiérrez, which would require NYC Public Schools to report monthly on invoices and payments to early childhood care and education providers, replacing the current quarterly budget terms-and-conditions reporting. The Deputy Chancellor for Early Childhood Education (referred to as Deputy Chancellor Hawkins) testified that the agency shares the transparency goals but prefers quarterly reporting, citing advance payments and batch invoicing, and described improvements including a new early childhood management system targeted for launch by the end of the calendar year and an average two-week invoice processing turnaround. The Independent Budget Office reported that contracts were registered an average of 247 days late in 2024, up from 83 days in 2021, and supported monthly invoice disaggregation. Providers and advocacy organizations testified about late payments, reliance on loans, staffing turnover, and pay parity concerns, largely supporting the bill. No vote was taken.
0:16 Okay sergeants good morning
0:16 and welcome to today's New
0:17 York City Council hearing from
0:19 the committee on education at
0:21 this point I'd like to remind
0:22 everyone to please silence or
0:24 devices and at no point as
0:25 anyone to approach the dais or
0:27 the witness table unless
0:28 invited to testify if you
0:29 would like to testify and have
0:31 not signed up to testify at
0:33 this point you can do so by
0:34 filling out a form ok on the
0:36 reception desk with the
0:37 sergeant arms chair we're
0:38 ready to begin good morning
0:42 everyone I'm councilmember
0:43 Eric dane witz proud graduate
0:45 of our New York City public
0:46 schools proud former teacher
0:48 in our New York City public
0:50 schools and now a chair of the
0:51 education committee and I'm
0:53 pleased to welcome you all
0:53 here today at our first
0:55 hearing of the City Council's
0:59 26 2 29 legislative session
0:59 today we're holding a hearing
1:01 on introduction 203 sponsored
1:04 by Council Member Jennifer
1:06 to early childhood care and
1:12 education providers for
1:13 several years the council has
1:15 required quarterly reporting
1:16 through budget terms and
1:18 conditions to monitor whether
1:19 early childhood care and
1:21 education providers are being
1:22 paid in full and on time those
1:24 reports have offered some
1:28 insight but they have also had
1:29 clear limitations they are
1:31 retrospective and aggregated
1:34 and by doo's own admission
1:35 have not always allowed the
1:38 City to reliably quantify
1:39 outstanding invoice backlogs
1:41 or assess how long providers
1:42 are waiting to be paid at
1:44 prior hearings this committee
1:46 has heard troubling testimony
1:48 from providers describing the
1:49 real consequences of delayed
1:50 or partial payments.
1:52 Providers have reported
1:54 draining operation reserves
1:56 operating reserves just t
1:58 omeet payroll taking out loans
1:59 or lines of credit to stay
2:01 afloat and facing uncertainty
2:03 about whether and when they
2:04 will be paid for work already
2:08 performed under City contracts e
2:12 described waiting months or
2:14 even longer for reimbursement
2:16 without clear information
2:17 about where their invoices
2:19 stood in the system.
2:20 At the same time the council
2:22 has heard from the
2:24 administration that system
2:25 transitions and internal
2:27 process challenges have made
2:29 it difficult to consistently
2:30 track invoices or provide real
2:32 time answers to basic
2:33 questions about what is owed
2:35 to whom and for how long these
2:38 payment delays do not exist in
2:40 a vacuum
2:41 . The early childhood care and
2:42 education workforce is
2:44 overwhelmingly made up of
2:46 women and disproportionately
2:47 women of color and many of
2:49 these workers earn modest
2:51 wages while providing
2:51 essential care and education
2:53 . To some of the cities
2:54 youngest New York er's when
2:57 providers are not paid on time e
3:04 immediate consequences and
3:05 it's the families who depend
3:07 on stable child care who
3:09 ultimately feel the impact
3:11 through staff turnover program
3:13 instability and even closures
3:17 the issue takes on even
3:18 greater urgency as Mayor
3:19 mamdani has pledged to advance
3:22 universal childcare care
3:23 across the City ensuring that
3:25 providers are paid fully and
3:28 promptly is a foundational
3:30 concern a system that cannot
3:31 reliably pay providers for
3:34 existing programs cannot
3:35 sustainably support expansion
3:38 intro to o 3 is intended is
3:39 intended to replace existing
3:41 quarterly reporting condition
3:43 with more frequent invoice
3:45 based reporting framework by
3:47 requiring monthly reporting on
3:49 the number and value of
3:50 invoices paid in full paid
3:54 partially or unpaid and by
3:55 requiring disclosure of
3:57 average processing time the
3:57 bill seeks to shift oversight
4:00 from periodic snapshots to
4:01 ongoing real time monitoring
4:04 if enacted this legislation
4:05 will demand greater visibility d
4:10 accountability and how the
4:12 City pays for providers for
4:13 work they have already
4:15 performed under contract the
4:16 goal is straightforward to
4:20 ensure that early childhood
4:21 care and education providers
4:24 are paid fully and on time t
4:26 oprotect the workforce that
4:27 delivers these essential
4:30 services and to give the City
4:31 the tools it needs to identify
4:34 problems early address them
4:36 systematically and avoid
4:37 repeating past failures I look
4:39 forward to hearing from the
4:41 administration today and thank
4:42 the witnesses for appearing
4:45 today thank you to my own
4:46 staff and the education
4:49 committee staff including
4:50 counsel alejandro carvel
4:52 senior policy analyst chloe
4:54 rivera policy analyst katie
4:58 selena and finance analyst
5:00 drew lane lawless and grace
5:01 amato for their work at
5:04 today's hearing and thank you
5:05 to my colleagues who are
5:06 present today council members
5:09 luis um Joseph Lee wang wang
5:13 and ahn zum we have us have
5:15 joining us councilman Narcisse
5:19 and Schulman finally I would
5:22 like to remind everyone who
5:24 wishes to testify in person
5:26 today that you must fill out a
5:29 witness slip which you can
5:30 find on the desk of the
5:31 sergeant at arms at the
5:32 entrance of the room please
5:34 fill out this slip even if you
5:36 have already registered in
5:37 advance that you will be
5:39 testifying in person today
5:41 . If you wish to testify on
5:44 introduction to hundred
5:45 3please indicate on the witness
5:46 slip whether you are here t
5:49 otestify in favor or in
5:50 opposition to the legislation
5:53 I want to point out that we
5:54 will not be voting on
5:56 legislation today ah to allow
5:57 as many people as possible t
6:00 otestify testimony will be
6:00 limited to three minutes per
6:03 person whether you are
6:04 testifying in person or on
6:06 zoom I am also going to ask my
6:08 colleagues to limit their
6:10 questions and comments to five
6:12 minutes please note that
6:13 witnesses who are here in
6:15 person will testify those
6:17 before those who are signed on
6:19 to zoom I'd like to know we've
6:21 also been joined by council
6:22 member La Rosa as a reminder
6:23 to all of our witnesses please
6:25 state your name prior to your
6:26 testimony for the record if
6:28 anyone here today requires an
6:30 accessible version of a
6:31 presentation give it at
6:33 today's hearing please email
6:35 testimony at counsel dot dot
6:37 gov I will now administer the
6:39 oath and according to the
6:40 rules of the council ah please
6:42 raise your right hand do you
6:45 affirm to tell the truth the
6:46 whole truth and nothing but
6:48 the truth before this
6:50 committee and to respond
6:52 honestly to Council Member
6:53 questions I do.
6:54 Thank you and you begin your
6:58 testimony thank you it's
6:59 bringing me a sense of
7:00 nostalgia to be back in the
7:01 building I once worked in so
7:02 thank you for having me today
7:05 good morning to your benowitz
7:07 and members of the City
7:09 council committee on education s
7:13 and I serve as deputy
7:14 chancellor for the early
7:16 childhood education division
7:16 at New York City public
7:18 schools thank you for the
7:19 opportunity to be here and for
7:21 your continued partnership and
7:23 supporting New York city's
7:25 youngest learners and the
7:27 early childhood providers who
7:28 serve them.
7:28 New York City public schools
7:31 shares the council's
7:32 commitment to transparenc
7:34 yaccountability and timely
7:35 payments to early care and
7:39 education providers our
7:39 contract it provided partners
7:40 who comprise about 60% of our
7:43 portfolio of seats play a
7:46 critical role in delivering
7:46 high quality early learning
7:49 experiences to thousands of
7:50 children across New York City
7:52 . Ensuring predictable and
7:53 sustainable funding to them is
7:56 essential to the to the
7:57 stability of the system excuse
8:00 me we also share the council's
8:01 goal of supporting high
8:03 quality early childhood care
8:05 and learning across the City
8:06 and look forward to continue
8:08 nstrengthen providers and
8:12 improve outcomes for children
8:15 and families I know this to be
8:16 true not only as the deputy
8:18 chancellor but as a parent who
8:20 relied on this very system for
8:23 my daughter I would like t
8:24 obriefly share with you
8:25 information about early
8:26 childhood provider payments
8:28 are ongoing efforts to improve
8:30 that support and our thoughts
8:31 about the proposed legislation s
8:35 contracts with early childhood
8:36 providers through a flat rate
8:39 funding model designed t
8:39 opromote stability and equity
8:42 across programs in most cases
8:44 this model provides funding
8:46 above enrollment levels and
8:48 includes advanced payments at
8:49 the start of the program year.
8:51 Where registered contracts
8:54 exist these advances are
8:56 intended to support providers
8:57 with up front cop operating
9:01 reduce financial volatility
9:04 . While specific payment
9:07 processes vary across early
9:08 childhood program modalities
9:10 and contract types the
9:13 overarching funding structure
9:13 is designed to promote
9:15 stability equity and fiscal
9:16 accountability throughout the
9:20 system
9:21 . Invoices submitted by
9:22 providers are reconciled
9:25 against these advances
9:27 enrollment aleka ble costs and
9:29 approved operating budgets in
9:32 many cases invoice submission
9:34 appropriately occurs after
9:35 required documentation is
9:38 complete or after
9:39 reconciliation with advances
9:42 is necessary as a result
9:42 invoices are not always
9:43 submitted or processed
9:45 processed on a uniform monthly
9:47 schedule this timing reflects
9:48 the structure of the funding
9:50 model and the need to ensure
9:52 accuracy and fiscal
9:53 responsibility New York City
9:54 public schools works closely
9:55 with providers throughout this
9:57 process and remains committed
10:00 to addressing concerns
10:01 resolving issues ensuring and
10:03 ensuring that payments are
10:04 made fairly and properly.
10:08 Although progress in
10:08 responding to those provided
10:10 concerns has been achieved
10:11 over the past two years we
10:13 recognize that we must make
10:16 additional refinements New
10:17 York City public schools with
10:18 support from the City Council
10:20 has undertaken a range of
10:21 efforts to strengthen payment
10:24 processes and improve the
10:26 provider experience.
10:26 Focused on modernizing
10:29 systems and processes that
10:30 support contract management
10:32 documentation and payment
10:34 tracking for early childhood
10:35 providers at the same time we
10:37 recognize that some early
10:39 childhood providers continue
10:41 to face challenges navigating
10:43 the administrative
10:43 requirements associated with
10:44 contracting with the City of
10:45 New York these requirements
10:48 are essential for
10:49 accountability and stewardship
10:51 of public funds but they can
10:52 be difficult to manage without
10:54 sufficient support New York
10:55 City public schools continues
10:58 to offer technical assistance
10:59 to providers to help them
11:01 navigate these administrative
11:03 requirements
11:04 . I will now turn to the
11:06 proposed legislation intro 203 n
11:08 payments to early childhood
11:11 early care and education
11:12 providers New York City public
11:14 schools shares the goal again
11:16 of strengthening transparency
11:18 and accountability connected
11:19 to provider payments and
11:21 welcomes continued partnership
11:22 with the council to advance
11:23 that high priority we look
11:25 forward to working with you on
11:27 the following adjustments t
11:28 othe reporting requirements at
11:31 the same time as drafted the
11:33 bill raises several concerns
11:35 that we believe should be
11:36 addressed to ensure it is
11:38 effective and aligned with how
11:39 payments function and practice
11:43 first quarterly reporting more
11:45 accurately reflects payment
11:46 activity given the use of
11:48 advanced
11:48 . Payments budget approvals
11:51 and reconciliation processes
11:53 quarterly invoice data would
11:53 give the most complete picture
11:55 and provide the clarity of the
11:57 counsel seeks second we look
11:58 forward to working with you t
12:01 oclarify certain definitions
12:01 bless you and the proposed
12:04 legislation to ensure clear
12:05 and meaningful accountability
12:08 finally we believe what the
12:09 proposed changes that this
12:11 report could align and enhance
12:13 other existing public
12:14 reporting like the terms and
12:16 conditions report New York
12:18 City public schools remains
12:20 committed to working with the
12:22 council to improve
12:24 transparency and
12:24 accountability we would
12:25 welcome the opportunity t
12:26 ocollaborate on amendments that
12:29 align reporting requirements
12:31 with existing systems and
12:33 ensure that any New
12:34 obligations advanced share
12:35 goals thank you again for the
12:36 opportunity to be here today I
12:38 look forward to continued
12:40 partnership with the council
12:41 on behalf of New York city's
12:44 children families and early
12:45 care and education providers
12:49 and we've been joined thank
12:49 you for your testimony we've
12:51 been joined um by the sponsor
12:53 of this legislation council
12:57 member and she would like t
12:59 oask some questions about the
13:02 bill thank you
13:02 . Thank you chair good to see
13:04 you do you see you doing good
13:06 good morning my apologies for
13:08 missing a good chunk of your
13:10 testimony so if you covered it o
13:16 much for for wanting to hear
13:17 this bill I I do want t
13:20 oacknowledge that as part of
13:23 two budget negotiations ago as
13:23 part of like the council and
13:26 the administration's
13:27 roundtable a big a big part of
13:28 our discussions were related
13:30 to reporting and on time
13:31 payments and I just want t
13:34 oacknowledge that we spend a
13:34 lot of time on it I know it's
13:36 not perfect but I know that
13:37 there's been tremendous
13:38 headway so I'm really
13:39 interested today in
13:41 understanding the way that you
13:44 were able to provide reports I
13:46 know that those were already
13:47 agreed into terms and
13:48 conditions we obviously want
13:49 to make it and we want to fin
13:51 etune the reporting but I'm
13:52 interested if you could just
13:53 explain a little bit the
13:57 journey before 20 23 20 23 and
14:01 now how to get you know
14:03 everything back on track and I
14:05 think for many of us that