Carriage drivers' union sues in federal court minutes after Romanch's Law is signed, arguing the city is taking medallions without paying for them
TWU Local 100, the Transport Workers Union of America, a medallion owner and two drivers filed in Manhattan federal court Thursday. They want the ban declared unconstitutional and blocked. The city had not answered in court as of Friday.
The Transport Workers Union filed a federal lawsuit against New York City on Thursday, Nov. 19, minutes after Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed Romanch's Law, which ends horse-drawn carriage rides by June 1, 2028, the New York Daily News reported.
According to the Daily News and a statement from the union, the plaintiffs are the Transport Workers Union of America and its Local 100, which represents carriage drivers, along with a medallion owner and two drivers. The union describes the case as a class action. It was filed in federal court in Manhattan.
Why it matters to residents: the case will decide whether the city can end a licensed trade without paying for the medallions its owners bought, and how quickly. It could also shape what the city ends up spending on the transition.
This follows our Thursday story on the signing, written before the complaint was filed.
Advertisement
What the union argues
According to the union's statement, the suit says Int. 943-A violates the U.S. and New York State constitutions and conflicts with earlier court rulings on the limits of the Council's power. It argues that:
- the city cannot ban an entire industry when it could regulate and punish individual violators;
- agency testimony described an industry that generally followed the rules, so the city has not shown regulation failed;
- the delayed effective date, and the lack of similar rules for e-bikes, undercut the public safety rationale;
- the Council was hostile to the industry, which the union compares to a recent appeals court ruling against the city in a case brought by DoorDash.
The Daily News reported that the suit says the law singles out carriage tours while leaving horseback riding and racing alone, and does not explicitly offer owners and drivers "just compensation." The union wants the law declared unconstitutional, arbitrary and capricious, and blocked, according to its statement.
"This bill is an unconstitutional abomination," John Samuelsen, president of the Transport Workers Union of America, said in the statement. One of the plaintiffs' lawyers is former Council Member Benjamin Kallos, the union said.
What the city has said
As of Friday morning we had not seen a city filing in the case. At the signing, Mamdani said, "We understand the responsibility that we hold to facilitate a transition that is both fair and respectful to this industry," the Daily News reported.
Advertisement
Speaker Julie Menin told the Council at Thursday's stated meeting that the law "sets out a path" the administration has begun following so the industry can wind down and its workers can move on (14:39).
The Daily News reported that the mayor has said he will push for the city to buy back the industry's 68 medallions, which it said sell for roughly $400,000 each, and to create job training for drivers and stable hands. The framework the mayor released Tuesday promises help aimed at medallion buybacks but includes no dollar figures, and the law asks the city to "consider" paying owners without requiring it.
The timeline
- Oct. 22: the Council passed the bill, 40-7 with two abstentions (Council release).
- Nov. 19: signed; the suit was filed the same day.
- April 1, 2027: the law's deadline for a worker transition plan.
- June 1, 2028: carriage licenses end.
We will link the docket and report any request for an early court order once we can confirm them in court records.