On My Block · NYC Politics

LegislationLabor

Mamdani signs Romanch's Law, ending carriage rides by June 2028. The drivers' union heads to federal court, and six more bills face Saturday's deadline

The mayor signed the horse carriage ban at City Hall Thursday morning, two days before it would have become law without him. Six other bills sent to him the same day still show no action.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed Romanch's Law on Thursday morning, ending New York City's horse-drawn carriage industry by June 1, 2028. The signing was set for 9:30 a.m. at City Hall, CBS New York reported, and amNY reported that he put his signature to it.

"Our city has changed. Now it is time for our laws to change too," Mamdani said, according to CBS New York. Speaker Julie Menin called it "a truly historic day for New York City," the station reported.

Why it matters to residents: the law ends a trade the mayor called a fixture of Central Park for 150 years, and it affects about 200 drivers, stable hands and medallion owners, by City Hall's estimate. What the city pays them, and whether the law survives in court, are still open.

This follows our Wednesday story on the mayor's transition framework, when the bill was still unsigned.

What the law does

Int. 943-A, from Christopher Marte, passed the Council 40-7 with two abstentions on Oct. 22. According to the Council's release and our earlier reporting:

  • no new carriage, horse or driver licenses on or after June 1, 2028, and existing licenses end May 31, 2028;
  • horses must be placed humanely, and selling them for slaughter is banned;
  • the city must publish a transition plan for the industry's workers by April 1, 2027.

The law is named for Romanch Mahajan, 18, who died after a carriage crash in Central Park in June, ABC7 reported.

The bill went to the mayor on Oct. 22, and he held the required public hearing on Nov. 4. Under the City Charter, a bill he neither signed nor vetoed within 30 days would have become law without his signature, which pointed to Saturday. He had said Nov. 4 he would sign it.

The court fight

TWU Local 100, which represents carriage drivers, said it would file a lawsuit Thursday arguing the law is unconstitutional, amNY reported. CBS New York reported that union leaders, lawyers and workers planned to gather at noon outside the federal courthouse in Manhattan to lay out the challenge. As of late Thursday morning we had not seen a filed complaint; we will link it when it is docketed.

John Samuelsen, president of the Transport Workers Union International, has called the measure a "horrifically flawed and unconstitutional anti-worker bill" that abolishes an industry "without any funding, mandates, or guarantees," CBS New York reported.

What workers have been promised

The framework the mayor released Tuesday promises financial help aimed at medallion buybacks, a training program run with LaGuardia Community College, stipends and a study of electric carriages. It includes no dollar figures. The law asks the city to "consider" paying medallion owners but does not require it.

Six bills still on the desk

The Council sent six other bills to the mayor the same day as the carriage ban. As of Thursday morning our records still listed all six as "Enacted (Mayor's Desk for Signature)," with no signature, veto or mayoral hearing:

  • Int. 978-B, from Farah N. Louis: a higher income limit for the rent freeze programs for seniors and people with disabilities.
  • Int. 296, also from Louis: data on gender-based violence.
  • Int. 786-A, from Selvena N. Brooks-Powers: early mail and absentee ballot procedures for people in city jails.
  • Int. 797, from Public Advocate Jumaane Williams: reports on voter registration and voting in city jails.
  • Int. 853, from Susan Zhuang: a study of how social and economic factors affect access to special education.
  • Int. 927-A, also from Brooks-Powers: a street renaming in Queens.

Unless he vetoes them, they become law either way. Most bills this term have become law without his signature, as we reported.

What's next

  • Saturday, Nov. 21: the six remaining bills are signed, vetoed or become law without a signature.
  • The lawsuit: watch for the union's federal complaint and any request to block the law.
  • April 1, 2027: the transition plan is due, which is where buyback amounts would be expected.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime