On My Block · NYC Politics

Public HealthOversight

Council investigators found banned flavored vapes near a third of the schools they checked, and unlicensed shops paid 0.5% of their fines

The Council's Oversight and Investigations Division visited 222 stores near middle and high schools last spring. Its report sets up Friday's hearing on Int. 1167, which would let the city padlock repeat violators.

Flavored e-cigarettes have been illegal to sell in New York City since a 2019 law. A Council investigation released Wednesday found them on offer at stores within 500 feet of nearly a third of the public middle and high schools it checked, often kept out of sight until a customer asked.

The report, "Behind the Counter," from the Council's Oversight and Investigations Division, comes two days before a joint hearing of the Oversight and Investigations and Consumer and Worker Protection committees at 10 a.m. Friday, Nov. 20, where members will take up Int. 1167, a bill to let the city seal shops that keep breaking the rules.

Why it matters to residents: the stores in the report sit on the blocks students walk to and from school. The report also finds that the city has rarely collected the fines it has imposed on unlicensed sellers.

This follows our Nov. 12 story on the bill and the hearing.

How the investigation worked

Investigators selected 222 businesses within 500 feet of a public middle or high school: all 144 licensed e-cigarette retailers in that radius, plus 78 businesses without an active e-cigarette license that had prior complaints or enforcement actions. They visited in March and April 2026, posing as customers. Of the 222, 193 were open and were included in the analysis.

Because the unlicensed stores were picked for their complaint histories, the report cautions that findings about them "should not be interpreted as representative" of all unlicensed businesses.

What they found

According to the report:

  • Flavors on offer: 121 of the 193 open businesses sold e-cigarettes, and 48 of those, or 40%, offered at least one recognizable banned flavor. That included 28 of 101 licensed sellers and all 20 unlicensed sellers that offered vapes.
  • Near schools: 65 of the 201 schools in the study, or 32%, had a nearby store offering a banned flavor.
  • Behind the counter: at 33 of the 48 stores selling banned flavors, the products came out only after investigators asked for a flavor. In the Bronx's Belmont neighborhood, a clerk around the corner from a middle school showed an investigator an iPad menu of hundreds of flavored options.
  • "Clear" products: 52 licensed sellers offered vapes labeled "clear" but no other recognizable banned flavor. The report says some "clear" products may carry a non-tobacco taste, and investigators found some that appeared to disguise flavors such as watermelon, peach and mint. It did not conclude that every "clear" product breaks city law.
  • Ads near schools: 66 businesses showed tobacco or vape ads or smoking paraphernalia visible from the sidewalk, near 70 of the 201 schools. State law bars such displays within 500 feet of a school.

The fines

Between July 2023 and March 2026, 47 of the surveyed businesses received upheld summonses for selling flavored vapes or selling to people under 21, carrying about $1.62 million in penalties, the report says. Licensed stores accounted for $492,000 and paid about $297,000. Unlicensed stores accounted for about $1.12 million and paid about $5,300, or 0.5%.

The report found no case in which the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection had sealed a business based solely on e-cigarette violations. The department has read its sealing power as covering tobacco violations, and it told the Council that legislation clarifying its authority over e-cigarettes would help, according to the report and the committee report for Friday's hearing.

What Int. 1167 would do

The bill, from Mercedes Narcisse, lets the department's commissioner, after notice and a hearing, order a store sealed if it has been found selling e-cigarettes without a license on at least two occasions within three years, or breaking the city's flavor ban or under-21 sales rule on at least three occasions within three years. It would take effect 60 days after becoming law. Narcisse is its only listed sponsor.

The report also recommends that the department issue guidance on "clear" products, that city and state health agencies step up enforcement of the advertising ban near schools, and that agencies review how fines are collected from repeat violators.

What's next

The hearing is at 250 Broadway on Friday at 10 a.m., chaired by Shekar Krishnan and Harvey D. Epstein. The committee report says the department and health experts were invited to testify. A hearing is not a vote; the bill would need a committee vote before reaching the full Council.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime