City CouncilConsumer Protection
A bill to let the city padlock e-cigarette shops that keep breaking the rules gets its number and a Nov. 20 hearing
Mercedes Narcisse's Int. 1167 would let the consumer protection department seal stores after repeated unlicensed sales, sales to people under 21 or sales of flavored vapes. In March, the department told the Council it already seals some repeat unlicensed sellers.
The bill we listed last week by its draft number, T2026-2791, is now Int. 1167, introduced at Thursday's stated meeting. It gets its first hearing at 10 a.m. Friday, Nov. 20, at a joint meeting of the Committees on Oversight and Investigations, chaired by Shekar Krishnan, and Consumer and Worker Protection, chaired by Harvey D. Epstein. It is the only item on both agendas.
Why it matters to residents: vape shops that sell without a license, to teenagers or in banned flavors are a common complaint to Council offices, and the sponsor says fines have not stopped repeat offenders. A sealed store cannot reopen at that location until the order is lifted.
What the bill would do
The sponsor, Mercedes Narcisse, wrote in her memo that it would let the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection commissioner order a store sealed, after notice and a chance to be heard, when the business has been found:
- selling e-cigarettes without the required city license on at least two occasions within three years, or
- breaking the city's e-cigarette sales rules, including those on sales to people under 21 and on flavored products, on at least three occasions within three years.
A single violation would not trigger a sealing order. The law would take effect 60 days after it is signed. "A store can be cited, pay or ignore the penalty, and keep selling from the same location," Narcisse's memo says, adding that residents often report the same merchants to her office "again and again." The memo notes the city can already padlock unlicensed cannabis shops.
Advertisement
What the department told the Council in March
At the department's March 19 budget hearing, an official said the agency was already "sealing using our own independent powers businesses across the City that are repeat unlicensed actors" (2:02:31). Officials said that in 2025 the department collected about $2.1 million for unlicensed tobacco and e-cigarette sales, from 4,742 violations, and that the fine for operating without one of those licenses is $100 a day (2:05:37). They said the department sealed 57 businesses in 2025 and collected $785,000 in penalties using its own powers (2:06:48), and that it had sued a repeat unlicensed seller on Lenox Avenue and its landlord.
A member at the hearing described stores that "get to three violations" and keep operating at "the same location, same, you know, people," even after repeated visits from the Sheriff's Office. An official called that kind of shuffling "pervasive across all enforcement."
So the bill's main additions would be clear repeat-offense thresholds written into the e-cigarette law and the ability to seal over repeated underage or flavored sales, not just unlicensed ones. The hearing is where the department will say whether it needs that.
Related work
Earlier this year, Gale A. Brewer told the Finance Committee that the Sheriff had closed 93 illegal smoke shops in her district (5:00:47). Consumer department officials said in March that much of the recent smoke shop enforcement was done jointly with the Sheriff's task force, and that the department does not directly enforce the cannabis laws.
What's next
Anyone can testify on Nov. 20 in person at 250 Broadway or online. The bill has one sponsor so far. After the hearing, it would need a committee vote before going to the full Council.