On My Block · NYC Politics

BudgetTransit

The city skipped $200 million it usually pays the MTA for buses this year. A watchdog says the MTA, not the state, absorbed it

Reinvent Albany says the one-time cut helped close the city's budget gap last spring. Gov. Hochul says the state offset it by deferring MTA pension costs and that bus service is unaffected. The Council's budget hearings did not take it up.

New York City is paying $200 million less than usual this fiscal year toward the MTA's bus operations, and the transit agency is covering the difference, the watchdog group Reinvent Albany said in a report released Monday. The group called it a "backdoor" cost shift.

Gov. Kathy Hochul said the group "mischaracterized" the arrangement, amNY reported, and that her administration offset the loss by deferring the MTA's Tier 6 pension costs. "So they have the resources they need," she said.

Why it matters to residents: the city pays the MTA each year to run the bus routes of MTA Bus, the former private lines in Queens, Brooklyn and the Bronx. The cut helped balance the city budget, and the MTA is planning fare and toll increases and projects deficits approaching $900 million by 2030, amNY reported.

What the report says

According to Reinvent Albany, Streetsblog and amNY:

  • The cut was part of a spring package of about $4 billion in state help that closed a city budget gap for fiscal 2027, which runs through June 2027.
  • The city's May budget documents labeled the $200 million savings "State Aid for MTA." The state budget agreement did not mention it.
  • The MTA's July financial plan described a "one-time reduction in the expected city subsidy reimbursement, which will be covered by MTA resources," and said it would still maintain current bus service.
  • City Comptroller Mark Levine's office said in June that the change "was not included in the State's Enacted Budget and must be made in the MTA financial plan."
  • Reinvent Albany said the $200 million roughly cancels out the revenue expected from next year's 4% fare and toll increase.

A Hochul spokesperson told Streetsblog the reduction "has zero impact on bus service for New Yorkers." Mayor Zohran Mamdani's office did not respond to amNY's request for comment.

What the Council heard

We searched our transcripts of this year's Council budget hearings and found no discussion of the $200 million MTA Bus reduction. The Council adopted the fiscal 2027 budget on June 30.

The cut is one-time, according to the MTA's plan, so the question returns with the next budget. Mamdani's November financial plan projects a $6.2 billion gap for fiscal 2028 (our story).

Why the 2004 agreement comes up

Reinvent Albany's Rachael Fauss argued that city aid for MTA Bus is protected under a 2004 agreement between the city and the MTA, when the agency took over the private bus lines, according to Streetsblog. "The problem is that the MTA was made to eat the cost," she told amNY. Betsy Plum of the Riders Alliance said the move "makes New York less affordable and erodes trust in our government," amNY reported.

What's next

  • The MTA board votes on its 2027 budget and final financial plan in December.
  • The mayor's preliminary budget for fiscal 2028 is due in January, and the Council's hearings on it begin in March. That is where any new city payment to MTA Bus would show up.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime