On My Block · NYC Politics

BudgetMayor

Mamdani's November budget update: $129.2 billion this year, a $6.2 billion gap next year, and watchdogs asking for more savings

Tax collections came in nearly $1 billion above forecast. The city found about a quarter of the savings the mayor ordered, the Citizens Budget Commission says. The Council does not vote on this update; its next say comes with the January preliminary budget.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration released its November financial plan update on Nov. 12, raising this fiscal year's budget to $129.2 billion, $3.3 billion more than the budget adopted in June, according to the mayor's office.

The plan projects a $6.2 billion gap for fiscal 2028, which starts next July, $257 million smaller than in June. The gaps grow to $8.7 billion in fiscal 2029 and $9 billion in fiscal 2030.

Why it matters to residents: the November update is the first look at whether the city's money is on track since the budget passed. The gaps it shows are what the mayor and Council will have to close next spring, through savings, new revenue or cuts.

Where the money came from

According to the mayor's office:

  • Taxes: $965 million more in city tax revenue this year than expected in June, from higher collections and a strong Wall Street.
  • Other sources: of the $3.3 billion increase, about $1.15 billion is city money, about $1.48 billion federal and about $635 million state.
  • Savings: $683 million in debt service and agency savings over this year and next, plus $845 million paid early toward next year's bills.
  • Reserves: $7.8 billion this year.

What the watchdogs said

Andrew Rein, president of the Citizens Budget Commission, urged deeper savings, City & State reported. In July the mayor asked agencies for savings of 2.5%, roughly $1 billion; the commission says the plan identifies about $250 million for next year. "Disappointingly, four months after the Mayor directed agencies to find savings," Rein said, the plan includes only a small fraction of the target.

City Comptroller Mark Levine said the update shows how much the budget relies on Wall Street and that the city faces a gap of "more than $6 billion in Fiscal Year 2028," City & State reported. State Comptroller Tom DiNapoli cautioned that revenue growth could slow.

What the Council has said before

The Council does not vote on the November update. It negotiates and adopts the budget each June.

When the Finance Committee questioned the administration on March 25, Speaker Julie Menin said the reported gap had shifted from $12 billion to about $7 billion and lower within weeks, and asked: "What is the real size of the budget gap?" (3:11). She said the Council had identified nearly $1.7 billion in possible revenue and savings, including from vacancies (4:11), and that raising property taxes was "not on the table."

Line items to watch

The plan adds money for some things the Council has held hearings on. We look at those in a separate story and at the youth detention money.

What's next

  • January: the mayor's preliminary budget for fiscal 2028 is due by mid-January under the City Charter.
  • March: the Council holds its preliminary budget hearings, agency by agency.
  • Dec. 3: the Finance Committee has a meeting on the Council's calendar with no items listed yet (meeting page).

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime