City Council

Thursday, November 19, 2026, 1:30 p.m. (New York City time), Council Chambers - City Hall

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Roll-call votes

Documents

Summary

The New York City Council held its stated meeting of November 19, 2026, presided over by Majority Leader Shaun Abreu with communications from Speaker Julie Menin. The meeting opened with roll call and an invocation by Reverend Phillip Jackson of Trinity Church, spread on the record at the request of Council Member Christopher Marte. The Council adopted land use call-ups, rezonings in Council Member Schulman's district, finance resolutions on organizational funding and property tax exemptions, and a package of legislation including bills on electronic property registration, open permits, dental care education, doula resources, fertility treatment education, and Council reporting requirements. Members also voted on resolutions regarding Haiti TPS, emergency contraception vending machines on CUNY/SUNY campuses, IVF tax credits, preimplantation genetic testing coverage, lactation services, Albanian Independence Day, violence against women, and Puerto Rico solidarity. Members introduced numerous new bills in general discussion, including a bill on bike-share age verification, building safety notification after the Flatbush collapse, e-bike battery retailer enforcement, shelter construction disclosure, a ban on stationary transport refrigeration units, AI customer service disclosure, animal welfare, nonprofit contracting, reproductive health safe harbor expansion, and sewage infrastructure requirements.

Transcript

0:03 Please not. We will. Yeah,

0:03 I have your attention,

0:16 please have your attention

0:17 ,please. Quiet on a David,

0:18 please, quiet out of fou

0:20 rweeks started on to take your

0:25 positions at this time at this

0:26 time, please place all

0:27 electronic devices, all of

0:29 devices to vibrate. Majorit

0:32 yleader is all yours. Good

0:37 afternoon and welcome to the

0:38 state meeting of November 1

0:40 92026 I am majority leader

0:42 Shaun Abreu I like to thank

0:43 you for joining us as a

0:45 reminder the core must be

0:46 respected at all times. If you

0:49 like to follow along the

0:50 agenda for today's meeting is

0:51 posted on our web site on

0:54 behalf of the body. I welcome

0:55 the members of the public who

0:56 have joined us today

0:57 , during stated meetings only

0:58 members of the council speak

1:00 members of the public shall

1:01 remain silent if you wish to

1:03 express this your support of

1:06 any remks,ar you make the

1:07 silent approval gesture. Thank

1:12 you.

1:12 Please join us for the

1:13 pledge of allegiance roll call

1:39 aldo ball here. Areola,

2:02 councilmember, areola. You

2:03 cannot hear me? Yes, thank you

2:06 , councilmember.

2:08 Thank you, Avilés presente.

2:13 Thanks. Here, rouer? Yeah,

2:20 Brooks Powers cab on president

2:27 dela Rosa here. Benowitz here

2:33 .incarnation present Epstein

2:39 president are yes, present

2:44 Felder here. Police here

2:51 genero here Gutiérrez when the

2:55 sentence, honey. Here

3:03 ,Hankerson. Thanks. Present

3:08 Hudson present Joseph

3:13 president Krishnan here. Plea

3:19 here, lewis president Maloney

3:28 present marty

3:29 . President Mealy president

3:35 moreno here, Narcisse

3:43 president. Nurse. Oh, say

3:51 president Paladino warning

3:56 wrestler here, reilly

4:00 president salam president

4:04 Justin Sanchez, president.

4:07 Pierina Sanchez present

4:12 . Santos was so here, shellman

4:18 . Yeah

4:19 . Stevens still here. Thomas

4:25 Henry, present president

4:39 bernita Williams and again,

4:47 Wilson here, one present. One.

4:55 Yeah, you are. Yeah, car

5:03 present, agree, ou president

5:05 ,speaker men in here. Thank you

5:12 . We will now have today's

5:14 vacation delivered by reverend

5:16 phillip jackson, director,

5:18 trinity church, wall street.

5:21 Welcome, reverend jackson. O

5:28 hwould like to begin by

5:29 thanking all the members of

5:30 the council. Those who invited

5:33 me and all of you for the work

5:34 that you do my name is Phil

5:39 jackson. Yes, it is. I'm the

5:42 director director, trinity

5:44 church, Eric church, of cours

5:44 e, has been a part of this

5:46 neighborhood for 329 years and

5:50 a. It's the first time tha

5:50 ti've been invited to be here

5:52 and I'm honored to be here. So

5:55 I invite you all to join me in

5:56 prayer as you begin today's

5:57 session, let us pray

6:01 . God, our creator. We thank

6:02 you for bringing us here today

6:04 in service of the people of

6:06 our great City. We thank you

6:09 for this day and for this wor

6:13 k, we pray that you will guide

6:14 our council members and be

6:16 present in their collective

6:17 wisdom as they work to serve

6:22 our neighbors bring the

6:22 mtogether in a spirit of

6:24 humility, integrity and

6:28 openness as they consider the

6:28 issues that affect those who

6:31 City that we all call whom be

6:39 with them in their

6:39 deliberations and decisions

6:43 and we keep in our hearts.

6:44 Those who are homeless

6:47 ,unemployed, sick or hungry and

6:50 all who experience any need or

6:55 want we remember in our

6:55 prayers. Those who are here in

6:57 search of safety and a better

6:59 life for themselves and their

7:03 families. We pray that they

7:06 encounter kindness and

7:06 compassion on their journey.

7:10 We give thanks for all who

7:11 were tirelessly on behalf of

7:14 our neighbors give them

7:15 strength to continue their

7:16 important work and courage and

7:18 hope to sustain them when

7:22 they're discouraged. We thank

7:23 our council members for the

7:24 gift of their service to their

7:26 constituents and to on

7:29 eanother. They be faithful

7:30 representatives of their

7:32 . Neighborhoods while serving

7:33 also the good of our entire

7:38 City, we ask your blessing

7:40 upon them and upon this

7:44 meeting that their labour be

7:45 fruitful and their decisions

7:49 wise in your name, we pray.

7:54 Amen. Thank you. I would now

7:57 ask Council Member Chris

8:00 martin, Christopher Marte

8:00 spread the invocation on the

8:01 record

8:01 . Thank you, majority leader,

8:03 the reverend philip a. Jackson

8:03 was named the nineteenth

8:06 rector of trinity church in

8:09 February 2022 in this

8:10 . Row he serves as a spiritual

8:11 leader of the parish while

8:13 also managing operation parish

8:15 programs, the clergy, staff

8:17 and all resources and

8:18 facilities of the church prior

8:21 to his institution as rector,

8:22 probably, jack said served as

8:24 priest in charge for a years,

8:27 father jackson has focused

8:28 trinity's energy and resources

8:30 on four main areas, offering

8:32 meaningful and beautiful

8:33 worship services and

8:34 opportunities to build

8:36 christian community providing

8:37 programming and support

8:38 through grants and other

8:39 activities for children and

8:41 you supporting New York City

8:42 through outreach grants,

8:44 advocacy and the work with

8:47 local partners and shrank,

8:48 opening our ties with the

8:49 anglican communion and the

8:51 episcopal church for the

8:52 jackson joined trinity church

8:54 in 2015, leading the

8:56 congregation's life has as a

8:58 parent parish through ministry

9:00 programs, including liturgies,

9:02 music education programming

9:03 ,membership and stewardship

9:06 before coming to trinity

9:07 jackson was the director at

9:09 christ church at.

9:10 The ascension in paradise

9:12 valley, arizona, ordained in

9:14 19 94. He also served in

9:16 parishes in houston and

9:18 detroit and was also an

9:20 attorney and honolulu. I

9:21 personally want to tank father

9:23 jackson for all his work.

9:24 Lorraine hank could be a

9:25 really noisy, chaotic place

9:28 where he brings a calm

9:31 foundation to trinity church

9:33 and for many years, trinity

9:35 church thought about

9:35 everywhere else in the world

9:37 under his leadership, he

9:38 continues to think about

9:39 laurie, men and their backyard

9:41 and serving some of our own

9:43 neighbors and New neighbors,

9:44 no matter where they come from

9:44 and I want to thank a from all

9:47 the families that you hav

9:48 ehelped since I've been in

9:50 office from the bottom of our

9:51 hearts. Thank you to you to

9:53 your leadership, your vision

9:54 and citrine ity church I make

9:55 the motion of the anonymous

9:57 consent to spread the

9:58 invocation and full upon the

10:01 record

10:01 . Thank you, councilmember

10:02 adoption of minutes. None.

10:03 Messages and papers from the

10:05 Mayor 1 0 2 2 2 1 4 meryl

10:08 appointments refer to rules

10:11 communication from City,

10:11 county and bar offices 1 0 5

10:17 and 1 0 6 budget modifications

10:18 . Referred to finance

10:18 petitions of communications,

10:20 none lanyards call ups m 10710

10:25 130 eighth street. Thank

10:25 . You. I would ask that the

10:26 clerk take a world call vote

10:27 on today's land use crawl up,

10:30 thank you. Shulman

10:33 . Permission to vote on all

10:35 items on today's stated agenda

10:37 . Permission granted, I anne

10:37 all aldo bowl I Ana arriola,

10:46 high and all. Thank you. A

10:49 village I Banks I Brewer? Yes,

10:59 Brooks Powers cab on I

11:04 delarosa high

11:05 . Thank you. Dinner wits high.

11:12 Encarnación I Epstein oh,

11:27 let's remember Epstein lan

11:28 duse. Close, please. Hi. Thank

11:31 you. Very.

11:31 I would I? Felder, I felice,

11:37 I I know I I thank you,

11:43 Gutiérrez, I Shahana Hanif

11:49 Hankerson hank's I. Hudson I

11:56 Joseph, I. Krishnan, I ble I.

12:00 Lewis, I. Maloney her mission

12:06 to vote on all matters covered

12:07 coupled on general orders

12:12 calendar permission granted, I

12:14 eye iona. Thank you,

12:17 councilman martek. I merely I

12:21 murano, I Narcisse about Nurse

12:29 . Oh, say I Paladino rustler

12:41 high Riley I salam bara,

12:44 Justin Sanchez I, marina

12:51 Sanchez. I thank you. Santos

12:53 was so I thank you, Stevens, I

12:58 , Thomas Henry I on? I bernick

13:12 aww Williams. Hello, chair.

13:13 I'd like to request

13:16 . Formacion symbol of couples

13:17 on

13:18 . The general where it.

13:19 Happened to permission

13:24 granted. Thank you so much I

13:24 ,one and all one. Oh, I don't

13:43 know huang I car I you I

13:52 speaker mennen I. Today's land

14:03 use call ups are adopted by a

14:05 vote of 45 in the affirmative

14:07 zone, the negative. Thank you.

14:09 We will not have communication

14:10 from speaker Julie Menin

14:13 . Good afternoon, everyone.

14:14 Ah, earlier this morning I

14:16 was so proud to stand with

14:18 colleagues and alongside the

14:19 Mayor as he signed the

14:21 official bill of romances law

14:23 into law what it.

14:28 Was truly monumental to

14:30 usher in a New chapter of

14:33 safety, security and mos

14:34 timportantly humanity in the

14:35 story of our City, but as much

14:38 as a welfare of our animals

14:39 and the health of our

14:40 residents. We also sought t

14:41 oprotect the livelihoods of the

14:45 dedicated workers this

14:46 legislation sets out a path

14:47 that the administration has

14:48 already started moving towards

14:50 to ensure the industry can

14:51 wind down and its workers can

14:54 successfully transitioned out

14:57 of it yesterday,

14:58 representative landmark chu as

14:59 we released a report exposing

15:02 the wide spread availability

15:05 of flavored e cigarettes and

15:08 shapes products that let's be

15:09 clear already already illegal

15:12 to south. Thanks for that the

15:13 City Council passed in 20 19

15:17 since the council's oversight

15:19 and investigations division

15:19 and I really want to thank

15:20 them for their amazing work

15:23 has gone into 193 businesse

15:27 slocated within 500 feet of a

15:29 public middle or high school

15:30 across the five boroughs. Our

15:34 investigation found that 40%

15:36 of shop survey that carried e

15:38 cigarettes offered products

15:40 with a prohibited flavor and

15:41 nearly

15:41 . A third of the schools

15:43 surveyed had shops with

15:45 prohibited advertising within

15:48 500 feet. Currently the

15:49 department of consumer and

15:51 worker protection does not

15:52 have the authority to close a

15:54 business solely for unlicense

15:56 dor flavored e cigarette sales.

15:58 Instead, they can issue a

16:00 simple slap on the wrist in

16:00 the form of of a fine.

16:04 Tomorrow. However, we will

16:05 hear a bill sponsored by

16:07 Council Member Mercedes nursey

16:10 to give the authority to close

16:13 a business if they have three

16:15 violations of selling e

16:18 cigarettes and will continue

16:19 to look for ways tha

16:21 tstrengthen enforcement of

16:22 advertising restrictions near

16:25 schools. Vape ce our risk t

16:26 othe health of our children and

16:27 let's be clear about that

16:29 these flavored e cigarettes

16:31 are marketed with flavors,

16:33 bubble gum flavor candy cane

16:36 flavor and packaging marketed

16:37 to our kids who have

16:39 developing lungs, and we all

16:40 know there is an explosive

16:42 rise of cancer among young

16:43 people here in the City. So

16:46 this is an important public

16:47 health issue. It's our

16:49 responsibility to deliver o

16:50 nour vision of a safer,

16:51 healthier City for every New

16:52 yorker who calls it home as

16:55 part of the council's

16:57 oversight role. We also held a

16:58 hearing to ask about the cost

17:01 and the performance of the

17:02 department of education school

17:05 bussing operations, pupil

17:06 transportation is dios third

17:10 largest contract category at

17:13 $2.28 billion in fiscal 20 27

17:17 and more taxpayer dollars are

17:17 being spent and ever before as

17:20 part of our contract review of

17:21 the contracts we had requested

17:23 from dewey. I just want to be

17:24 clear. Many of these bus

17:27 contracts literally go back t

17:28 othe 1970s and then and are

17:29 just renewed each year. Yet

17:33 this growth has not led to

17:35 improve service and New

17:36 yorkers are not experiencing

17:38 any additional benefit and we

17:39 all know this is having a

17:42 disproportionate effect,

17:43 particularly on our special

17:45 needs students. We are

17:46 committed to transparency

17:47 about how a third of our

17:48 budget is spent and to make

17:50 sure the next contracts a day

17:52 selects deliver the services

17:53 in yorkers are paying for

17:57 . Looking to next week. I want

17:58 to wish everyone in early, but

18:00 a very happy thanksgiving,

18:00 hoping you have a wonderful

18:02 time spent with loved ones.

18:04 I'm incredibly thankful to all

18:06 of you as colleagues and his

18:07 friends for the hard work that

18:09 you and all of your teams do

18:12 every single day to serve our

18:13 constituents and all New

18:16 yorkers.

18:16 And on a personal note, very

18:17 excited about the thanksgiving

18:19 day parade hope many of you

18:20 will end up being able to go

18:23 and to join, bring family and

18:24 loved ones and friends the

18:27 Saturday after thanksgiving is

18:29 small business Saturday and

18:30 let's.

18:30 Be honest, it's a wonderful

18:31 that New York is home t

18:33 oalmost 200000 small businesses

18:36 that employ nearly adrienne

18:39 million New yorkers truly

18:40 forming the backbone of our

18:43 great City as a four more

18:44 small business owner myself a

18:46 no. First that every customer

18:48 is crucial to these

18:49 institutions whether you're

18:50 getting a meal at a restaurant

18:53 buying a New something at a

18:55 clothing store or finding your

18:56 favorite book at a bookstore

18:59 . Please join me in wishing a

19:01 belated happy birthday to

19:03 Council Member Kevin

19:06 . Reilly is celebrated on the

19:08 six cheap and a happy early

19:10 birthday to Council Member

19:11 Eric Dinowitz, birthday's on

19:12 the 21, so I also want she

19:18 would knowledge in New York

19:20 City legend an icon, bill

19:22 ritter and his wife, kathleen,

19:24 and all if there's w

19:25 colleagues who have made it

19:28 here.

19:29 We were so thrilled and I

19:30 know many of you were here t

19:31 ojoin us to present a

19:33 proclamation to recognize his

19:36 David decades of service and

19:37 thank you to Council Member

19:38 Brewer. I know how important

19:39 this was to you. I'm bill. We

19:43 thank you so much for the

19:45 years and years and years of

19:49 incredible reporting you've

19:49 given to our City to the world

19:52 of journalism and most

19:53 importantly to the pursuit of

19:56 truth.