Thursday, November 19, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 2
Committee: Committee on Immigration
The Committee on Immigration met to vote on a resolution calling on the U.S. Senate to pass and the president to sign S. 4814 (referred to in the transcript as both "s 4 8 1 4 2" and "s 48 2 14"), which would require the Secretary of Homeland Security to designate Haiti for Temporary Protected Status (TPS) through April 29, 2029. The chair, identified in roll call as Chair Encarnación, recounted Haiti's history of disasters and gang violence and criticized the termination of Haiti's TPS designation, noting the State Department's travel warning against Haiti. Council Member Joseph spoke in support, describing the roughly 40,000 Haitian TPS holders in New York State and arguing the Senate must act. The resolution was adopted with a vote of five in the affirmative, zero in the negative, and no abstentions.
0:13 Even better good morning and
0:13 welcome to today's New York
0:15 City Council vote from the
0:16 committee on immigration at
0:18 this time I'd like to remind
0:19 everyone to.
0:20 Police house there
0:21 electronic devices and no no
0:22 point is anyone to approach
0:23 the dais chair we are ready t
0:27 obegin good morning everyone I
0:30 am Council Member all of whip
0:32 of the New York City Council
0:34 and chair of the committee on
0:36 immigration today we are
0:37 voting on councilmember for
0:38 errol lewis's resolution 6 2 6 d
0:42 states senate to pass and the
0:44 president to sign s 4 8 1 4 2
0:48 require the secretary
0:49 secretary of homeland security
0:51 to designate haiti for
0:53 temporary protective status or
0:56 tps the committee heard this
0:58 resolution on September 22 an
1:00 dreceived ample testimony in
1:01 support of this bill we are
1:03 joined today by my counsel
1:05 colleagues Council Member
1:07 Avilés Council Member hank's
1:09 Council Member Joseph and
1:10 council on that's right now
1:12 later time t
1:20 . T p secretary of the
1:23 department of homeland
1:24 security for countries
1:26 experiencing ongoing armed
1:27 conflict environmental
1:28 disasters or other
1:30 extraordinary and temporary
1:32 conditions immigrants have
1:33 been granted tps that have
1:35 been granted tps are protected
1:38 against detention and
1:39 deportation on the basis of
1:42 their immigration status in
1:45 2010 haiti received a first
1:46 received the t designation
1:49 after experiencing massive and
1:51 devastating earthquake and
1:52 since then has suffered
1:53 through an epidemic another
1:56 earthquake a tropical storm a
1:58 presidential assassination the
2:00 resignation of their prime
2:01 minister and widespread gang
2:04 violence despite these
2:06 atrocities the trump
2:08 administration to terminated
2:09 haiti's tps status in July 26
2:13 in a cruel twist of irony the
2:15 u s department of state's
2:17 latest travel advisory about
2:18 haiti warns u s citizens
2:20 against traveling there for
2:22 any reasons due to the risk
2:25 associated with crime
2:27 terrorism kidnapping unrest
2:28 and limited health care.
2:29 Yet the administration has
2:31 already deported more than 450
2:35 haitians in recent weeks its
2:37 landing amid a surge and
2:39 kidnapping and gang violence
2:40 across haiti our haitian
2:42 communities have measured have
2:44 immeasurably enriched our City
2:46 and haitian recipients belong
2:48 here in New York not in harm's
2:50 way.
2:51 I am proud to co sponsor
2:53 this resolution and thank
2:54 Council Member luis for
2:56 introducing it I would like t
2:57 othank the committee staff for
2:58 their work on this hearing
3:00 including senior legislative
3:01 council nicole kata senior
3:04 legislative policy policy
3:06 analyst rebecca barilla
3:08 principal financial analyst
3:09 navi beans and assistant
3:10 finance director florentine
3:12 kabir finally I like to thank
3:14 thank staff staff especially
3:14 my chief of staff stephanie
3:16 herrera and anyone working on
3:17 the background to make this
3:19 hearing run smoothly I would
3:20 like to open it to any members
3:21 who like to make a statement
3:25 . Council Member Joseph thank
3:27 you thank you chair and thank
3:28 you to my colleague
3:30 councilmember Farah lewis for
3:32 carrying this resolution today
3:33 we vote on a resolution
3:34 calling on the united states
3:35 senate to pass and the
3:37 president to sign s 48 2 14
3:39 the bill does one simple thing y
3:42 of homeland security t
3:44 odesignate haiti for temporary
3:47 protective status through
3:49 April 29 2020 , nine the
3:50 families this bill protects
3:51 live here about 40000 haitian
3:54 tps holders call New York
3:55 state home most of them in
3:57 brooklyn and queens and in
3:58 neighborhoods like the ones I
4:00 represent
4:01 . They are nurses home health
4:02 aides they are parents of
4:03 children in our public schools l
4:08 businesses and keep our
4:09 hospital staff this summer
4:10 after the supreme court
4:11 allowed the administration t
4:12 oend tps for haiti those
4:15 protections disappeared are
4:16 City has had to let go of
4:18 employees who lost their job
4:21 authorization insists since
4:21 deportation flights have left
4:23 for haiti every single week
4:25 those flights are going to a
4:26 country in crisis gang
4:29 violence kidnappings and the
4:31 collapse of basic institution
4:33 one recent attack killed 4
4:36 7people so that a dozen
4:37 hostages including including
4:38 children are own state
4:39 department one americans not
4:40 to travel to haiti we cannot
4:42 tell our citizens it is too
4:43 dangerous to visit and then
4:46 tell our neighbors is safe
4:47 enough to live the court said
4:49 judges cannot override this
4:51 decision that puts it squarely
4:52 in congress's hand.
4:53 The house has already acted
4:56 a bipartisan majority passed
4:58 the companion bill in the
5:00 president has said he wants t
5:01 owork with congress and
5:03 immigration.
5:03 Here's the place to start
5:04 the senate must act then it
5:07 must act now haitians are not
5:08 temporary they are New yorkers e
5:12 my colleagues to do the same
5:13 messy and ill thank you
5:14 . Thank you so much
5:16 councilmember I also like t
5:17 oto acknowledge that we've been
5:18 joined by councilmember Brewer
5:21 any last requests for
5:23 statements no okay I now turn
5:27 it to you you you wrote it
5:30 wrote it already um to do t
5:33 otake world call
5:35 . Sorry apologies ben jacobs
5:38 quid the clerk of the City
5:39 council committee on
5:40 immigration.
5:40 This is the roll call vote
5:42 on resolution 606
5:44 . Chair Encarnación I
5:45 councilman breaux hills
5:47 proudly vote I in standing in
5:50 full and unapologetic
5:51 solidarity with the haitian
5:53 community Council Member
5:55 Brewer
5:55 . Very supportive of the
5:56 haitian community about I
5:59 councilmember Hanks
5:59 . I vote I Council Member
6:03 Joseph I vote aye again thank
6:06 you with the vote of five in
6:07 the affirmative zero in the
6:09 negative and no abstentions
6:09 the item is adopted thank you
6:15 and our closest committee