Committee on Fire and Emergency Management

Friday, November 20, 2026, 9:30 a.m. (New York City time), Council Chambers - City Hall

Committee: Committee on Fire and Emergency Management

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Committee on Fire and Emergency Management, jointly with the Committee on Housing and Buildings, held an emergency oversight hearing on residential fires and the dangers of lithium-ion batteries, following fatal fires in the Bronx and Sunset Park. Speaker Julie Menin, chairs Joann Ariola and Pierina Ana Sanchez, and multiple council members pressed FDNY, HPD, and the Department of Buildings on rising fire deaths (90 fatalities in 2026 to date, over 400 lithium-ion battery fires this year), inspections, education campaigns, and enforcement of existing laws. The committees discussed a package of bills including Intro 920 (removing the residential fire code exemption for charging mobility devices), Intro 1174 (a public fire data dashboard), Intro 1175 (electrical capacity studies of older buildings), Intro 1184 (targeted outreach and enforcement plan), Intro 1189 (increased penalties), and Intro 1202 (lowering the threshold for sealing violating retailers). Agency representatives expressed support for some bills and concerns about others, particularly criminalizing or penalizing individual possession of uncertified devices. No votes were taken; public testimony was heard from unions, delivery workers, safety advocates, and family members of fire victims.

Transcript

1:53 Thank you. Good morning an

1:53 dwelcome to the committee on

1:55 fire and emergency management,

1:57 joining with housing and

2:00 buildings. These your phone on

2:01 vibrate or silent mold at any

2:02 time during this hearing do

2:03 not approach the day is thank

2:04 you for your cooperation chair

2:06 . We are ready to begin. Good

2:15 morning. I am Council Member

2:17 Joann Ariola to the committee

2:18 on fire and emergency

2:20 management, I would first lik

2:21 eto acknowledge our speaker,

2:22 Julie Menin, is here today and

2:24 who I would like to thank for

2:26 her leadership on this very

2:28 pressing issues that we are

2:28 here to discuss

2:31 . This hearing is being held

2:32 jointly with the committee on

2:34 housing and buildings. I would

2:35 also like to thank era Pierina

2:38 Sanchez for holding today's

2:40 hearing and acknowledge the

2:42 fire and emergency management

2:45 committee members wang salam

2:51 zoom on, Virginia Maloney on

2:54 zoom De La Rosa. Ah, I think

3:00 that's that,

3:01 uh, today the committee will

3:03 be discussing oversight on

3:05 residential fires and the

3:06 dangers of lithium ion

3:08 batteries as well as hearing

3:12 related legislation over the

3:13 past few years as scooters and

3:15 powered mobility devices have

3:16 become more prevalent the City

3:19 has experienced a rapid

3:21 increase in lithium ion

3:22 battery related fires, both in

3:24 residential and commercial

3:28 properties like no, no, not

3:29 only destroys property, but

3:30 results in in and fatalities

3:34 in fiscal year 20 26. The

3:36 experience over 25000

3:39 structural fires, of which

3:39 more than 21000 occurred in a

3:44 residential occupancies, an

3:45 increase of nearly 1300 when

3:47 compared to the prior fiscal

3:50 year during the 20 25 during

3:53 20 25 investigated 292 lithium

3:56 ion battery related fires in

3:58 the City a total that I

3:59 snearly 10 times the amount of

4:02 reported battery related fires

4:02 in 20 20. Additionally, there

4:05 has been a massive spike in

4:07 fires related to lithium ion

4:09 batteries this year, including

4:12 two fatal residential fires,

4:13 one in the south bronx and one

4:15 in sunset park, which is still

4:18 under investigation.

4:19 And those have resulted in

4:19 the death of 10 individuals

4:21 and among them were children

4:24 in 20 23, the committee passed

4:26 legislation related to lithium

4:27 ion battery safety and

4:28 intended to mitigate the

4:30 safety risks related to the

4:31 proper use of e bikes and

4:33 lithium ion batteries since

4:36 then, although the number of

4:37 injuries and deaths had

4:39 declined until this year, the

4:40 number of related incidences

4:43 have risen. I want to be very

4:45 clear to this administration.

4:48 We must have enforcement of

4:49 our city's laws for them to b

4:52 eeffective. To that end, the

4:53 committees will also hear a

4:54 package of legislation that

4:55 aims to protect New yorkers

4:57 from these dangerous batteries

4:59 by increasing public awareness

5:01 and establishing regulations

5:02 regarding the charging and

5:04 storage of lithium ion

5:06 batteries to help mitigate the

5:07 fire safety risks proposed by

5:09 these batteries and motorized

5:10 bikes and schooled earth. We

5:11 will be hearing seven bills

5:14 six or seven of which are six

5:16 of which are on fire and

5:18 emergency management and one

5:21 by our accompanying co co

5:25 committee.her and

5:29 introduction hundred 2

5:29 0sponsored by counsel number

5:32 one removes the exception in

5:33 the New York City fire code

5:34 that allows the storage and

5:36 charging a mobility devices in

5:38 a drilling unit in a group are

5:43 to occupancy building

5:44 introduction number 11 74

5:45 ,sponsored by chair. Sanchez

5:47 requires the fire department's

5:48 maintain a publicly accessible

5:51 dashboard displaying dat

5:52 arelated to fire emergencies

5:55 the dashboard would display

5:56 data, including the

5:57 approximate date time

5:57 ,location and cause of each

5:59 fire over the period of the

6:01 prior two years uses of the

6:04 dashboard would be able t

6:05 ofilter and view this

6:06 information on charts and maps

6:09 introduction 11 84, which is a

6:11 bill I have introduced

6:13 requires the department of

6:14 consumer and worker protectio

6:17 nand the fire department t

6:17 odevelop and implement a

6:20 targeted outreach, inspection

6:21 and enforcement plan to

6:22 mitigate the risk of death

6:24 ,injury and property damage

6:25 resulting from fires caused by

6:28 certain powered bicycles,

6:29 power mobility devices and

6:31 storage batteries used by such

6:35 devices. The goal of such plan

6:35 would be to reduce the sale

6:38 use and possession of the

6:40 products that we do that do

6:41 not meet safety out safety

6:43 standards that are established

6:44 by local laws and ensure that

6:48 devices and storage batteries

6:49 are stored and charged and a

6:52 matter consistent with the

6:54 real relevant fire code

6:57 requirements

6:58 . Introduction 11 89

6:58 ,sponsored by council members

7:00 make it unlawful to store

7:03 handle, use or possess a

7:05 powered bicycle motor, a

7:06 powered mobility device or a

7:08 storage battery for such

7:11 devices unless the equipment

7:12 meets the relevant standards

7:13 for sale established by local

7:17 law, the bill would establish

7:19 civil penalties, not criminal

7:21 r thfoose who violate and

7:24 possess at possession violate

7:25 the possession ban.

7:27 Additionally, the bill would

7:29 amend existing penalties for

7:30 the sale of such products such

7:33 that an individual would be

7:34 guilty of a misdemeanor

7:35 punishable by up to one yea

7:38 rof imprisonment in addition to

7:39 the civil penalty of up t

7:43 o$1000 for each violation.

7:44 Those are for the people who

7:45 are selling these products.

7:49 Finally, a person who

7:50 assembles or cells a secon

7:52 duse storage battery would be

7:53 liable for a civil penalty of

7:55 up to $1000 and would be

7:59 guilty of misdemeanor

8:01 punishable by a one year of

8:04 imprisonment introduction

8:05 number 12 to sponsored by

8:07 Council Member Susan the

8:10 threshold needed for the

8:11 department of sumer compared

8:12 affairs and worker protectio

8:15 nand the fire department t

8:16 oseal the premises of retailers

8:18 that violate local laws

8:20 establishing safety standards

8:22 for the distribution sale and

8:23 lease and rental of powered

8:26 bicycles, power mobility

8:27 devices or storage of

8:28 batteries for such devices.

8:32 Ceiling would be permitted

8:32 after the retailer received

8:34 violations on at least two

8:36 occasions in a two year period

8:38 , whereas currently the

8:40 premise can only be sealed.

8:41 Premises can only be sealed

8:43 after a retailer receives

8:46 violations on at least three

8:47 occasions during a three yea

8:51 rperiod the committee wants t

8:51 oexamine the circumstances

8:53 surrounding the current spike

8:53 of e bike related fires over

8:55 the past year, evaluate the

8:58 response to this continued

8:59 safety risk and consider New,

9:02 stronger measures to mitigate

9:02 fire risks are rising from

9:04 these devices. We look forward

9:06 to the from the administration

9:07 on this legislation later in

9:10 and intend to work

9:12 collaboratively to find

9:14 appropriate solutions t

9:15 odecrease the ever growing

9:17 problem of residential fires

9:18 related to the storage and

9:20 charging of e bikes and

9:20 lithium ion batteries. I will

9:23 not. I would like to thank

9:25 josh kingsley, our committee

9:26 counsel will hung ash, our

9:28 senior analyst and my chief of

9:29 staff phyllis and working so

9:33 hard to put our portion of

9:35 this this hearing together,

9:38 and I will now turn the

9:39 microphone over to speaker men

9:40 in for her remarks. Thank

9:42 . You so much chair. I'm Julie

9:43 Menin, of the New York City

9:45 council. I first of all want

9:46 you to thank chair areola and

9:51 chair Sanchez for holding this

9:52 hearing? I asked for this

9:54 emergency hearing because we

9:55 are in an emergency. The

9:58 numbers in terms of fatalitie

10:02 s. Injuries are just completely

10:05 unacceptable. This is a crisis

10:07 of epic proportions, a council

10:08 has passed a bill after bill

10:11 after bill and yet the problem

10:14 is getting worse, not better.

10:15 And so we want to have a

10:20 real discussion, a real

10:21 oversight hearing about why

10:23 this is happening, so let me

10:25 first of all say that before I

10:27 begin anymore in terms of

10:28 remarks I want to acknowledge

10:29 the lives that have been los

10:33 tin addition to the individuals

10:33 that are now living with long

10:36 term medical conditions as a

10:37 result of the thousands of

10:38 fires that have occurred I

10:39 nnew York City this year in

10:41 their honor. Let's pause for a

10:42 moment of silence. Thank you

10:56 so, as the chair said in

10:58 fiscal year 20 26 in New York

11:01 City experienced over 25000

11:04 structural fires, of which

11:05 more than 21000 occurred in

11:08 apartments or houses an

11:10 increase of almost 1300 fires

11:13 compared to the prior year. F

11:16 y has disclosed that more than

11:20 2200 of these were serious

11:22 fires that required response.

11:23 Crews of at least 60.

11:28 Tragically these fires

11:30 caused 82 fatalities and 54

11:34 life threatening and just

11:36 injuries to civilians before I

11:38 say anything more I first want

11:40 to thank the members of our

11:43 fire department. We know that

11:43 every day they are putting

11:44 their lives on the line to

11:47 save others exemplifying what

11:48 it means to be New york's

11:51 bravest, and we know that they

11:52 know and want to do everythin

11:55 gthey can to prevent fires in

11:58 the future.

11:59 According to y the top non

12:01 incendiary causes of fires in

12:02 New York City are as follows

12:05 electrical fires due to

12:07 overloaded outlets are faulty

12:10 wiring, candles and smoking

12:11 heating equipment such as

12:13 space cedars and electrical

12:16 blankets and unfortunately,

12:18 more recently, lithium ion

12:20 battery failures in recent

12:21 years, the City Council has

12:23 experienced a sharp increase

12:25 with e bikes and scooters.

12:32 Such fires present unique

12:35 challenges to firefighting

12:36 operations as a spread very

12:40 quickly. They oftentimes

12:41 difficult to extinguish and

12:43 they can produce a gases as of

12:49 November 2026, this City has

12:51 . Experience over 400 lithium

12:54 ion battery fires year to date

12:56 and increase in 292 such fires

12:59 that occurred during all of 2

13:04 025. So these numbers are just

13:06 skyrocketing fatalities and

13:07 injuries, some with ion

13:09 battery fires have also

13:11 increases here, rising from 51

13:14 injuries and one death in 2

13:20 025 2 83 injuries and 12 deaths

13:21 so far in 20 26, most recently

13:26 on October 28 at a fire at a

13:29 bronx nature development

13:30 killed a child to teenagers

13:32 and the 33 year old mother of

13:34 one of the teens. The cost an

13:37 e bike that was charging in

13:39 the apartment's kitchen caught

13:41 fire and the devices location

13:43 near a doorway blocked the

13:45 family's escape from their

13:49 apartment less than a week

13:49 later in a fire at a

13:51 residential building in sunset

13:52 park, brooklyn, a building

13:52 where the presence of bikes

13:54 and with ion batteries was

13:57 being investigated by fire

13:59 marshals six people were

14:00 killed and nine injured. Thes

14:04 eincidents are more than a.

14:05 They are entirely

14:08 preventable and they

14:09 represents safety failures at

14:10 the highest level

14:14 . We know that y issues

14:15 guidance related to safe use

14:17 and storage of lithium ion

14:19 batteries. We know that many

14:21 buildings have issued rules

14:23 pertaining to the safe storage

14:24 of e bikes and scooters and.

14:27 We know that the department

14:29 of consumer and worker

14:31 protection has worked to get

14:33 illegal or unsafe batteries

14:34 off the streets and out of our

14:37 stores, but we need to do for

14:40 better with the proliferation

14:43 of electric mobility devices

14:44 in New York City. This cannot

14:47 be the New normal. We cannot

14:50 allow these fires to continu

14:52 ehappening.

14:53 We cannot accept the loss of

14:54 even one more life. We simply

14:57 cannot, and that is why we

14:58 call this emergency hearing

15:00 . At today's hearing. We are

15:02 eager to understand what more

15:04 we can be doing

15:05 . Why some of the City Council

15:07 laws are not being fully

15:08 enforced to the highest levels

15:11 and really what we can do t

15:13 oensure that we are protecting

15:14 New yorkers and ensure that

15:16 these tragedies never happe

15:17 nagain. I'll turn it back t

15:19 othe chair at this point. Thank

15:22 you,

15:23 thank you, speaker men in

15:24 chair Sanchez.

15:25 Thank you so much chair,

15:27 areola and thank you both

15:28 chair and speaker for

15:30 centering this immense problem

15:31 within our City. Good morning.

15:34 I'm councilmember beauty Ana

15:36 ,chair of the committee on

15:37 housing and buildings on

15:39 behalf of our committees in

15:40 the council welcome and thank

15:41 you for being with us today to

15:44 discuss residential fires and

15:45 the dangers of lithium ion

15:48 batteries.

15:49 We are here today as my

15:50 colleagues have said because

15:52 of heartbreak in a lithium ion

15:54 battery caught fire in a bronx

15:56 nycha apartment as a speaker

16:00 just mentioned gratitude

16:00 accounts member incarnation

16:01 and her work supporting that

16:02 family in that community

16:05 eight days later, a fire and

16:06 sunset park killed six mor

16:08 enew yorkers and injured nin

16:10 eand also gratitude to council

16:12 members rank for being there

16:17 for those families.

16:17 Too many to count, it feels

16:18 in my district and the west

16:20 bronx includes council felice

16:22 and also our sister community

16:24 in washington heights council

16:25 De La rosa's district. It

16:28 feels like fires are an

16:29 unfortunate means day

16:32 . For many of us are council

16:33 tenure began with the horrific

16:36 twin parks northwest tragedy,

16:38 which claims 17 lives after a

16:40 space heater malfunctioned and

16:43 doors failed to self close and

16:44 Council Member for liz's

16:47 district,

16:48 we promised then to to do

16:50 better. We passed many, many

16:52 bills and the problem remains

16:55 gratitude. Always first to the

16:57 first responders at y and I

16:58 want to also include a special

16:59 mention of New York City

17:01 emergency management for your

17:03 increased efforts to spread

17:04 awareness in the west bronx.