Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection

Thursday, November 12, 2026, 11 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 3

Committee: Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection held a vote on Proposed Intro 891-A, sponsored by Speaker Menin, concerning surveillance pricing. Chair Harvey D. Epstein described the history of fixed pricing, noting that businesses can now use consumer personal data to offer different prices to different consumers for the same goods. The bill would prohibit businesses from engaging in surveillance pricing. The committee voted to approve the bill, with the vote recorded as nine in the affirmative and none in the negative, with no abstentions. The meeting was then adjourned.

Transcript

0:12 Guys ready good morning and

0:12 welcome to the New York City

0:17 council vote for the committee

0:19 on consumer worker protection

0:22 at this time please put all

0:24 devices on silent and no one

0:26 should approach the dais chair g

0:31 everyone welcome to this

0:33 consumer worker protection

0:34 committee vote on proposed

0:36 intro hundred 91 a sponsored

0:39 by speaker mennen

0:40 relationships of family

0:41 pricing I'm Harvey Epstein of

0:43 the committee I'm joined by my

0:46 colleagues Brewer De La Rosa

0:49 Krishnan Schulman had a ball

0:50 Wilson and we have a quorum so

0:55 when you yorkers go to the

0:55 store we generally expect that

0:56 we can look at a tag or a

0:58 shelf label to see how much an

0:59 item costs these prices are

1:02 typically not negotiable and

1:03 we expect them to be the same

1:04 for every shopper at least in

1:06 the short term but shopping is

1:07 not always been this way

1:08 before the 18 hundred

1:10 sconsumers largely had t

1:11 ohaggle over a price of goods

1:13 and services they wished to

1:15 purchase this allowed

1:16 merchants to charge different

1:17 consumers different amounts

1:19 for the same product depending

1:20 on the well willingness to pay

1:23 even these economic realities

1:24 are always a group of people

1:24 who believe it was morally

1:26 wrong to charge different

1:27 prices for the same goods one

1:29 of those people I was the

1:32 founder of macy's roland

1:34 hussey macy's began putting

1:35 price tags in the 1870s it

1:38 turned out these prices that

1:40 benefit both consumers and

1:42 shopkeepers consumers could

1:44 easily compare shops while

1:45 stores can make train New

1:47 employees simplify simplify

1:49 accounting systems and it

1:49 really saved time for everyone o

1:53 today's technology has changed

1:54 the system businesses are able

1:56 to use consumer personal data

1:58 to offer different price

2:00 options to different consumers

2:01 with the the same goods and

2:02 services this practice known

2:04 as surveillance pricing t

2:05 otoday's intro hundred 9

2:08 1prohibit businesses from

2:08 engaging in surveillance

2:10 pricing I congratulate the

2:11 speaker on the bill which is a

2:12 major step on transparency

2:14 consistency around pricing and

2:17 discounts offers consumers ah

2:19 now off asta kirk to call the

2:22 roll call.

2:23 Good morning uh can we on

2:25 consumer and worker protection

2:26 protection ben jacobs quinn

2:27 this is the the roll vote on

2:28 intro 891 a chair Epstein yes

2:34 Council Member.

2:35 Yes it's my understanding

2:36 too that the state is

2:38 considering has passed the

2:39 governor hopefully will sign

2:40 and that these bills are

2:42 compatible that was of concern

2:43 of mine thank you very much

2:45 yes.

2:45 Councilmember De La Rosa I

2:48 thank you Council Member

2:52 Council Member christiane I

2:56 councilman burrell would I

2:59 councilmember shulman I

3:02 Council Member Banks I

3:06 raye Council Member the vote

3:19 stands at nine of the

3:20 affirmative not in the

3:21 negative with no abstentions

3:24 thank you everyone would you

3:25 like to hold the

3:25 . Vote open I don't think we

3:26 need to heap the roll open I

3:30 don't think ariel

3:31 . I always heard that she's

3:33 sick and on unable to make it

3:35 today so I'll just now adjourn

3:37 this meeting

3:38 . Thank you thanks thank you

3:39 everyone for being here and

3:40 appreciate