Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics

Monday, November 9, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 1

Committee: Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Committee on Rules, Privileges and Elections held an advice-and-consent hearing on six mayoral and council nominations. Martha King testified for appointment to the New York City Board of Correction, answering questions on Rikers oversight, ICE detainers and sanctuary city policy, deaths in custody, solitary confinement, and the transition to borough-based jails. The committee then heard from five City Planning Commission nominees and reappointees (Anthony Cromwell, Kenneth Knuckles, Julie Stein, Margaret Anadu, and Vasan) on housing production, the fast-track affordable housing process and the 2025 charter changes, community benefits agreements, infrastructure adequacy, environmental review, and public engagement. No votes were taken during the hearing, and no members of the public signed up to comment before the public hearing was closed.

Transcript

0:15 Oh, oh, oh , first. Good

0:15 morning. Good morning. Welcome

0:17 to today's New York City

0:18 council hearing from the

0:19 committee on rules privileges

0:21 ,election standards and ethics

0:22 at this time like your mind.

0:24 Everyone, please. Sounds you

0:25 relectronic devices and at no

0:26 point does anyone to approach

0:29 the dais additionally, know

0:30 nas two across the witness

0:31 table unless invited t

0:31 otestify. If you would like t

0:32 osign up for in person,

0:34 testified.

0:34 Testimony. But you have not

0:36 dense already feel free to

0:37 sign up with a white slip

0:39 looked outside the reception

0:42 desk chair. We're ready t

0:45 obegin. Good morning and

0:46 welcome to this meeting on the

0:47 committee of rules privileges

0:49 election standard and ethics

0:50 and Council Member on showed a

0:53 committee before we begin, I

0:53 would like to recognize the

0:54 other member of this committee

0:57 for a minority leader David

0:59 Carr also like to acknowledge

1:00 the counsel to the committee a

1:01 mandate to grasso and the

1:04 committee staff direct on

1:05 today's hearing, the director

1:07 of public integrity, alicia

1:08 gazelle, chief f council and

1:10 director of public integrity

1:12 unit per more the compliance

1:14 associates and the public unit

1:16 and the additional attorneys

1:17 in the office of general

1:20 counsel will help to prepare

1:20 this hearing today will be

1:21 holding a public hearing on

1:24 six nominations for

1:25 appointments

1:25 . Will be considering martha

1:27 king for appointment to New

1:28 York city's board of

1:31 corrections and anthony calm.

1:33 Well, margaret. Anna do can if

1:35 not goes Julie stein knoxy for

1:39 this City planning.

1:41 Commission. Each candidate

1:41 will be invited and make it

1:42 opening statement before we

1:45 proceed. Remember questions

1:46 after all, candies appeared.

1:47 We will hear public testimony

1:52 . Up first will be the City

1:53 council's nomination of marfa,

1:54 keen for the appointment, but

1:55 a council as a member of the

1:56 New York City board of

1:58 corrections, I vote king t

1:59 ocome to win this table. Good

2:11 morning

2:11 , the border corrections is

2:12 static 6 2 6 of the New York

2:14 City charter is responsible

2:15 for the inspection of all

2:17 institutions and facilitie

2:18 sunder the jurisdiction of the

2:21 department of corrections of

2:22 all records we tamed by work.

2:25 In addition, the border

2:26 corrections is responsible for

2:28 the evaluation of the

2:29 department of corrections

2:32 performance, muscle, minimal

2:33 standards. The photo care care

2:35 custody correction treatment

2:37 ,supervision and discipline of

2:38 all persons held or confined

2:40 under jurisdiction of the

2:43 department, and it promulgates

2:44 such minimal standards and

2:44 rules and regulations after

2:45 give me the Mayor commissioner

2:47 an opportunity to review and

2:49 comment on the proposed

2:50 standards on lemons audition

2:54 to such standards, the has

2:55 nine members appointed equally

2:56 by the Mayor, the council and

2:58 the Mayor from judicial.

3:01 Nominations. Mayors sorry

3:02 members serve six year terms

3:04 and vacancies are filled for

3:05 the remainder of the term the

3:08 is required to establish

3:09 procedures for the hearing of

3:10 grievances, complaints, all

3:12 requests for assistance by on

3:14 behalf of any persons. Hello

3:15 confined under the

3:16 jurisdiction of the department

3:17 or by any employee of the

3:21 department

3:21 . Must issue a at least every

3:23 three years on the

3:24 department's grievous for som

3:26 eprocess incorporating feedback

3:28 from incarcerated individuals

3:29 and recommend for improvement

3:32 ,including for vulnerable.

3:33 Population. This report must

3:34 be submitted to the council

3:35 and pulsing the board's

3:38 website

3:38 , the bill is also in most

3:40 instances obligated to

3:41 investigate and prepare report

3:42 about the death of any

3:45 individual indeed custody the

3:46 report to include any

3:47 recommendations about the

3:49 measures or correctional

3:50 health services implement in

3:52 the future to prevent the

3:54 circumstances that contributes

3:57 individual stuff socially pus

3:57 hshould be posted on the

3:58 board's website, along with

3:59 any response when correctional

4:02 health services. If a point of

4:04 the marvel king was served the

4:05 remainder of the six year term

4:07 that ends on February 1 2029.

4:12 Leo joined today by martha

4:12 king, who can serves as a

4:14 program director for education

4:16 or urban affairs at charles h.

4:19 Represent foundation from 2

4:21 015 2 20 19, miss king being

4:23 served as corrections percy

4:25 oversaw the development of the

4:27 board's first sexual abuse, re

4:28 french and regulation 25 year

4:31 s

4:31 . Establishing a public

4:32 monitoring system for injuries

4:33 data transparency initiatives,

4:38 and advice the council

4:39 legislation related to the

4:41 boys oversight

4:42 responsibilities prior to that

4:43 . So you sort of a senior

4:44 posse alice in the for office

4:46 of the first deputy Mayor also

4:48 serves independent consultant

4:49 to numerous, not for profit

4:53 organizations.

4:54 King jose juris doctorate

4:55 degree in sociology from the

4:56 graduate center at the City

4:58 university of New York as well

4:59 as to master's degree from

5:01 princeton university, on

5:02 epublic affairs and one in

5:02 urban and regional planning. I

5:06 now recognize the committee

5:07 counsel to administer the

5:12 affirmation

5:12 . Please raise your right han

5:13 d. Do you affirm to tell the

5:14 truth, the whole truth and

5:14 nothing but the truth and your

5:16 statements before this

5:17 committee and in response t

5:18 oall questions posed by council

5:19 members. I do. Good morning,

5:22 miss keene. I recognize you

5:23 now to make it opening

5:24 statement. Thank you. Good

5:27 morning, sharon angle and

5:28 members of the committee. It's

5:29 an honor to be here today and

5:30 to be considered for a to the

5:32 New York City board of

5:34 correction. My connection to

5:35 New York City and in an

5:37 unusual way to rikers island

5:38 began when I was a few months

5:39 old and my parents moved our

5:41 family, too. Chicago to New

5:42 York so that my father could

5:46 run the monte fior, rikers

5:47 island to health service. This

5:49 move made me a New yorker and

5:51 created a lifelong commitment

5:52 commitment to public service

5:54 and improving the institution

5:55 s, particularly those of the

5:56 criminal justice system that

5:59 shape life in the City. I'm

6:01 now a philanthropic advisor

6:02 and strategist with 25 years

6:04 experience working across the

6:06 foundation government and

6:09 nonprofit sectors. I have

6:10 spent my career seeking to

6:11 better New York City and have

6:13 familiarity with diverse

6:15 policy areas from 2015 through

6:18 2019. I had the privilege of

6:20 serving as execuve dtiirecto

6:20 rof the board of correctio

6:23 nduring that period with

6:24 support from the council and

6:25 the mayor's office. We

6:27 increased the agency staff and

6:28 budget by more than double and

6:31 significantly expanded its

6:34 monitoring investigations,

6:35 research regulations in public

6:38 reporting. Since that time I

6:38 have remained involved in

6:39 oversight of jails and prisons

6:41 through national network. My

6:43 research public engagements

6:44 and serving as chair of the

6:46 correctional association of

6:47 New York sport of directors

6:51 this experience gives me deep

6:53 appreciation for what?

6:54 Independent oversight can

6:56 accomplish

6:56 . And an awareness awareness

6:58 of its limitations. I have

6:59 firsthand understanding of the

7:02 obligations and

7:02 responsibilities of a members

7:04 and would welcome the

7:05 opportunity to uphold them

7:09 . At a time of intensive court

7:11 . Oversight and the

7:11 significant transition t

7:13 oburrow based jails, the

7:15 institutional knowledge on the

7:17 ground and real time insights

7:20 and commitment to transparency

7:21 or especially important. The

7:24 has a remarkable history of

7:25 reforming the city's jails and

7:26 establishing the elements of

7:29 safer conditions, including

7:30 access to the courts and legal

7:33 services visits daily showers.

7:34 The practice of religion,

7:35 health and mental health care

7:38 in 19 77 future Mayor David

7:41 dinkins testified before the

7:42 board of correction

7:44 encouraging its regulations,

7:45 he noted.uote q. We have

7:47 abandoned the presumption of

7:48 innocence when we allow such

7:50 demeaning and debasing

7:51 conditions in our jails t

7:54 oexist the regulations remain

7:56 nable work against demeaning

7:57 and debasing conditions even

7:59 as those shift in nature

8:02 ,Mayor dinkins statement holds

8:03 true today and improving

8:05 conditions in City jails and

8:06 upholding the presumption of

8:08 innocence must be a priority

8:11 for our City, three quarters

8:12 of the people.

8:13 Detained on rikers returned

8:14 directly straight our our

8:18 communities.

8:18 If appointed, I would bring

8:19 deep knowledge of the City'

8:19 sjail system and a strong

8:21 itment to New York City to

8:24 the board. I would also

8:25 advance the work with an open

8:25 mind digging into current

8:27 conditions in evaluating the

8:28 evidence before the board

8:29 today, I would visit the jails

8:31 regularly work with other

8:33 board members and staff to set

8:35 priorities, follow the facts

8:36 and exercise independent

8:40 judgment. The council has a

8:40 long history of appointing

8:42 dedicated independent members

8:43 of the board and a partnering

8:45 with the implement reforms, it

8:46 would be an honor and

8:47 privilege to further that

8:49 . Legacy. Thank you for the

8:49 opportunity to appear and for

8:52 your consideration and I look

8:53 forward to your questions.

8:58 Thank you for your testimony.

8:59 We also been joined by a

9:02 council so.

9:02 First, I'm gonna kick it off

9:04 some questions and I'm going

9:04 to pass it off to my council

9:06 members probably come back,

9:09 so first, why do you want t

9:10 oserve on the board of

9:14 corrections. Well, I think we

9:14 have an especially promising

9:16 moment to create fundamental

9:18 reform in the jails.

9:20 Considering the current

9:21 leadership of the department

9:23 of correction considering the

9:25 federal courts intervention

9:26 and considering the move t

9:27 othe borough based jails the

9:31 board's standards and

9:33 regulations. It's

9:35 institutional historical

9:36 knowledge and memory are

9:37 crucial to that process.

9:39 Additionally, the board is the

9:42 one agency among all of those

9:43 involved in reform of the

9:47 jails that's formally

9:48 committed to transparency and

9:50 to speaking with all parties

9:52 combining real time data and

9:54 conversations with people on

9:55 staff and people in custody

9:59 .thank you. You previously

10:00 served as the as a executive

10:03 director. What a most

10:04 significant reforms that you

10:06 lead during your service and

10:07 what impacts that they have

10:10 that. I'm very proud that when

10:12 I was executive directo

10:13 rworking with the council in

10:14 the mayor's office. We were

10:15 able to more than double the

10:17 budget and the staff, which

10:20 translated to more

10:22 investigations, more public

10:23 reporting additional

10:27 regulations and much more

10:28 transparency in our cities

10:29 jail system one or two

10:31 examples of which I'm

10:32 particularly proud of or the

10:33 work by the board, too

10:37 .evaluate the department of

10:38 corrections, complaint and

10:40 grievance system we issued the

10:43 first comprehensive

10:43 evaluations of the grievance

10:44 system when I was executive

10:48 director, and those

10:48 evaluations led to a package

10:51 of City Council legislation

10:52 .it also led to an entirely New

10:57 digital centralized complaint

10:58 system run by the department

10:59 of correction it allowed them

11:02 to streamline all of their 300

11:04 and complaints with other

11:06 mechanisms for getting

11:07 complaints and it also led to

11:09 staffing and policy changes

11:10 that improve the grievance

11:14 system based on your

11:15 experience overseeing the City

11:16 jails will do you believe

11:17 incarceration should play in

11:18 the criminal justice system.

11:21 Well, I believe incarceration

11:24 has a necessary but limited

11:26 role, so it should be used

11:27 when it is necessary to

11:30 protect public safety to

11:31 protect the integrity of the

11:35 legal process. I think we have

11:35 of overusing incarceration t

11:40 otry to solve problems that

11:42 cannot be solved with a jail

11:43 or with a prison.

11:46 We also have a record in New

11:47 York City over the past 30

11:51 years or since Mayor dinkins

11:52 of reducing the number of

11:53 people who are incarcerated

11:55 while we've also reduced crime

11:57 and made the City safer. So I

11:58 hope that we can continue t

12:01 obuild on that trajectory you

12:05 currently serves as a chair of

12:06 the correctional association

12:08 of New

12:09 . York what lessons from that

12:10 real, will you bring to the

12:13 border questions. Um, so just

12:17 to clarify so.

12:18 In case anyone's confused,

12:19 the correctional association

12:21 monitors and oversees the

12:23 state prison system entirely

12:24 different jurisdiction, and I

12:25 did talk to the conflicts of

12:26 interest board, and I will be

12:28 cognizant of any potential

12:29 conflicts. If I were to b

12:31 eappointed. I was not advised

12:32 if any, by the

12:35 . Quick. Um, so I think with

12:38 the with cani's experience, my

12:40 experience of candy and at the

12:41 board of correction, one of

12:43 the key lessons is using data

12:47 to inform our conversations

12:49 about potential policy changes

12:53 and also paying attention t

12:54 othe actual implementation of

12:57 reforms so.

12:58 Prisons and jails have many,

13:01 many policies and regulations

13:02 that they're supposed to be

13:05 following. The problem lies in

13:08 the implementation and

13:09 integrity of those policies

13:10 and regulations on the ground

13:12 and so I believe that my

13:15 lessons from candy and the

13:15 board previously are too

13:19 really be persistent and

13:20 constentis in looking at

13:23 implementation and conditions

13:24 in real time and and using

13:27 data from all sides so as much

13:30 data as can be gathered

13:32 through information systems

13:33 and data that comes from

13:34 people who working in the

13:37 system or are detained in the

13:38 system bring important