Committee on Finance

Tuesday, November 17, 2026, 11 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 2

Committee: Committee on Finance

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Committee on Finance held a joint oversight hearing with the Committee on Housing and Buildings on "Advancing Homeownership Opportunity and Protection." Council sponsors presented a package of bills including Intros 861 and 862 (Brooks-Powers, voucher homeownership outreach and HomeFirst expansion), 1084 (Hudson, automatic enrollment in property tax payment plans), 1091 (Narcisse, lien warning notices), 1096 and 1097 (Williams, displacement outreach and DOB equity study), 406 (Riley, co-op board training), 1082 (Hankerson), Resolutions 599 and 9. The HPD Commissioner and Department of Finance and Buildings officials testified on homeownership programs (Our Home, Open Door, HomeFirst, the land bank) and announced lien sale reforms for a planned 2027 sale; DOF testified it cannot support Intro 1084 in its current form, favoring opt-in plans. The committee also pressed the administration on the overdue red line on Intro 657 (Safer Homes Act). Dozens of HDFC shareholders, advocates, and homeowners then testified, largely urging passage of Resolution 9 supporting the state HDFC bill (S880B/A2707B), ending or reforming the tax lien sale, and stronger deed theft protections. No votes were taken; the hearing was an oversight and bill discussion.

Transcript

0:09 Thank you hit it again here we

0:09 go good morning good morning

0:16 welcome to the New York City

0:19 council committee on finance

0:20 joint with housing and

0:22 building at this time we ask

0:23 that you please silence all

0:26 electronics if you wish t

0:27 ofill out an appearance card

0:29 wanted the sergeant at arms in

0:31 the back and at no point

0:32 please do not approach the

0:34 begin good morning I'm

0:46 councilmember purina adina

0:47 Sanchez chair of the committee

0:48 on housing and buildings

0:50 welcome to today's joint

0:51 oversight hearing with chair

0:52 Linda Lee and the finance

0:54 committee on advancing

0:55 homeownership opportunity and

0:56 protection thank you also to

0:58 the speaker for her

0:59 flexibility I'm dealing with a

1:00 personal care matter but I

1:01 will be here for a few hours

1:03 today because this matter is

1:04 so important I want t

1:06 oacknowledge my colleagues who

1:08 are present today

1:11 councilmember Salaam note

1:12 sorry I'm very short

1:14 councilmember Council Member

1:19 salam Narcisse ah.

1:20 Deputy speaker Williams

1:22 Council Member wang council

1:24 member Carl Wilson and council

1:27 member Justin Sanchez oh and

1:30 Council Member mart and

1:32 Council Member so Morano yes

1:36 moran and councilmember member

1:37 jim genaro on thank you you

1:40 . For generations working

1:41 families across the City have

1:43 sacrificed saved and worked

1:44 themselves to the bone for the

1:46 chance to own a little piece

1:49 of New York not just for a

1:50 roof over their heads but for

1:52 the stability that it brings

1:53 the roots it allows them to

1:54 put down and the possibility

1:56 of passing something on t

1:58 otheir children that is the

2:00 dream of homeownership and in

2:00 a City built by working people

2:02 we should be doing everything

2:04 in our power to protect it

2:07 instead we're watching that

2:08 dream become harder and harder

2:10 to achieve and harder to keep

2:12 for families who sacrificed t

2:13 obuy a home taxes insurance

2:15 utilities and repair costs

2:17 keep rising as buildings age

2:20 for older black and latino

2:22 homeowners especially

2:23 financial distress can put

2:24 their generational wealth at

2:25 risk in the third quarter of

2:28 2026 single and two famil

2:30 yhomes together represented 66%

2:31 of New York city's first time

2:35 for closer auction cases and

2:36 to make matters worse

2:38 predatory activity is on the

2:40 rise between 20 23 and 20 25

2:44 complaints of deed theft more

2:46 than tripled

2:47 . Between 2020 20 New York

2:48 City lost more than 185 non

2:53 hispanic black residents

2:54 rising housing costs are part

2:55 of that story but research

2:56 from the pratt center shows us

2:58 and found that more than 10000

3:00 New York City homes were

3:02 flipped between 20 21 and 2

3:05 025 disproportionately in black

3:06 and brown neighborhoods we

3:07 have to ask is this City doing

3:08 all that we can to prevent

3:11 speculation from pricing

3:12 working families out of the

3:13 very neighborhoods that they

3:15 helped to build and is our

3:17 City equipped to track how

3:18 many homes are moving from

3:20 owner occupants into investor

3:23 hands these specific pressures

3:24 affect mitchell aama and hdfc

3:26 co ops market co ops and

3:28 condos single family home

3:29 owners and small owner

3:31 occupied multi family

3:31 buildings differently coop op

3:33 boards face costly repairs

3:35 that governance challenges.

3:36 Small property owners juggle

3:39 expenses and responsibilities

3:41 with their tenants and for New

3:43 yorkers trying to buy their

3:44 first home the median first

3:46 time buyer recently put down

3:51 $265000 on an $883000 home.

3:54 That's only about one third

3:56 of the City the city's

3:57 households who are owning

3:58 their homes and in the bronx

3:59 in my neck of the woods barely

4:00 one in five what kind of

4:02 opportunity is this for a

4:03 working family.

4:04 We've been working on these

4:05 issues for years in the

4:06 council.

4:07 From our comprehensive

4:09 hearing in 20 23 on home

4:10 ownership to hearings on which

4:11 allama h's this summer co opt

4:14 transparency deed theft

4:15 distressed properties and the

4:17 mayor's overall housing plan

4:18 we've pressed hpd to update

4:21 its homeowner excuse me its

4:22 home ownership term sheets and

4:24 enacted a 4% homeownership

4:26 opportunity target in the last

4:28 administration today we want

4:30 to hear this administration's

4:32 plan are she tax payment plans

4:34 and d theft protections

4:36 reaching families before they

4:37 lose their homes are home

4:39 first the homeowner help desk

4:40 which shoutout to to

4:42 councilmember Brooks Powers

4:43 her bill created and the

4:44 office of the homeowner

4:46 advocate voucher homeownership

4:48 tax incentives like j 51 an

4:50 ddevelopment.

4:51 Programs are these are these

4:52 things meeting the need.

4:53 We look forward t

4:54 oexchanging ideas with the

4:56 administration and

4:56 collaborating to kee

4:57 phomeownership a real

4:58 possibility for more New

4:59 yorkers including discussion

5:01 of my colleague's bills before

5:02 us today intro 8 61 sponsored

5:05 by councilmember Brooks Brooks

5:06 Powers for example would

5:07 expand outreach about the

5:08 housing choice voucher

5:10 homeownership program which

5:11 helps voucher holders

5:13 transition into ownership

5:15 intro hundred 62 also

5:16 sponsored by councilmember

5:17 Brooks Powers would expand the

5:19 home first down payment

5:20 assistance so that at least

5:21 600 New yorkers a year would

5:23 receive the financial

5:24 assistance they need to mak

5:26 edown payments in addition t

5:27 othese bills which would give

5:29 direct financial assistance t

5:32 opotential homebuyers.

5:33 Council members council

5:33 member o'reilly's intro 406

5:35 Council Member narcissus 109

5:37 1council member hudson's

5:40 thousand 84 and deputy speaker

5:40 Williams intro

5:41 . 1 0 9 Would create

5:43 protections for current

5:45 homeowners while council

5:46 member Hankerson intro

5:48 thousand 82 and deputy speaker

5:49 Williams intro thousand 97

5:50 would help us understand why

5:51 New York er's are struggling

5:52 to purchase homes so that we

5:53 together with the

5:54 administration can better

5:56 serve the public I want t

5:57 otake a moment to thank deputy

5:59 speaker natasha Williams for

6:01 leading this package and the

6:02 black latino and asian caucus

6:04 for championing black

6:05 homeownership I thank my team

6:07 ben ratner kim castellanos

6:08 gerard fernandez malia

6:10 sardinia

6:11 . Marcus khan geraldine Feliz

6:13 emily porta lyn

6:14 . Mendez maria jose mares so

6:15 that got a big team y'all so

6:17 oriana and the committee staff

6:19 here today austin malone billy

6:23 second and dirk spencer

6:24 mohammed shadid and noah sloss d

6:27 member Lee Lee to deliver her

6:34 remarks ah before I begin

6:35 we've been joined by council

6:37 members Riley Avilés a Brooks

6:39 Powers and Abreu okay I know

6:41 it's a little toasty so

6:43 hopefully you all won't fall

6:44 asleep during the hearing but

6:47 it's exciting stuff good

6:48 morning everyone I'm

6:50 councilmember Linda Lee chair

6:51 of the committee on finance

6:51 and would like to thank my

6:53 colleagues and co chairs

6:55 Council Member perino Sanchez

6:56 chair of the committee on

6:58 housing and buildings and

6:59 deputy speaker and natasha

7:00 Williams for joining me this

7:03 morning for this over

7:04 important oversight hearing on

7:06 advancing homeownership

7:08 opportunity and protection

7:09 today we will hear a package

7:11 of legislation intended to

7:13 promote homeownership

7:14 opportunities and fortify

7:15 protections for current and

7:16 prospective homeowners in New

7:18 York City including intro

7:20 thousand 84 which falls under

7:21 the jurisdiction of the

7:22 committee on finance and your

7:24 thousand 84 co sponsored by

7:25 Council Member Crystal Hudson

7:26 would require the commissioner

7:28 of finance to automatically

7:29 enroll individuals in a

7:30 department of finance

7:32 administered residential

7:33 property tax payment plan that

7:35 requires an individual to pay

7:36 the lowest total amount the

7:37 commissioner would be required

7:38 to notify an eligible

7:40 individual about automatic

7:42 enrollment at least 60 days

7:43 before the first payment is

7:44 due under the applicable plan

7:46 the types of plans for which

7:48 the individual is eligible and

7:49 their costs the plan in which

7:52 the individuals enrolled and

7:54 any steps necessary to

7:55 complete enrollment

7:56 additionally the commissioner

7:57 would be required to establish

7:59 a plainly and conspicuously

8:02 communicated opt out mechanism

8:03 that would allow an individual

8:05 to decline automatic

8:06 enrollment at the time the

8:07 individual receives the notice.

8:08 Throughout my time serving

8:10 as a nonprofit leader and now

8:11 as a Council Member I've seen

8:13 how crucial homeownership

8:16 resources are to my

8:17 constituents as they navigate

8:18 the many facets of owning a

8:20 home in this great City

8:22 including navigating various

8:23 City offices and agencies when

8:24 faced with questions or

8:26 hardships related t

8:27 ohomeownership owning a home

8:28 can be very difficult and it

8:30 is our responsibility as

8:31 lawmakers to make it easier

8:33 for homeowners to seek help

8:35 and support when they feel

8:36 overwhelmed or burdened rather

8:37 than adding to the challenges

8:39 of navigating the complexities

8:40 of City government.

8:42 I'm excited that we were

8:42 able to convene

8:44 representatives from d o f h

8:45 and dub to better understand

8:47 how we can continue to make

8:49 homeownership a reality for

8:51 more New yorkers while also

8:52 ensuring that current

8:53 homeowners have the resources

8:54 and support they need t

8:56 oafford and remain in their

8:58 homes thank you to my

8:59 colleagues for joining me

9:00 today to do f and the other

9:03 agencies for testifying and t

9:03 othe finance committee staff

9:06 mra ada daniel croup jacks

9:09 story teller damn nuke jim

9:10 naco andrew wilbur lyle reade

9:13 carla naranjo owen cutoff ski

9:15 brian sorrowful and spencer

9:18 coon oh I think we recognized

9:21 everybody right okay okay and

9:22 I'll pass it back to you

9:25 Sanchez speaker

9:26 . Thank you cheer least I'll

9:27 now turn it over over t

9:28 ocouncilmember Brooks Powers

9:29 followed by deputy speaker

9:32 Williams thank you cheer leave

9:33 chair Sanchez and members of

9:34 the committees on finance and

9:36 housing and buildings for

9:38 including intro 861 and intro

9:41 862 in this critical hearing

9:44 on homeownership I have the

9:45 privilege of serving

9:46 communities where

9:47 homeownership has long been a

9:49 cornerstone stone of

9:50 neighborhoods stability and

9:52 economic opportunity in my

9:55 district roughly half of all

9:56 households own their homes and

9:58 nearly seven in 10 of those

9:59 homeowners are black

10:02 . For generations families in

10:03 southeast queens have worked

10:04 hard saved and sacrificed t

10:06 obuy homes and build something

10:09 lasting to pass down to their

10:10 children and grandchildren but

10:12 rising costs and limited

10:14 access to available resources

10:16 are putting that goal out of

10:18 reach but to many New yorkers

10:20 er's City fewer than 1 1 3 on

10:23 their homes including just 26%

10:26 of black households in 17% of

10:30 latino households we cannot

10:31 talk about building affordable t

10:34 addressing both sides of this

10:37 challenge helping existing

10:38 homeowners stay in their homes

10:41 and creating meaningful

10:41 opportunities for the next

10:43 generation to become

10:44 homeowners my bills together

10:47 prioritize outreach and access

10:49 for resources the City.

10:51 Excuse me the City already

10:53 funds to make sure that

10:55 potential homeowners are aware

10:57 and eligible for the tools we

10:59 have in place intro 861 would

11:03 require h to launch an

11:04 education and outreach

11:06 campaign so section eight

11:09 voucher holders know about the

11:11 housing choice voucher

11:12 homeownership program which

11:14 lets eligible families put

11:16 their voucher towards buying a

11:18 home the campaign would

11:20 explain who is eligible and

11:21 how to apply in every

11:25 designated citywide language

11:26 access to opportunity begins

11:27 with knowing it exists intro 8

11:30 62 which strengthened the

11:31 city's home first program by

11:33 requiring hpd to help at least

11:37 601 time homebuyers every year

11:38 year with down payment and

11:41 closing course 2 and 2 report

11:42 annually on how many families

11:44 were helped and the

11:44 communities where they bought.

11:45 As of January 2025 h

11:49 reported humphries had helped

11:51 over 1100 New yorkers in the

11:54 past decade a little over a

11:56 hundred a year the council has

11:58 since secured funding t

12:00 odouble the city's investment

12:01 in the program and intro 8 62

12:04 to make sure that investment

12:06 reaches families at scale

12:08 together these bills expand

12:09 pathways to first time home

12:11 ownership and help working

12:13 families build equity

12:16 established and create

12:16 generational wealth so New

12:17 yorkers can afford to stay in

12:19 the City they call home thank

12:21 you to the advocates who

12:23 continue to fight for

12:26 affordable homeownership

12:26 across New York City including

12:28 the center for New York

12:30 homeownership where I am proud

12:30 to serve on the board and many

12:33 others thank you as well to my

12:34 colleagues for their work on

12:36 this package I look forward t

12:38 oworking with the chairs and

12:40 the committees to move intro

12:42 hundred 61 and intro 862

12:44 forward thank you

12:46 . Thank you Council Member I

12:46 now like to call on deputy

12:50 speaker Williams thank you so

12:53 much chairs and I really

12:54 appreciate your leadership

12:57 your flexibility your support

12:59 in hosting this hearing today

13:00 and before I get into my bills e

13:04 council's commitment to

13:05 homeownership doesn't just

13:07 extend legislatively and we're

13:09 excited to hold this hearing

13:11 but this year we also created

13:13 a New initiative under the

13:15 leadership of finance chair

13:17 Lee called the homeownership

13:20 opportunity protection package d

13:22 the amount of money that goes

13:26 to organizations supporting

13:27 all facets of homeownership

13:28 or deed death as a fewy

13:34 examples and then in addition

13:38 to what we've been doing

13:40 financially through our

13:42 initiatives is also a