Committee on Immigration

Friday, November 20, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 1

Committee: Committee on Immigration

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Committee on Immigration, chaired by Council Member Elsie Encarnación, held an oversight hearing on the current state of immigration enforcement activity in New York City and heard four legislative items: Proposed Int. 1077-A and 1078-A (prohibiting NYPD and the Department of Correction from honoring civil immigration detainers without a judicial warrant), Intro 739 (agency training and publication of implementation plans on non-local law enforcement cooperation), and Resolution 729 (supporting the state BUILD Act to fund immigration legal defense). Testimony from the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs (MOIA) and NYPD focused on Executive Order 13 implementation, new NYPD patrol-guide policies, and the October 8 ICE shooting of Oscar Delgado in Marble Hill, which several Council Members pressed NYPD on. The NYPD representative stated the department fully supports Int. 1077-A, and MOIA expressed support for the spirit of the detainer bills while the Law Department reviews them. No votes were taken; public testimony overwhelmingly supported the 'Cut Ties with ICE' package.

Transcript

0:38 Thank you. Good morning and

0:38 welcome to today's New York

0:40 City Council hammer for the

0:42 committee on immigration,

0:43 ladies and gentlemen at this

0:44 time, please ask your silence

0:45 .all electronic devices. If you

0:49 would like the fellow of

0:49 testing when we slip and

0:50 please he wanted to start our

0:52 own offices moving forward no

0:53 one is to approach the front

0:55 days chair. You begin. I am

0:59 calling this hearing to order

1:02 .good morning, everyone. I am

1:06 Council Member chair of the

1:07 committee on immigration.

1:10 Thank you for joining us toda

1:11 y, we will be examining the

1:13 current state of immigration

1:15 enforcement activity in New

1:16 York City and hearing fou

1:20 rbills introduction 709

1:23 proposed introduction thousand

1:24 77, a proposed into 78 a and

1:29 resolution 1029

1:33 . I like to thank all of the

1:34 representative from the

1:35 administration, members of the

1:36 public and my council

1:37 colleagues who have joined us

1:39 here today, including council

1:41 hank's councilmember Brewer,

1:42 Council Member of and I'm

1:48 going to throw you in there

1:49 ,jomana and a public advocate,

1:50 your body. Williams.

1:54 For nearly two years our

1:55 country has reckoned with a

1:56 presidential term that has

1:58 sown chaos instilled fear and

2:01 enacted a program of mass. Oh,

2:05 my god. Deportations of

2:08 apologies and family

2:09 separation and immigrant

2:10 . Communities in recent month

2:12 s, those realities have played

2:13 out in an excruciating way in

2:16 our own neighborhoods from

2:17 washington heights to sunset

2:19 part to corona, where ice has

2:21 abducted community members

2:22 during street rates this came

2:25 to head last month on a

2:27 bustling residential street in

2:28 marble hill where ice agents

2:31 shot oscar boggle, a 28 year

2:32 old New yorker from the

2:34 dominican republic while he

2:35 was in his car with his five

2:36 year old son. Mercifully, the

2:39 child was not physically

2:42 harmed

2:43 . But bogle has since been

2:44 transferred to the notorious

2:46 metropolitan detention center,

2:48 ballads, attorneys alleg

2:48 ethat the left side of his face

2:52 remains numb following the

2:53 shooting that he struggles to

2:54 hear anything out of his left

2:55 ear and that's the bullet

2:56 remains lodged in his body.

3:00 New York City has been and

3:00 will always be a City of

3:03 immigrants now more than ever.

3:05 Ordinary New yorkers and all

3:07 five boroughs are coming

3:08 together to protect our

3:12 immigrant neighbors. They have

3:12 affirmed their values and

3:14 positive vision for City,

3:15 that's safeguards and empowers

3:17 immigrants to thrive alongside

3:19 all New yorkers for centuries

3:21 ,this City has been a beacon

3:23 for families across the globe

3:24 who have sought freedom from

3:26 persecution, a better future

3:28 for their children and the

3:29 ability to earn a living with

3:32 dignity with today's oversight

3:33 hearing the committee on

3:34 immigration will examine the

3:36 current state of immigration

3:37 enforcement activity in New

3:38 York City and assess whether

3:40 the city's response to it

3:41 lives up to the promise of our

3:43 City and the bravery of New

3:46 yorkers, we will explore the

3:48 mayoral administrations.

3:49 Efforts to uphold our

3:51 protective laws fund legal

3:51 services and know your rights

3:54 .trainings refrained from

3:55 facilitating civil immigration

3:57 enforcement actions and

3:58 empower the working people of

4:01 this City this council remains

4:02 ready to work with the

4:02 administration to stand up

4:04 against oppressive immigration

4:06 policies and to protect our

4:09 communities futures. Lastly,

4:10 the in the committee of

4:11 immigration, we'll hear

4:12 several bills, including two

4:13 that I sponsored first

4:16 proposed introduction 1077

4:18 8would prohibit the New York

4:20 City police department from

4:21 detaining an individual beyond

4:23 the time when such person what

4:25 otherwise be released from

4:27 custody without a judicial

4:30 warrior.

4:31 Proposed 10 propose

4:32 dintroduction thousand 77 a

4:33 would allow the nypd to honor

4:36 civil immigration detainers by

4:38 holding a person beyond their

4:40 release date or notifying

4:44 federal authorities of a

4:44 person's release only if

4:47 federal immigration

4:48 immigration authorities are

4:50 present nypd with a judicial

4:53 warrant and such warrant is

4:55 for law enforcement purpose

4:57 not related to immigration of.

5:00 The bill would also examined

5:02 an existing exception allowed,

5:04 allowing the nypd to honor a

5:06 civil immigration detainer by

5:07 holding a person for up to 4

5:10 8hours beyond the release date

5:11 under certain circumstances

5:14 .the removal of this existing

5:15 exception would bring local

5:16 law in line with New York case

5:18 law holding that such an

5:20 action constitute a New arrest

5:22 and seizure on the both New

5:23 York law and the fourt

5:24 hamendment of the u. S.

5:28 Constitution. Second propose

5:28 dcontrol 1078 would similarly

5:31 prohibited department of

5:32 corrections from detaining

5:33 that individual beyond the

5:35 time when such person would b

5:37 eotherwise released from

5:38 custody without a judicial

5:41 judicial warrants the bill

5:41 would allow to honor civil

5:43 immigration detainers by

5:44 holding a person beyond the

5:45 release date or notifying

5:47 federal authorities of a

5:49 person's release only if

5:51 federal immigration

5:52 authorities present with the

5:54 judicial warrant and such

5:56 warrant is for law enforcement

5:58 purpose not related t

6:01 oimmigration enforcement

6:02 . If pass these bills would

6:04 replace the existing evidence.

6:07 Sorry existing convention to

6:08 convict based approach.

6:11 With a due process based

6:12 model by implementing an

6:15 unequivocal judicial criminal

6:16 warrant exceptions and

6:18 streamlining our detainer law

6:18 s. I look forward to hearing

6:20 the administration's position

6:21 on these bills

6:23 . Next, the committee will

6:25 consider introduction 7 39,

6:26 sponsored by council members

6:28 in relation to requiring

6:30 agency training and the

6:32 publication of implementation

6:34 plans concerning immigration

6:35 enforcement and cooperation

6:36 with non local law enforcement

6:40 agencies.

6:40 This bill will require

6:41 agencies to train their

6:43 employees, contractors and

6:44 subcontractors on the

6:45 requirements ofur o City

6:48 resources law and to publish

6:50 protocols for implementing and

6:51 complying with that law

6:52 . The bill would apply the

6:54 same training and protocol

6:56 publication requirements, too.

6:58 The department of probation

7:00 member knee for introducing

7:07 these bills. Finally, the

7:08 committee will hear resolution

7:11 7 29, sponsored by public

7:11 advocate your money. Williams

7:13 calling on New York state

7:14 legislator to pass and the

7:17 governor to sign to 6 8 9

7:20 slash s 4 5 3 8 in relation to

7:23 enacting the building up

7:25 immigration legal defense or

7:26 build act the builder.

7:28 Act would provide

7:29 competitive workforce

7:32 development and capacity

7:32 building grants to eligible

7:33 and entities that are seeking

7:35 to expand access to

7:38 representation for individuals

7:40 facing deportation by

7:40 increasing the workforce and

7:42 strengthening the legal

7:43 service infrastructure needed

7:46 to provide such representatio

7:47 n. No New yorkers should have

7:48 to face the deportation

7:50 dragnet without an advocate by

7:53 their side. Um, and so I want

7:54 to thank the public advocate

7:55 for introducing it, and I

7:56 would also like to thank my

7:57 committee staff for the work

7:58 on this hearing, including

8:01 senior legislative council nor

8:03 kolkata, senior legislative

8:04 policy analytical analyst

8:07 rebecca barria, principa

8:08 lfinancial analyst nobby baines

8:10 and assistant finance director

8:11 florentine cab. Finally, I

8:12 would like to thank my staff,

8:13 especially my chief of staff

8:16 stephanie herrera and

8:17 everybody working in the

8:18 background to make this

8:18 hearing once more, especially

8:20 are amazing, sergeant and arms

8:23 they didn't one else come in.

8:26 No. Okay, I will now turn it

8:27 over to the public advocate

8:30 Williams for brief remarks on

8:34 his resolution.

8:35 Oh, thank you, Madam. Chair.

8:35 Good afternoon everyone was

8:36 mentioned my name is jiminy

8:37 Williams and public eye of

8:38 City of New York and the

8:39 knicks on a winning streak. U

8:42 m, I'd like to thank you

8:44 .custom in consternation on

8:45 always was his name. Oh, I'm

8:46 working on. I apologize. Ah,

8:49 and members of the immigration

8:49 committee for holding this

8:50 hearing it for the opportunity

8:51 to share the statement. New

8:53 York City has forever and

8:54 always been home to immigrant

8:56 communities from every single

8:56 part of the world immigrants

8:59 are students, coworkers

9:00 ,neighbors, business owners and

9:01 a fundamental part of the

9:02 socioeconomic, economic and

9:03 cultural fabric of New York

9:06 City the same time these same

9:07 immigrants in yorkers are

9:07 dealing with the consequences

9:09 of aggressive federal

9:10 immigration enforcement that

9:12 has communities broken apart

9:13 families and left residents in

9:17 constant fear, isis

9:17 indiscriminately carried out

9:18 arrests in workplaces

9:20 ,immigration court hard

9:20 hearings and routine check ins

9:23 and infiltred satpaces where

9:25 people seek assistance and

9:25 support from the City this

9:28 summer in flatbush. I was

9:28 speaking to a roughly idiot a

9:29 woman who now walks around

9:30 with a passport, she's afraid

9:32 of being stopped. The impact

9:35 of these actions is not simply

9:38 theoretical, responsive t

9:38 ogrowing concerns about federal

9:39 immigration enforcement

9:40 activity in New York City

9:42 executive order 13 directed

9:43 City agencies to examine and

9:45 report on ice activity and its

9:47 effects on City services and

9:50 facilities took to order the

9:51 internal policies and

9:52 protocols and immigrant

9:54 immigration enforcement

9:55 coordination and report back

9:56 to the Mayor, according to the

9:58 May 2026 order that was

9:59 produced, there was a 71%

10:01 increase in ice enforcement

10:01 actions across New York City

10:04 area between January 20 2025

10:08 March 1020 26 and an overall

10:11 rising federal presence inside

10:11 certain City shelters

10:13 unauthorized entry is the

10:14 incidents and searching

10:16 detainer requests.

10:16 The order also documented

10:19 arrests at routine ice check

10:20 ings these incidents is

10:21 highlighted how individuals

10:22 attempting to comply with

10:24 immigration requirements or

10:24 instead of fighting themselve

10:26 s, separated from the loved

10:26 ones and placing in detention

10:29 ,the repercussions of

10:30 immigration detention extend

10:31 far beyond the initial

10:32 incarceration. Individuals are

10:33 often transferred to

10:34 facilities and away from their

10:36 support networks, making it

10:37 difficult for them to contact

10:39 the legal representatives, I

10:40 echo concerns about the

10:41 reported lack of medical care

10:42 and unsafe detention

10:46 conditions, reports that

10:46 chronic illness left untreated

10:48 prescriptions are interrupted.

10:49 Physician physician coverage

10:51 is radical nonexistence and

10:52 facilities are over.

10:53 And insanitary families and

10:54 communities of those

10:55 essentially kidnapped faced

10:56 sudden loss of incomes and

10:58 understandably reluctant to

10:59 reach out or receive

11:00 government resources and fair

11:01 of corporation with federal

11:04 authorities. This makes it

11:05 more difficult for our City t

11:06 oreliably provide services and

11:08 maintain stability. Today's

11:09 oversight hearings, crucial

11:10 opportunity to examine the

11:11 current state of immigrants

11:13 immigration enforcement

11:13 activity in New York City and

11:14 how agencies are implemented

11:16 laws to protect our

11:17 immigration immigrant

11:20 residents. I support all o

11:20 fthe legislation heard today

11:21 and want to speak in depth

11:22 about my legislation.

11:24 Hundred 9, which calls on

11:25 New York state legislature t

11:26 opass and the governor to sig

11:29 nassembly build to 6 8 9, bill

11:32 438. We're going building up

11:36 immigrant legal defense or

11:37 build act this legislation,

11:39 sponsored by senator john

11:40 lewis summer. Remember

11:41 catalina cruz, whose hair

11:43 would establish dedicated

11:44 funding to provide workforce

11:45 development capacity building

11:46 grants to scale up the legal

11:49 workforce and strengthen

11:49 infrastructure, too ensure

11:50 more undocumented individuals

11:51 have access to depor

11:52 tdeportation of events in this

11:53 way the build act with support

11:56 organizations, increasing the

11:57 capacity to serve individuals

11:58 and families navigate

12:01 immigration court. This

12:01 investment is particularly

12:02 important as legal services

12:04 provide providers legal

12:05 service providers facing

12:06 impressive increase demand for

12:08 the services for immigrant

12:09 snew yorkers, particularly

12:09 those who protected status has

12:11 recently been eliminated.

12:12 Children who have lost legal

12:14 representation after federal

12:15 funding cuts and families

12:16 navigating the needlessly

12:18 difficult course system these

12:19 services are life altering

12:22 studies by the immigration

12:23 american immigrant council

12:24 covering fiscal years 20 19 20

12:27 24 found that only 26.9% of

12:30 representative respondents

12:30 were ordered removed compared

12:32 with 61.8% of represented

12:35 unrepresented rep. Respondents

12:36 expanding access to legal

12:38 representation requires more

12:38 than simply assistant people

12:39 in navigating complex

12:42 paperwork. We have to show

12:43 that people grappling with the

12:44 possibility separation from

12:45 their families and their homes

12:46 understand their rights and

12:47 have an advocate I'd like to

12:48 thank the season recent

12:50 allocation of 4.5 million t

12:51 oexpand the mayor's office of

12:53 immigrant affairs, immigration

12:54 , legal support hotline t

12:55 oseven days a week. This

12:57 investment will help ensure

12:58 ensure it. Immigrant New

12:59 yorkers have greater access t

13:01 ofree confidential legal

13:03 assistance and trusted

13:03 information. It's a meaningful

13:05 start. Of course we need true

13:08 systemic change. We must also

13:09 be made truly make this