Monday, October 19, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 2
Committee: Committee on Health
The Committee on Health, chaired by Council Member Schulman, held an oversight hearing on the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene's (DOHMH) food service establishment inspection program and considered six bills and one resolution. Topics included declining initial inspection rates (99.5% in FY2019 to 69.7% in FY2025), staffing and recruitment of public health sanitarians, restaurant grading, food protection certificates, tobacco bar relocation, children's meal nutrition standards, and legionella reporting thresholds for cooling towers. DOHMH Deputy Commissioner Corinne Schiff testified, largely supporting the intent of most bills while raising operational concerns, and opposing the tobacco bar relocation bill as undermining the Smoke Free Air Act. Public testimony came from a labor union representing sanitarians, health advocacy organizations, and legionella/cooling tower experts, with divided views on the legionella reporting and tobacco bar bills. No votes were taken at the hearing.
0:20 Few minutes good morning and
0:20 welcome to today's New York
0:22 City Council hammering for the
0:24 committee on health ladies and
0:25 gentlemen at this time we
0:27 please ask you silence all
0:28 electronic devices if you
0:30 would like the fellow a
0:31 testimony slipped and please
0:32 see one of the sergeant armed
0:34 officers moving forward at no
0:36 point in time as anyone t
0:38 oapproach the front dais chair
0:39 you begin good morning
0:43 everyone and welcome t
0:44 otoday's hearing of the New
0:45 York City Council committee on
0:46 health I am councilmember Lynn
0:48 shulman chair of the committee y
0:50 colleagues and the
0:52 representatives from the
0:52 department of health and
0:53 mental hygiene for joining us
0:55 today to discuss food service
0:57 establishment inspections in
0:58 New York City we've been
1:00 joined today by council
1:04 members marty a De La Rosa
1:08 Wilson and arriola on zoom at
1:10 its core public health is
1:11 about protecting New York er's
1:12 and their everyday lives it
1:15 means making sure the food we
1:16 eat is safe that the business
1:18 is serving our communities
1:19 made clear and consistent
1:21 standards and that New York
1:22 er's have access t
1:23 oinformation that supports
1:24 their health and well being
1:26 today the committee will
1:28 examine do mh is oversight of
1:30 food service establishment
1:32 inspections and consider a
1:33 range of legislation
1:35 addressing food safety
1:36 restaurant accountability
1:38 tobacco regulation disease
1:39 prevention and children's
1:42 nutrition the council's
1:43 analysis of doe mh data and
1:45 preparation for this hearing
1:47 highlights the current
1:48 challenges facing the city's
1:51 restaurant inspection program
1:52 and fists 2019 99.5% of
1:56 restaurants received an
1:57 initial sanitary inspection by
1:59 fiscal year 20 25 that figure
2:01 had fallen to 69.7% and almost
2:06 30% drop the covid-19 pandemic
2:09 seriously impacted inspection
2:09 rates and staffing levels the
2:12 public public health sanitary
2:13 inns the title given t
2:16 orestaurant inspectors recently
2:17 there are encouraging signs of
2:19 increased inspection activity
2:20 the average number of monthly
2:22 inspections rose from
2:24 approximately 400 in the final
2:26 quarter of 20 23 to nearly
2:29 2200 by June 2024 reaching
2:31 just under 2700 by August 2026
2:35 however the department's entry
2:36 level public health sanitary
2:38 in workforce has not returned
2:39 to its pre covid levels and
2:42 inspection trends reflect this
2:43 reality these data raise
2:46 questions about staffing
2:47 inspection capacity and the
2:49 department's ability to
2:51 provide consistent oversight
2:52 across the city's food service
2:54 establishments the council's
2:56 analysis also found that
2:57 facility and equipment
2:58 maintenance and pest presence
3:00 and prevention account for
3:02 nearly half of all violations
3:04 across inspections these
3:06 findings underscore why
3:07 routine inspections accurate
3:10 documentation and timely
3:11 corrective action are
3:12 essential to protecting New
3:13 yorkers from unsafe and
3:15 unsanitary conditions we want
3:18 to understand how is
3:19 addressing inspection capacity d
3:22 follow up visits and ensuring
3:23 that violations are identified e
3:27 look forward to z's engagement
3:29 with these topics in addition
3:31 the committee will consider
3:32 600 duck shins and one
3:34 resolution these three
3:35 proposals today focus on
3:36 restaurant operations food
3:38 safety and accountability
3:40 proposed intro hundred 89 a
3:41 sponsored by Council Member
3:44 for faris would require
3:46 photographs of video
3:48 documenting each sighted
3:49 violation when a restaurant
3:50 inspection results in 14 or
3:52 more points intro 908
3:54 sponsored by council members
3:55 for verifying food protection
4:01 certificates and prevent a
4:02 restaurant from being
4:03 penalized solely because the
4:04 physical certificate is not
4:06 present provided the required
4:08 certification can be verified
4:10 as valid digitally and intro
4:13 11 24 sponsored by myself
4:15 would require individuals
4:16 managing or supervising food
4:18 service establishments to
4:19 renew their food protection
4:21 costs certification every fiv
4:23 eyears we will also hear
4:25 proposed intro 405 a and intro
4:28 947 both sponsored by council
4:31 member Riley healthy eating
4:32 habits begin early and the
4:34 food and beverages children
4:35 consume can have lasting
4:36 implications for their health
4:37 and development
4:38 . Proposed intro 405 would
4:40 establish nutrition standards
4:42 for children meals served a
4:44 chain restaurants intro 947
4:46 concerns tobacco boys the bill
4:48 would allow a qualifying
4:50 tobacco bar experiencing
4:51 financial hardship to seek a
4:54 one time transfer of its
4:55 registration and a one tim
4:57 etransfer of its tobacco retail
4:59 dealer license to a New
5:01 location subject to specified
5:03 conditions we look forward t
5:06 ohearing do perspective on the
5:07 the public health implications
5:08 of the proposal and how the
5:10 existing registration and
5:11 licensing framework for
5:13 tobacco bars and tobacco
5:15 retail dealers operates as a
5:16 follow up to our hearing on
5:17 legionnaire's disease this
5:18 past we will also consider my
5:22 legislation introduction 109
5:24 4requiring building owners t
5:26 oreport legionella test results
5:27 of at least 10 colony forming
5:29 units per milliliter to do mh
5:30 timely reporting of test
5:32 results can be a critical
5:33 component of identifying
5:35 potential health risks and
5:37 giving due do h m h access t
5:39 omore testing data could help
5:40 the agency take a more
5:42 proactive approach the metric
5:43 I am proposing this this bill
5:45 was in jurisdictions in canada
5:47 and has been a successful tool
5:48 and proactively addressing
5:51 legionnaire's disease we want
5:51 to understand how the proposed
5:53 requirement would fit into mh
5:55 is existing and whether the
5:57 agency sees a benefit to
5:59 changing this reporting
6:02 threshold finally we will hear
6:04 resolution 152 sponsored by
6:06 council Stevens supporting
6:07 state legislation addressing
6:09 certain food additives as well
6:11 as color additives and foods
6:12 settled in.
6:13 Schools and closing I want
6:14 to thank my colleagues for
6:15 bringing these proposals
6:16 forward I want to thank deputy
6:17 commissioner corine schiff and
6:18 d o h m h for appearing before
6:20 the committee today I look
6:21 forward to a substantive
6:23 discussion about how we can
6:24 strengthen restaurant
6:25 inspection and enforcement
6:26 practices promote food safety
6:27 which we all know is really
6:30 important these days address
6:31 and I want to thank the h
6:34 who've been really on top of
6:35 this issue so addressing
6:37 emerging foodborne illness
6:38 concerns and how we can
6:40 collaborate to ensure that an
6:42 rates rebound together we can
6:43 work to improve these
6:45 processes for restaurants for
6:47 the inspectors and for the
6:48 public with that I would like
6:49 to read a brief statement by
6:51 Council Member send tend to so
6:53 so on her legislation
6:55 . I would like to thank
6:57 councilmember shulman for
6:58 including intro 908 onto
7:00 today's agenda and the
7:01 legislative staff especially
7:02 Christopher pepe for their
7:04 work drafting this bill intro
7:06 908 would close a bureaucratic
7:07 loophole that is hurting
7:08 beloved restaurants across our
7:10 City currently any restaurant
7:11 that is open for business must
7:13 have at least one person on
7:15 site who holds a food
7:17 protection certificate this is
7:18 an important regulation that
7:19 helps keep restaurants safe
7:21 for patrons however when do hm
7:22 h conducts an inspection the
7:25 certified worker must have a
7:26 physical copy of the
7:27 certificate on hand otherwise
7:28 the restaurant could receive a
7:30 serious violation and hefty
7:32 hefty fine despite dohn
7:33 presumably having a database
7:34 that shows who is certified
7:36 . So if a worker forgot to
7:37 bring this certificate to work
7:38 that day the restaurant is
7:40 penalized despite the fact
7:41 that this worker is duly is a
7:43 duly certified food protection
7:45 worker this legislation is
7:46 very simple it would require d
7:48 o h m h to create and maintain
7:50 a digital database a food
7:52 protection certificate holders
7:53 and to consult that database
7:55 during inspections of a worker
7:56 does not have their
7:56 certificate on hand this would
7:59 not eliminate doe mh tze
8:00 ability to enforce the
8:01 underlying rule requiring
8:03 certification in the first
8:04 place and does not change food
8:07 safety requirements it simply
8:07 recognizes that we are in an
8:09 increasingly digital world and
8:10 that checking a database is
8:13 often a more efficient system
8:15 than requiring a worker t
8:16 oremember a physical card every
8:19 day passing this legislation
8:20 would demonstrate to the
8:20 hospital industry that the
8:22 City supports them and wants
8:23 to make it easier for them t
8:24 ocontinue serving our
8:26 neighborhoods for years to
8:27 come
8:27 . Now I would like to read a
8:29 deep brief statement by
8:30 Council Member on his bills
8:32 thank you cheer showman and
8:33 the committee for hearing to
8:35 important pieces of
8:36 legislation focused on the
8:36 health of New York is in
8:38 supporting our local
8:39 businesses first intro 504 a
8:41 the healthy kidsmeals bill as
8:43 a father of three I know
8:45 firsthand how challenging it
8:46 can be to make healthy choices
8:47 for our children when dining
8:49 out families should not have
8:50 to sacrifice their children
8:52 health for convenience and
8:53 healthy options should not
8:54 depend on where a family lives
8:56 or chooses to eat this
8:59 legislation establishes
9:00 stronger nutrition standards
9:01 for children meals including
9:02 fruits vegetables healthier
9:03 beverage options and specific
9:05 nutritional requirements for
9:06 chain restaurants a goal is
9:08 simple make healthier meals
9:10 the standard encourage good
9:11 habits early and give families
9:13 greater confidence in the
9:14 choices available to their
9:16 children next in 9 4
9:18 7addresses the the operation of
9:19 tobacco bars in New York City
9:21 we recognize that longstanding
9:23 businesses can face face
9:25 hardships that that their
9:26 ability to main remain
9:27 operational this legislation
9:29 creates a pathway for eligible d
9:31 tobacco boys to relocate and
9:34 resume operations subject t
9:37 odemonstrated financial
9:37 hardship department of health
9:39 approval and applicable
9:40 requirements it's about
9:43 balancing economic opportunity
9:45 with responsible oversight and
9:45 the interests of our
9:47 communities I look forward t
9:49 otoday's discussion and thank
9:50 my colleagues the legislative
9:51 drafting team and all
9:52 stakeholders who have
9:53 contributed to advancing these
9:55 bills and now I will ask our
9:57 counsel to administer the oath e
10:03 truth the whole truth and
10:04 nothing but the truth before
10:05 this committee and to respond
10:07 honestly to Council Member
10:10 questions yes you proceed with
10:11 your testimony before we do
10:12 that I just want t
10:13 oacknowledge we've been joined
10:14 by council Epstein
10:20 . Good morning chair shulman
10:21 and members of the committee
10:22 my name is corinne schiff and
10:23 I'm the deputy commissioner
10:25 for environmental health at
10:26 the New York City health
10:28 department I'm joined today by
10:29 kim kessler assistant
10:30 commissioner for the bureau of
10:32 chronic disease prevention by
10:34 dr archuleta lonnie director
10:35 of tobacco policy and programs
10:38 and by vasu dha reddy deputy
10:39 director of the bureau of
10:41 communicable diseases on
10:42 behalf of commissioner martin
10:43 thank you for the opportunity
10:45 to testify today about our
10:48 program programs to promote
10:48 food safety address foodborne
10:51 illness outbreaks control
10:53 tobacco advanced nutrition
10:53 efforts in restaurants and
10:55 regulate operation of the
10:56 city's cooling towers the
10:57 sall New yorkers including two
11:03 promote the highest food
11:04 safety standards in New York
11:06 City restaurants respond t
11:07 ofood borne illness outbreaks
11:10 reduce tobacco related disease
11:12 and death encourage
11:13 consumption of healthy foods
11:15 and promote compliance with
11:16 the local law governing
11:19 cooling towers to protect
11:20 diners the department issues
11:22 permits conducts outreach and
11:23 education for restaurant
11:25 owners trains restaurants
11:26 supervisors in food protection d
11:29 inspections and issues
11:31 inspection grades so New York
11:32 er's and the millions who
11:34 visit our City can make
11:36 informed decisions about where
11:37 to eat out about 90% of
11:40 restaurants are currently
11:41 posting an a grade the
11:42 department investigates
11:43 complaints of food poisoning
11:45 and conducts foodborne illness s
11:48 often working with public
11:50 health experts across the
11:51 country as in the recent
11:53 nationwide cyclospora outbreak o
11:55 implements a wide variety of
11:57 measures to protect New York
11:57 er's from the harms of smoking
12:00 and New York City has long
12:02 been a leader in tobacco
12:04 control the city's landmark
12:06 smoke free air act
12:08 dramatically limited indoor
12:09 smoking making New York City a
12:11 model for jurisdictions around
12:12 the world protecting New York
12:13 er's from secondhand smoke and
12:15 normalizing a smoke free
12:17 culture the s f a along with
12:18 other strategies has enabled
12:20 the City to reduce the smoking
12:21 rate by over 50% since 2002
12:25 but smoking remains a leading
12:26 cause of death and continues
12:28 to be a public health priority e
12:31 department have continuously
12:32 strengthened the city's
12:33 tobacco retail and second hand
12:35 smoke policies those efforts
12:37 have paid off in expanded life
12:39 expectancy and a reduction in
12:40 tobacco related diseases and
12:42 deaths most recently chair
12:43 shulman and the City Council
12:47 codified healthy the
12:47 department's plan for
12:49 improving life expectancy and
12:50 creating a healthier City for
12:53 all preventing tobacco use and
12:55 reducing smoking among New
12:56 yorkers is critical t
12:57 oreducing to reaching the
12:59 chronic disease goals set
13:00 under healthy and and
13:02 increasing life expectancy the