Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises

Tuesday, October 20, 2026, 11 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 3

Committee: Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises, chaired by Council Member Louis, met in hybrid format and held votes on two rezoning proposals plus a hearing on a third. The subcommittee approved a rezoning for 455 Coney Island Avenue in Council Member Felder's district for a 300-bed nursing home (LU 142-243), and a rezoning for 135-227 Sapphire Street in Council Member Ariola's district for a residential project with 260 apartments, 67 permanently affordable (LU 144-145); both items were referred to the full Land Use Committee. The subcommittee then held a hearing on the Studio 54 rehabilitation and zoning text amendment (LU 153-154), in which the applicant panel from Roundabout Theatre Company, its land use counsel, and its architect presented the rehabilitation plan and the transfer of development rights mechanism, Council Member Wilson voiced support and asked questions, and one member of the public testified in support. The hearing was closed with the items laid over.

Transcript

0:11 Starting webinar good morning

0:11 welcome to welcome to today's

0:14 New York City Council vote for

0:16 the subcommittee on zoning in

0:17 franchises at this time I

0:18 would like to remind everyone

0:20 to silence all electronic

0:22 devices also at this point

0:23 going forward no one is t

0:24 oapproach to this hey we're

0:28 ready to begin

0:30 . Good morning and welcome t

0:31 oa meeting of the subcommittee

0:33 on zoning and franchises I'm

0:35 Council Member lewis chair of

0:37 the subcommittee this morning

0:38 we are joined by a council

0:41 member shulman salam Felder

0:44 Encarnación jason chest Thomas

0:46 Henry and Wilson today we are

0:48 voting on two proposals and

0:50 holding one hearing two

0:52 proposals that we the two

0:54 proposals that we will vote on

0:55 are 455 coney island avenue

0:59 community facility rezoning

1:00 and councilmember felder's

1:02 district 1 35 2 27 sapphire

1:06 street residential rezoning

1:08 and councilmember member

1:08 areola tze district we will

1:10 then hold the hearing

1:13 regarding studio 54 we have

1:15 and tax amendment and and

1:18 council district this meeting

1:19 is being held in hybrid format o

1:22 wish to testify and testify in

1:24 person or via zoom members of

1:26 the public wishing to testify

1:28 remotely register by visiting

1:29 the New York City Council web

1:32 at www dot counsel dot dot

1:36 backslash land use to sign up

1:38 or for those of you there in

1:40 the room today please see one

1:42 of the sergeants arms t

1:44 oprepare and submit a speaker

1:45 card members of the public

1:47 also view a live stream

1:48 broadcast of the meeting at

1:49 the council's website when you

1:51 are called to testify before

1:53 the subcommittee if you are

1:54 joining us remotely you remain l

1:59 recognized by myself to speak

2:00 when you are recognized your

2:01 microphone will be unutilized

2:03 we will limit public testimony

2:06 to two minutes per witness if

2:07 you have additional testimony

2:08 that you would like to the t

2:10 oconsider or if you have

2:11 written testimony that you

2:12 would like to submit instead

2:13 of appearing in person please

2:15 email mail it land use

2:17 testimony at counsel dot dot

2:19 aww written testimony be

2:22 submitted up to three days

2:23 after the hearing is closed

2:25 please indicate the l you

2:26 number in project name in the

2:28 subject line of your email we

2:30 request that witnesses joining

2:31 us remotely remain in the

2:32 meeting until excused by the

2:33 chair as council members have

2:35 questions lastly for everyon

2:36 eattending today's meeting this

2:37 is a government proceeding and

2:40 decorum must be observed at

2:41 all times members of the

2:43 public are acts not to t

2:45 oduring the meeting unless you

2:47 are testifying the witness

2:48 table is reserved for people

2:49 who are called to testify and

2:51 no video recording or

2:53 photography is allowed from

2:54 the witness table further

2:56 members of the public not

2:58 present audio or video

3:00 recordings as testimony but

3:02 submit transcripts of such

3:03 recordings to the sergeant at

3:05 arms for inclusion into the

3:06 hearing record we will now

3:08 proceed with the two votes the

3:11 first vote concerns l use 142

3:13 243 regarding the 1 14 55

3:17 coney island avenue rezoning

3:18 proposal and Council Member

3:19 felder's district applicant is

3:20 seeking to develop a nursing

3:21 home with 300 beds in midwood

3:24 brooklyn the proposal involves

3:26 two actions the first is a

3:28 zoning map amendment to change

3:29 the existing residential r

3:31 five district with a c 2-

3:33 3commercial overlay to a

3:35 commercial c 4- 5 d the secon

3:37 daction is the zoning text

3:39 amendment to map a mandatory

3:41 inclusionary housing area

3:42 because the rezoning would

3:44 increase the allowable

3:46 residential density a secon

3:48 dvote concerns l use 1 44 and 1

3:50 45 regarding the 1 35 2 20

3:54 sapphire boulevard rezoning

3:55 proposal and Council Member

3:56 areola tze district applicant

3:58 is proposing to build a

4:00 residential project with 260

4:03 apartments of 67 would be

4:04 permanently affordable the

4:05 proposal involves two actions

4:07 the first is a zoning map

4:08 amendment to change the

4:11 existing residential r fou

4:12 rdistrict to a residential r

4:13 six a district the secon

4:15 daction is a zoning text

4:17 amendment to map a mandatory

4:19 inclusionary housing area

4:20 Council Member areola this

4:23 application counsel are there

4:25 any members are there any

4:25 council members with questions

4:27 or remarks at this time no

4:29 chair I now call for a vote t

4:31 oapprove l use hundred 42 14

4:33 3related to the 455 coney

4:35 island island avenue and l use

4:39 14445 related to the 1 35 2 27

4:43 sapphire street council please

4:44 call the roll chair lewis I

4:49 don't know councilmember

4:52 shulman I I know councilmember

4:58 callum Council Member Felder

5:02 Council Member I councilmember

5:09 Sanchez I councilmember Thomas

5:13 Henry.

5:13 I my vote of seven the zer

5:16 oopposing in their abstention

5:17 the items are approved as oh.

5:24 Let's add one more vote this

5:27 Council Member would I so my

5:31 nom bi italia of aiding the

5:33 affirmative zero posing in

5:34 your abstention the items are

5:35 approved as described by the

5:36 chair and these items are now

5:38 referred to a full end use

5:40 committee.

5:40 Perfect we are now joined

5:42 also by councilman Farías.

5:44 Good morning I will now open

5:46 the hearing on l use 153 and 1

5:49 54 regarding studio 5

5:51 4rehabilitation and text

5:52 amendment and Council Member

5:54 district the applicant is

5:55 seeking to restore and old

5:57 theater in midtown and

5:58 transfer the development

6:00 rights generated by the lot

6:01 where the theater is located

6:03 for anyone wishing to testify

6:04 regarding this proposal

6:06 remotely if you have not

6:07 already done so you must

6:08 register online by visiting

6:10 the council's website at

6:11 counsel dot dot gov backslash

6:13 land use for anyone with us in

6:15 person please see one of the

6:16 sergeant at arms to submit a

6:18 speaker card if you would

6:20 prefer to if sorry sorry if

6:22 you would prefer to testimony

6:23 you can always do so by

6:25 emailing it to land use

6:26 testimony at counsel dot dot

6:29 gov we've also been joined by

6:32 councilmember Carr I now

6:33 recognize counsel Wilson for

6:34 remarks thank you chair good

6:36 stheater companies studio 5

6:43 4rehabilitation and their land

6:45 use application studio 54 is

6:47 an iconic part of New York

6:49 city's cultural history and

6:51 preserving spaces like this is

6:53 essential to keeping our

6:54 city's arts and entertainment

6:56 industry vibrant and

6:57 accessible for generations t

6:59 ocome theater is more than just

7:01 entertainment it supports jobs l

7:05 economy brings visitors to our

7:07 neighborhoods and creates

7:09 opportunities for artists and

7:09 audience from all walks of

7:12 life as Council Member for a

7:13 that that hosts some of the

7:15 city's most enduring cultural

7:17 touchstones I believe we have

7:19 a responsibility to protect

7:21 these institutions that make

7:23 our neighborhoods unique while

7:25 ensuring they can continue to

7:26 grow and serve our communities w

7:31 broadway and the theater and

7:33 our culture scene doesn't just

7:36 happen it takes investment and

7:38 it takes stewardship and this

7:40 project is a great investment

7:43 in the future of our broadway

7:45 scene in our cultural

7:46 landscape so I want to thank

7:48 roundabout theater for its

7:49 continued investment in New

7:51 York City and I look forward

7:52 to seeing studio 54 continu

7:55 eto thrive as an important part

7:56 of our city's.

7:57 Theatrical future thank you

7:59 . Thank you councilmember

8:00 Wilson we will now now reopen

8:01 the vote for a minority leader

8:05 car thank you so none by a

8:06 revised count for a secon

8:09 dtime a vote of 93 affirmative

8:12 zero opposing and zer

8:13 oabstentions the items are

8:14 approved as described every

8:15 turn these items are now

8:15 referred to a full land use

8:17 committee.

8:17 Thank you counsel I will now

8:20 open I went out called the

8:22 applicant panel for this

8:23 proposal which consists of

8:25 carol rosenthal Christopher

8:27 nave and france ile lim

8:28 council could you please

8:30 administer the oath once they

8:31 up here good morning you can

8:41 have a seat oh tonight yes can

8:55 you please raise your right

8:57 hand and state your name for

9:00 the record france elim.

9:03 Christopher nave carol

9:05 rosenthal you swear it over t

9:07 oyou for for nothing but the

9:07 truth in your testimony this

9:08 morning in your sponsor

9:10 Council Member questions yes

9:15 thank you thank you counsel

9:16 you now begin your testimony

9:17 which is limited to 10 minutes e

9:21 your presentation after eight

9:22 minutes when you begin your

9:24 presentation please restate

9:25 your name and the name of your

9:26 organization you begin thank

9:28 you chair lewis and fellow

9:29 members of the zoning

9:30 subcommittee for your time

9:32 today to review our euler

9:34 application my name is Chris

9:35 knave and I am the chief

9:37 advancement officer at

9:38 roundabout theater company

9:39 with us today are carol

9:40 rosenthal from freed Frank

9:42 french elle from any ad

9:44 architects as well as other

9:45 members of our team if you're

9:47 following along you can go t

9:49 othe next slide before handing

9:51 it off to my colleagues who

9:53 will speak specifics on our

9:54 requested actions and proposed

9:57 rehabilitation at studio 54 I

9:59 will share an overview of our

10:01 organization's mission and

10:02 impact as the nation's largest .

10:05 Company originally founded

10:07 in 19 65 roundabout is one of

10:09 only four nonprofits operating

10:11 on broadway our mission is t

10:13 ocelebrate the power of theater

10:16 by spotlighting classics from

10:18 the past cultivating New works

10:20 of the present and educating

10:21 minds for the future we

10:23 operate five theaters on and

10:25 off broadway within

10:27 manhattan's theater district

10:28 annually annually we produce 6

10:29 2 8 classics New plays and

10:31 musicals and reach

10:32 approximately half a million

10:33 theater goers we employ over

10:35 1500 full and part time staff

10:37 members and our work has been

10:39 recognized with 42 tony awards d

10:42 many other honors

10:44 . We're most proud to serve

10:46 30000 New York City students

10:48 teachers and lifelong learners

10:49 through tailored partnerships

10:51 with public schools and

10:52 libraries and all fiv

10:54 eboroughs most notably we

10:56 operate a nationally

10:58 recognized theatrical

10:58 workforce development program

10:59 and partnership with ioc and

11:01 the City of New York we are

11:02 proud of the 150 young New

11:06 yorkers trained to date 86% of

11:08 whom are working in performing

11:09 arts thanks to the city's

11:12 considerable $26.6 million

11:15 commitment with one third of

11:16 that coming from City Council

11:18 this will be the first

11:20 comprehensive renovation of

11:20 studio 54 in its hundred year

11:24 life cycle we're grateful t

11:25 ocouncilmember Wilson and his

11:27 colleagues across the City for

11:30 supporting this project we're

11:31 also appreciative of the

11:33 community board five an

11:34 dmanhattan borough president

11:35 brad oilman siegel for their

11:36 support of our land use

11:39 application I

11:39 . Just want to say before I

11:40 turn it over to carol among

11:41 our many priorities we are

11:42 committed to honoring the

11:43 legacy of studio 54 an

11:47 dmaintaining its tradition as

11:48 an epicenter of creativity

11:50 connection and artistic

11:51 expression and I'll hand it

11:52 over to carol

11:54 . Thank you we can turn to the

11:56 next slide I'm carol rosenthal k

12:01 representing roundabout about

12:02 today the theater is sort of

12:05 the north of the theater

12:06 district which you can see on

12:08 the slide to the left in

12:12 yellow and it's located on the

12:14 west street that's the main

12:15 theater building the entrance

12:17 is located off of west 54

12:20 street it goes through a 19

12:23 story office building it it's

12:23 an easement through the ground

12:25 floor also on the same zoning

12:27 lot is a third building which

12:30 is a 43 story building built

12:32 . About 25 years ago we can go

12:35 to the next side this is a

12:37 picture of it showing it from

12:40 the 54 street entrance and

12:42 showing it from the 53 street

12:45 where the actual theater

12:46 building is located and on the

12:49 next slide um you can see some

12:51 of the interior as it exists

12:55 today both what's happening t

12:56 othe left and also the theater

13:00 itself which has certain

13:01 components that are different

13:02 than many theaters including

13:05 no orchestra pit and I don't

13:07 know if you can tell from the

13:09 slide but the seats on the top

13:12 mezzanine are extremely

13:13 pitched like you sort of feel

13:16 like you're going to fly over

13:16 when you're when you're on

13:19 them

13:19 . So next slide Chris

13:21 mentioned that the theater has

13:23 a hundred year old history it

13:25 started in 19 27 as the gallo

13:29 opera house it was to compete

13:31 with the metropolitan opera

13:33 house and we know what

13:34 happened in that competition

13:36 stelevision shows studiossed by

13:43 . And then after that it went

13:45 through kind of a sallow time

13:50 until 19:00 77 where it became

13:51 the famous or something

13:53 infamous studio 54 and between

13:59 43 and 77 2 for the use of a

14:01 television studio the was

14:04 straightened so that the seats

14:06 came down and the orchestra

14:07 pit was filled ah after studio

14:10 54 which to my surprise only

14:12 lasted two years in our minds

14:14 that looms much larger it went

14:16 through a hole the building

14:18 went through a period of.

14:21 Difficulty and eventually

14:23 into a foreclosure and was

14:26 purchased by the

14:28 . Allied partners finally in

14:33 19 98 roundabout whose whose

14:33 cabaret show was having and

14:35 the results of an emergency

14:36 had to move to another theater

14:39 quickly and it moved to thi

14:42 stheater because cabaret had

14:43 suited cabaret with its flat

14:45 floor in 2003 roundabout

14:48 purchased studio 54 with the

14:49 help of the City and has run

14:53 it operated it since 2003 as a

14:55 not for profit theater next

15:02 next slide

15:02 . Two actions one is there is

15:06 existing in this running

15:08 resolution a theater

15:10 rehabilitation bonus so this