Wednesday, June 17, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), Council Chambers - City Hall
Committee: Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection
The Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, chaired by Council Member Harvey D. Epstein, held a hearing on Introduction 891, banning surveillance pricing, and Introduction 892, restricting grocery stores to one price increase per item in a 24-hour period. Speaker Julie Menin, sponsor of Intro 891, presented Council research documenting varied pricing across rideshare accounts, digital shelf labels capable of thousands of daily price changes, and data-based price manipulation. DCWP Commissioner Sam Levine testified in support of both bills, recommending a private right of action and data-use limits, and estimated eight additional staff lines would be needed. Public Advocate Jumaane Williams supported both bills, highlighting discriminatory impacts on communities of color. Public testimony included the State Attorney General's office (supportive), labor unions urging a ban on electronic shelf labels and stronger loyalty-program definitions, industry groups opposing the bills as overly broad, and consumer/privacy advocates supporting them. No votes were taken; discussion focused on amendments.
0:31 . Good morning. Good morning.
0:31 Welcome to the New York City
0:33 council hearing on the
0:34 committee on consumer and
0:35 hold on. Good morning. Goo
5:18 dmorning. Welcome to the New
5:19 York City Council hearing on a
5:19 committee on consumer and work
5:21 protection at this time,
5:23 please silence electronics and
5:24 do not approach the dais again
5:25 . Please do not approach the
5:28 dais if you're testifying or
5:28 have any other questions or
5:30 concerns, please contact a
5:31 sergeant at arms. Thank you
5:32 for your cooperation chairs
5:33 you begin. Thank you. Good
5:39 morning, everyone. My name.
5:42 Dahlia, my gavel. Thank you
5:43 .thank you for joining the
5:44 legislative hearing today and
5:44 the council's consumer work of
5:47 protection on introduction t
5:52 o291 and 8 92. I want to thank
5:53 the majority leader and the
5:54 speaker for end for advancing
5:57 this legislation will
5:58 recognize my colleagues who
5:59 are here, uh, cancels a member
6:04 and on it is areola and
6:09 Council Member Hanks was here,
6:10 but I think she's going to be
6:11 coming back and I would like
6:12 to be able to turn over to the
6:13 speaker for our opening
6:15 statement.
6:15 Great, thank you so much, I
6:16 first of all I want to thank
6:18 chair Epstein for holding
6:20 today's hearing. I'm Julie
6:21 Menin, of the New York City
6:23 council. I want to thank the
6:24 administration for testifyin
6:28 gtoday I'm here today t
6:28 odiscuss a bill in relation to
6:32 prohibiting surveillance,
6:32 pricing and it's also one that
6:33 I am proud to sponsor that's
6:35 introduction, 8 91 and also
6:39 proud to support introduction
6:43 8 9 by majority leader Shaun
6:44 Abreu relation to restricting
6:46 the frequency of price
6:47 increases in growth stores so
6:50 first of all I want to start
6:53 by defining some of these
6:53 terms because I think this
6:55 will be useful surveillance
6:57 pricing is a practice of
6:58 setting a price that utilizes
7:00 at consumers personal data
7:03 collected through surveillance
7:06 technology. The price feet or
7:07 discount that is set for one
7:09 consumer group of consumers
7:11 differ from the price feet or
7:13 discount that is set for
7:14 another consumer group of
7:16 consumers based on that. You
7:18 of personal data, this
7:22 personal data can be gathered.
7:23 It can be purchased or it can
7:24 be acquired from a third party
7:28 . Dynamic pricing is the
7:29 practice of changing t prihece
7:30 for a consumer good or service
7:32 literally in real time,
7:36 sometimes instantaneously,
7:37 sometimes multiple times a day
7:40 dynamic pricing utilize this
7:41 that analyzes minute to minut
7:43 emarket forces to opt revenue
7:47 as a former small business
7:48 owner and the former
7:49 commissioner of the department
7:51 of consumer affairs. I'v
7:51 ereally seen this issue from
7:54 all perspectives. New York
7:55 City consumers deserve price,
7:58 transparency and price,
7:59 predictability, and they need
8:01 to be able to understand the
8:02 prices of their goods in order
8:06 to make informed, reasonable
8:07 purchase decisions, however,
8:08 that is not the experience
8:10 that consumers are having or
8:12 about to have in light of
8:14 advancements in technology,
8:15 which should be utilized to
8:18 benefit consumers, many
8:20 shoppers are noticing a
8:23 troubling, for example
8:24 ,perhaps someone searches
8:25 online for the perfect next
8:28 jersey to wear to the parade
8:29 tomorrow, they find the ideal
8:32 one and it's priced at $50
8:33 when they show their friend
8:35 their purchase, they
8:36 discovered that their friend
8:38 bought literally the exact
8:39 same jersey from the exact
8:41 same retailer at the exact
8:42 same time but paid only $30.
8:45 Or another example.
8:47 Many New yorkers have had
8:48 experience where they're
8:49 leaving a bar after a night up
8:52 and a group of roommates all
8:53 order a for hire vehicle at
8:55 the exact same time only to
8:57 discover that each one of them
8:58 is quoted a different price t
9:00 obe taken on the exact same
9:05 route or perhaps most
9:05 troubling at all there is
9:07 technology that supermarkets
9:08 could potentially utilized
9:09 where if you place a bunch of
9:12 bananas listed at $3 into your
9:15 carts after you get to the
9:16 checkout counter that price is
9:18 now scanning at $7 for those
9:21 bananas New yorkers should be
9:23 protected from this type of
9:25 price, inconsistency and
9:28 unpredictability, and more
9:28 importantly, they deserve to
9:30 understand how and why it's
9:32 happening in our research and
9:33 I want to be clear. We sent
9:35 investigators out to look at
9:36 this issue in our research,
9:38 the council has discovered the
9:40 following examples of
9:40 surveillance and dynamic
9:43 pricing is, by the way. Not an
9:44 exhaustive bliss. I'm just
9:44 going to lift some of the
9:45 examples we found major
9:47 grocery chains are beginning
9:49 to roll out digital shelf
9:50 labels that enable stories t
9:53 oeasily update prices grocery
9:54 stores that have implemented
9:55 them report that they can
9:56 change a price of items up t
9:58 o2000 times per day.
10:02 Investigations have found that
10:03 major chain retailers set
10:05 different prices based on
10:06 consumers proximity to their
10:08 store competitive store wit
10:08 hthe price of a television at
10:11 one store increasing from
10:17 $499.0 9 to $599.0 9 when the
10:18 consumer pulled into these
10:19 stores parking lot a
10:22 behavioral economists who
10:22 worked at a rideshare company
10:24 revealed that the application
10:27 increases prices when a
10:29 consumer's phone battery is
10:30 low because they might not be
10:32 otherwise be able to get home
10:34 if they don't accept the high
10:38 offer an outside investigation
10:40 published in December 2025
10:41 found that a grocery delivery
10:43 platform was engaging in
10:45 algorithmic pricing
10:46 experiments that resulted in
10:47 consumers paying a for the
10:50 same products from the same
10:51 store at the same time with
10:53 the differences as high as 23%
11:00 for certain products on April
11:01 18 and airlines ex accountant
11:02 suggested a customer try
11:05 clearing there their account
11:06 and their cookies are booking
11:08 with an incognito window after
11:11 the customer complained about
11:11 a $230 increase in their
11:15 ticket price within one day
11:17 indicating that the company is
11:20 using personal browsing data
11:22 to set flight prices and
11:23 finally from our own
11:25 investigation that we did
11:28 using 10 different ride share
11:30 accounts to conduct
11:32 approximately 370 pricing
11:34 checks that are investigators
11:36 did across three standar
11:38 droots. Our investigation found
11:41 consistent variation and
11:42 discounts across accounts some
11:45 accounts repeatedly received
11:47 automatically applied
11:47 discounts that other accounts,
11:48 viewing the same route at the
11:50 same moment did not, so that
11:53 otherwise identical riders
11:53 were quoted different final
11:57 prices, at least one account
11:58 received no discotsun at all
11:59 of us. It is crucial that
12:08 government acts now to prevent
12:10 this predatory behavior from
12:11 becoming any more common, and
12:12 I just want to say if somebody
12:15 practice consumer protection
12:16 law for a very long time that
12:17 issue with dynamic and
12:21 surveillance pricing is it's
12:22 insidious the consumer
12:24 sometimes can't even detect I
12:26 t. So, for example, we know
12:27 that if you're doing online
12:31 shopping and you have a cart
12:31 and you leave that cart open
12:33 and don't purchase the goods
12:35 we know that some companies
12:36 are mining that personal data
12:39 and utilizing that to know
12:40 that you might be willing t
12:41 opay that price and then to
12:43 jack up the price. Accordingly
12:45 , we were thrilled to see that
12:47 our state colleagues passed
12:48 the one fair price act, and
12:50 I'm grateful to the attorney
12:52 general for her leadership in
12:53 getting this bill across the
12:56 finish line. We're looking
12:56 forward to the governor
12:58 signing the bill and I'm proud
13:00 to be sponsoring this
13:01 companion legislation t
13:02 oprotect consumers here in New
13:05 York City as a former
13:06 commissioner of the department
13:06 consumer, consumer affairs. I
13:07 know how robust or local
13:09 protections are for New York
13:10 City residents and our efforts
13:12 to partner with the state will
13:13 strengthen them. I also look
13:15 forward to hearing from the
13:16 department of consumer and
13:18 work protection today to learn
13:19 about how we can work together
13:23 to further protect New yorkers
13:24 . The legislation will discuss
13:25 today is rooted in a vision of
13:27 New York that is more
13:29 affordable for everyone that
13:30 calls are great City home that
13:33 brings transparency and equity
13:35 to pricing it gives New
13:37 yorkers more predictability
13:39 and affordability in their
13:41 purchases and it empowers them
13:42 to make more educated consumer
13:45 decisions and ultimately we
13:46 hope we can play a role in
13:47 driving down the costs of
13:49 various types of consumer
13:49 goods in our City. I look
13:51 forward to hearing the
13:52 administration's testimony
13:53 today. Thank you, chair. And
13:58 they thank you, speaker men in
13:59 I really appreciate your
13:59 effort in your your attention
14:01 to this really critical issue,
14:04 and so when New yorkers go t
14:05 othe store. You know, we look
14:06 at ourselves and we figure out
14:07 there's a price there and we
14:08 expect that's to be the price
14:10 and that we expect that's wha
14:11 twe're going to pay. That's the
14:14 history that of our lives and
14:18 our childhood and its benefits
14:19 consumers because consumer can
14:20 go from one store to another
14:21 and say I can compare prices
14:23 from this store to the other
14:24 and that's a system that's
14:25 been brought up in this
14:26 country and it's been fair.
14:29 Today we see a very distant,
14:30 different system arising as
14:31 the speaker mentioned. You
14:32 know, if you get on a cab.
14:34 That's a price in the cab. But
14:35 if you take an uber to peopl
14:37 eare taking the same uber going
14:39 to have really widely variety
14:42 of prices. This technology is
14:43 changing the system and we can
14:44 no longer expect the goods
14:45 when prices will be the remain
14:47 the same for two people for
14:49 the same items the bills we're
14:50 hearing today will seek t
14:52 oadjust these practices and
14:53 leverage data that change
14:54 prices in real time
14:56 surveillance, bracing and
15:00 dynamic pricing as the
15:00 speakers had surveillanc
15:01 epricing is used consumer
15:03 personal information and
15:04 individualized pricing,
15:05 meaning consumers buying the
15:06 same product the same time be
15:10 different prices. Dynamic
15:11 pricing as the speaker of
15:12 reference pricing refers t
15:14 oreal time in real time
15:16 adjustments, surprises based
15:17 on demand or other factors not
15:19 specified tile tied to the
15:20 personal data information, the
15:23 bills we have hearing today
15:24 addresses both.
15:25 Issues. I look forward to a
15:27 robust conversation with the
15:29 administration and with people
15:31 testifying today and I and I
15:33 know we don't have any other
15:40 testimonies. Uh, and then so
15:41 I'm going to know have the
15:43 administration's sworn in
15:51 . Do you affirm to tell the
15:51 truth, the whole truth and
15:52 nothing but the truth before
15:53 this committee and to respond
15:54 honestly to Council Member
15:55 . Questions I do what and and
15:57 the commissioner just want to
15:59 a denver who's at the table
16:00 with you today and we'll will
16:04 be testifying? Sure. I'm sam
16:04 levine, commissioner of
16:05 consumer worker protection.
16:06 I'm joined by carlos ortiz,
16:07 our chief of staff and deputy
16:10 commissioner for external
16:10 affairs and andy Frank are
16:11 associate general counsel
16:15 . I shall I proceed. Please,
16:16 please do. Commissioner? Um,
16:20 good morning, Madam speaker
16:21 cherubs and memrs obef the
16:22 committee of consumer and work
16:24 protection as a mentioned I'm
16:25 sam levin and commissioner,
16:27 I'm joined by my to colleagues
16:30 . Um, thank you for the
16:31 opportunity to testify before
16:32 the committee today on these
16:34 bills, the university
16:35 department of consumer merkel
16:36 protection is the nation's
16:38 leading municipal enforcement
16:39 agency charged with delivering
16:42 economic justice leverage I
16:43 sits authority to bring New
16:44 yorkers really economic relief
16:45 and protect them from
16:47 predatory, deceptive and
16:48 unfair practices that violate
16:49 the rights as consumers and
16:52 workers. This includes
16:52 pioneering cutting edge
16:53 protection such as the city's
16:55 consumer protection law t
16:56 oprotect the time ofthe law
16:57 workweek law and delivery
16:59 worker laws, including the
17:00 minimum pay raise for deliver
17:03 yworkers
17:04 . To licensing more than 45000
17:04 businesses in over 4
17:07 5industries insures fair
17:08 competition in a level playing
17:10 field for responsible small
17:11 businesses that are integral
17:12 in New York city's vibrant
17:15 communities also provides
17:16 essential services such as
17:18 free tax preparation and
17:19 financial counseling to insert
17:21 New yorkers keep more of what
17:22 they earn and complain for
17:24 their futures is committed t
17:25 omake it sure, New York is of
17:27 New York City is a fairer,
17:28 more affordable place to live.
17:32 Let me now turn to the
17:32 subject of today's hearing
17:33 dynamic in surveillance.
17:36 Pricing. I commend the
17:37 speaker and majority leader
17:38 for these bold steps to ensure
17:39 New York remains a leader when
17:41 it comes to a need t
17:43 oprotecting consumers from
17:44 emerging pricing abuses. This
17:47 is an issue I care about
17:48 deeply over the last two years
17:49 . I have launched federal
17:51 studies published reports and
17:52 testified before the united
17:54 states senate and the threat
17:55 these practices pose it, as
17:59 with many issues facing
17:59 american consumers today, the
18:01 federal government is a at the
18:02 wheel that is why these bills,
18:04 which would harm New yorkers
18:05 with the strongest safeguards
18:07 in the united states are so
18:11 critical the fat is large
18:12 corporations are getting ever
18:13 better and ripping us off if
18:15 you listen carefully to what
18:16 executives are telling
18:17 investors on recent earnings
18:19 calls they are often boasting