Committee on Finance

Tuesday, May 26, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), Council Chambers - City Hall

Committee: Committee on Finance

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

This joint executive budget hearing for fiscal year 2027 covered the Department for the Aging, the city's three public library systems, and the Department of Cultural Affairs. Council members questioned the Aging commissioner on contract reimbursement timelines, indirect cost rate backlogs, capital project delays at older adult centers, transportation services, and meals programs. Library leaders praised the baselining of $31.7 million in operating funds but described roughly $983 million in combined unfunded capital needs and new unfunded prescription-drug benefit costs. The Cultural Affairs commissioner presented a $10 million baseline increase, discussed grant panel changes and racial equity plan metrics, and the Manhattan borough president testified in support of a full $30 million increase. No votes were taken; public testimony on all agencies was scheduled for June 10.

Transcript

0:06 Morning. Welcome to New York

0:06 City Council executive budget

0:09 hearing for the company on

0:10 finance. Joann with the

0:11 committee on aging and

0:12 cultural affairs libraries in

0:14 international relations,

0:15 please. Signs all cell phone

0:16 electronic devices moving

0:17 forward no one is to approach

0:18 today is chairs

0:19 . We are ready to begin. Great

0:21 . Thank you. Good morning and

0:24 welcome to the first day of

0:26 the fiscal 20 27 executive

0:28 budget hearings on council

0:30 member Linda Lee today's

0:32 hearings will begin with

0:34 department for the aging,

0:35 followed by the city's library

0:36 systems and the department of

0:40 cultural affairs. I am pleased

0:41 to be joined by my colleagues,

0:41 Council Member Susan of the

0:43 committee on aging and we are

0:44 also joined by council shulman

0:47 Council Member Brewer and I

0:48 think that is it for now et m

0:51 e. So I want to welcome

0:53 .welcome to commissioner dr

0:54 lisa scott mckenzie and your

0:57 team. Uh, thank you all for

0:59 joining us today to answer our

1:01 questions on May 12 2026, the

1:04 administration released

1:04 executive financial plan for

1:05 fiscal 20 26 2 20 30 with a

1:09 proposed fiscal 27 budget of

1:15 the department for the aging

1:16 proposed fiscal 2027 budget of

1:21 represents less than 1% of the

1:24 administration's proposed by

1:24 27 budget in the executive

1:28 plan

1:28 . This is an increase of or

1:30 point 6% from the originally

1:35 budgeted in the fiscal 27

1:37 preliminary plan this

1:38 increased results from several

1:40 actions, mostly due t

1:43 oadditional fundings to support

1:43 indirect cost rates for human

1:45 service contracts as of April

1:47 2026 lift its head count was

1:49 300, David, which is 3

1:50 9positions less than their

1:52 physical 26 budgeted headcount

1:54 in the counsel's preliminary

1:55 budget response we called o

1:56 nthe Mayor to add $2 millio

1:57 nstiffed us budget to continue

2:01 one year funding for a council

2:01 priority that was included in

2:03 fiscal 26 for case management.

2:06 Services. We also called on

2:07 the administration to provide

2:08 additional metrics in the

2:09 mayor's management report on

2:12 the demand for types of meals

2:13 distributed at our older adult

2:15 centers and further details on

2:17 the meal distributions of our

2:19 home delivered meals and case

2:20 management metrics on the

2:21 level of assistance provided.

2:24 Further and our preliminary

2:26 budget hearing we called on

2:27 the administration to increase

2:29 City funded meals for older

2:30 adult population in light of

2:32 hr one federal funding cuts on

2:35 the council side I introduce

2:36 dlegislation which would expand

2:37 home delivered meals for

2:40 solely for solely weekdays. 7

2:43 2 7 Days a week as food

2:44 assistance for our older adult

2:47 population should not be

2:47 restricted to just business

2:49 days we were disappointed t

2:50 osee that our request was not

2:51 included in the plan.

2:53 And so we look forward t

2:55 olistening to your testimony

2:56 and hearing your thoughts on

2:58 many of these things that

2:59 we've brought up and I

2:59 . Will now turn it to my co

3:01 chair for this hearing,

3:02 Council Member Susan joining

3:03 her opening statement. Thank

3:07 you. Financed year. Good

3:08 morning, everyone. My name is

3:10 student wrong, wrong. I serve

3:11 owner to cheer my secon

3:16 dbudget hearing at the chair on

3:18 physical or 2027 executive

3:20 budget for New York City

3:21 department of for a for the

3:23 aging also have no as aging.

3:27 Thank you to agents

3:29 commissioner lisa scott

3:30 mckenzie for joining us. Thank

3:33 you to the order doubts at the

3:35 vacates and the community

3:37 members who have joined us

3:38 today, I will keep my comments

3:40 here brief and they request

3:44 that commissioner keep her all

3:45 road brief. So we can move on

3:48 questions for council members

3:49 and like to continue my New

3:50 tradition in the aging

3:53 committee, where each hearing

3:55 were showed some pictures of

3:56 the pictures from the always

4:00 see centers, which is one o

4:03 fthem. I actually a visits

4:06 there, and that's his

4:07 condition in some senior

4:09 centers, which is terrible,

4:11 it's essential that.

4:13 New York City government,

4:15 both in council and that is

4:15 the aging come face to face

4:19 with real issues order about

4:23 your language.

4:24 They, in fact, fact order

4:25 that's living every day, every

4:27 day, older doubts and the

4:28 people who serve them are

4:31 forced to exit in these

4:33 conditions, we must hold or

4:37 agency accountable, ordered

4:38 out and ordered does provider

4:41 network have face challenging

4:42 past few years you to pandemic

4:49 budgetary constraints as world

4:51 inflation and all the

4:51 increased cost of leaving I

4:54 look forward to working

4:57 collaboratively with providers

4:59 and the administration to hel

5:00 pcity the one point a million

5:03 order doubts overcome those

5:05 challenges on the aging have

5:07 critical role to play in

5:10 assessing the meeting the

5:13 needs of older doubts and a

5:15 collaborating with the

5:17 provider network and the

5:18 council to harness best

5:21 practice and the created

5:22 innovatively approach to best

5:23 serve our cities growing

5:27 population of older adults on

5:30 agents fiscal 2027, exactly

5:33 budget is which is more than

5:40 the physical to 7 27

5:43 preliminary budget.

5:45 Additionally, exactly budget

5:46 is less than physical 226

5:52 adopted budget as a consul of

5:55 discretionary initiativ

5:55 efunding is not yet, including

5:57 in physical 20027 despite

6:01 serving almost 20% of the City

6:07 of population for less than 1

6:09 %of the city's of all budget,

6:13 which is probably only point

6:15 6%, which is simple and not

6:17 sufficient to meet the needs

6:19 of other doubts in the City,

6:20 the executive plan includes

6:24 one you need, which at 4.2

6:29 million to baseline budget

6:29 starting in fiscal 2 20 24.

6:32 More actually, by the budget

6:35 for expect the cost for the in

6:38 rage for human service

6:41 contract, but enough of that

6:43 director service or program

6:44 for all their doubts. The

6:46 other adjustments mean this

6:49 plan were modest, which added

6:53 in physical 2026 and the friso

7:02 2027, saving indicated in the

7:04 plan total seven point. I'm

7:06 milling in fifth call 2026 an

7:09 d3 mailing in fiscal 2027 and

7:12 the in the out years. I'm

7:14 disappointed to not see deeper

7:16 investment in older doubts in

7:19 this plan and add chair of

7:20 this committee I look forward

7:23 to working alongside the

7:24 administration to come up with

7:26 New ways to create front and

7:28 the implement to expanded

7:29 service for other adapts.

7:33 Agents capital commitment

7:35 plant, the smallest in the

7:37 City 50 or five point a over

7:41 fiscal 2026 2 2030 a a

7:46 decrease of 26.5% when

7:50 compared to the politic memory

7:53 capital commitment plant

7:54 largest due to the project

7:56 being delayed and the push

7:58 further into the outer years

8:01 with over 300 older thou

8:04 center and about 60etwo nrk

8:08 sin agent nate work this

8:11 funding is in fish in even

8:14 sufficient to properly address

8:16 all the infrastructure needs

8:17 like this one, you see, I

8:19 believe that capital program

8:21 could be enhanced to help

8:24 refurbish centers, improved

8:25 teaching and the connect

8:28 . Or their doubts too much

8:29 need technology and the

8:32 resources yet as I said before

8:33 and once the agent should

8:35 advocate for additional

8:37 capital funding to be adding

8:39 budget to create a more

8:41 affordable other adults

8:43 housing units crossing the

8:46 City. This is a big priority

8:48 mind as older doubts are

8:50 struggling with raising rent

8:51 and the lack of access

8:55 accessible, affordable order a

8:57 doubt friendly units cross the

8:59 five boroughs into this

9:00 hearing, we would like to get

9:02 a deeper understanding of

9:05 agents expense and the capitol

9:08 challenge included in the

9:09 executive plan as well as the

9:12 impact of key agencies.

9:15 Services, including case

9:17 management home delivered

9:18 meals and older center

9:20 programs. Additionally, I

9:21 would like to learn more about

9:25 potential impact and the

9:26 decision making process that

9:28 went into.

9:29 Saving that were included in

9:31 this plan while we know all

9:34 agencies were required to find

9:35 saving too close the budget

9:37 gap. I'm concerned about the

9:39 impact on other doubt seeing

9:41 our City, I would like to

9:42 thank committee staff who have

9:45 helped to prepare this hearing

9:49 . Hi, senior financial

9:52 . Adviser, analyst julia okay?

9:57 Her, her paramus director

10:02 Christopher pop senior. Let's

10:03 let the council, hannah called

10:07 let's let him counsel, joshua

10:10 human policy analyst and my

10:12 the Jennifer a. Thorn mosque

10:21 calm, director of budget.

10:22 And the legislation I have

10:24 turned back to financial

10:27 community council to

10:28 administrate the almost two

10:28 member of the administration.

10:31 Great. Thank you chair and

10:32 then also before we move on.

10:33 We've been joined by council

10:35 members el doble and j.

10:37 Sanchez arms for being here

10:39 and I personally can attest t

10:40 ohow important the cdbg and

10:42 capital grants are for kitchen

10:43 renovations and all the things

10:45 that always needs. So we've

10:46 got to figure out how to get

10:47 more funding for that in the

10:48 pipeline, so thank you. And

10:51 before we get started. I'd

10:52 like to take a quick moment t

10:53 oalso think the entire council

10:55 finance division stuff for

10:55 their efforts preparing for

10:58 these hearings and as a chair

11:00 going already mentioned julia

11:01 harrah, miss simon hamid for

11:04 today's hearing committee

11:05 counsel staff brian scarfo, my

11:07 senior adviser and all the

11:09 finance analyst and support

11:10 staff who make it all work and

11:12 as a reminder for this year's

11:15 executive budget joint

11:15 hearings, we will take public

11:16 testimony on all agencies.

11:20 Executive budget on Wednesday,

11:21 June 10 beginning at 9 30 a. M

11:25 and I will now turn over t

11:26 oour committee counsel to swear

11:27 in the witnesses for their

11:32 testimony. Good morning. Do

11:33 you affirm to tell the truth,

11:34 the whole truth and nothing

11:34 but the truth before this

11:36 committee and to respond

11:38 honestly to Council Member

11:40 questions commissioner dr

11:42 scott mckenzie. I do and o

11:47 hmercado, I do, you begin. Good

11:52 morning. Cheers. Juan charlie

11:53 and members of the committees

11:54 on aging and finance. I am dr

11:57 lisa scott mckenzie,

11:58 commissioner of the New York

11:59 City department for the aging

12:00 New York City aging. I am

12:02 joined this morning by jose

12:04 makato, our chief financial

12:06 officer. Thank you for this

12:07 opportunity to discuss New

12:08 York City agents executive

12:10 budget for fiscal year 20 27

12:15 27. Over the past three month

12:15 s. I have become acclimated to

12:17 this role as commissioner for

12:18 New York City, aging every day

12:20 I see the incredible work tha

12:21 tstaff at this agency and

12:23 throughout our network of

12:25 community based nonprofit

12:26 providers, complete as they

12:28 deliver vital services t

12:29 onearly 2 million New yorkers

12:31 over the age of 60. Today we

12:34 are discussing the

12:35 administration's executive

12:36 budget doing during mate,

12:39 which, as you know is older

12:40 americans month this.

12:41 Month is a national time t

12:42 oacknowledge and promote the

12:44 contributions of older adults

12:46 in our society and throughout

12:48 the many communities

12:48 represented in New York City

12:51 , it is also an opportunity

12:52 for us to affirm our

12:53 commitment as the largest area

12:56 agency on aging in the united

12:58 states to provide agent

13:00 services and make New York

13:01 City, a truly age inclusive

13:05 community, this year's theme

13:06 for older americans month is

13:07 champion your health and I.

13:09 Am so excited to be a part

13:10 of New York City ages.

13:12 Commitment to older adults and

13:15 their help well being and

13:16 dignity as we meet the growing

13:18 needs of New York city's

13:20 quickly approaching 2 million

13:21 residents over the age of 60.

13:23 Through my previous work at

13:24 the New York City health and

13:27 hospital systems, I became

13:28 keenly aware

13:28 . Of the many ways in older

13:30 adults, health needs are

13:31 affected by outside forces,

13:33 whether that is based in food

13:36 and security escalating

13:37 housing costs or persisten

13:38 tinequality in our communities.

13:41 To support this important

13:42 work are.

13:43 Y 27 executive budget

13:45 projects in funding of which

13:52 is in City funds with funding

13:54 for head count of 343 staff.

13:58 This includes allocations t

13:59 ocore programs. You're all

14:01 familiar with

14:02 . Including 263.6 million t

14:05 osupport older adults centers.

14:06 81.1 Million for home

14:09 deliberate meals and 57.

14:14 6Million for case management.

14:15 The work done by oasis sees

14:18 and our providers combat

14:21 poverty and financial

14:22 insecurity while also

14:23 connecting older adults to end

14:26 home services, which address

14:27 their needs when struggling

14:28 with activities of daily

14:29 living

14:29 . There are also allocations

14:31 of 47.2 million to support

14:34 home care for homebound older

14:36 adults who

14:36 . Are not medicaid eligible

14:38 and 16.8 million for north

14:42 programs finally 15.4 million

14:45 for caregivers services

14:45 supporting the caregivers and

14:49 their care receivers in the

14:50 City

14:51 . And 7.3 million for

14:54 transportation services,

14:55 allowing older adults to be

14:56 connected to community centers

14:58 , houses.

14:58 Of worship, shopping and

15:00 medical.

15:01 Appointments as this

15:02 administration has made clear

15:04 there are key challenges in

15:06 the City financially and New

15:07 York City, aging is always

15:09 prepared to prioritize the

15:10 needs of older adults and our

15:13 poor aging services while

15:15 limiting the impacts of these

15:17 challenges

15:17 . Nonetheless, we are still

15:18 keenly aware ofhese t

15:20 challenges, which have been

15:22 exacerbated by changes to the

15:25 federal landscape and the need

15:26 for continued and increased

15:27 investment from the state to

15:29 support the growing number of

15:30 older adults throughout New

15:33 York

15:33 . We also continue to advocate

15:34 that our state and federal

15:36 partners share the financial