Monday, March 23, 2026, 12:30 p.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 3
Committee: Committee on Small Business
The Committee on Small Business, chaired by Council Member Thomas-Henry, held its preliminary budget hearing for the Department of Small Business Services (SBS) for fiscal year 2027. Commissioner Minaya testified about the agency's $185.5 million preliminary budget, the new NYC Future Fund loan program, the Business Express Service Team expansion, workforce development through Workforce1 centers, and the new Office of Street Vendor Services. Council members questioned the agency extensively on the 23% vacancy rate (which the agency said is closer to 10% excluding pass-through entities), the 241 hiring freeze, commercial lease assistance, federal funding risks, MWBE certification and utilization, workforce placement wages and outcomes, and—most contentiously—a new RFP that would restructure the Industrial Business Service Provider (IBSP) program. Numerous members pressed the commissioner on the RFP, which providers say would dismantle place-based industrial business support. The hearing concluded with over twenty public testimonies, overwhelmingly urging restoration or protection of the IBSP program and funding for worker cooperatives, street vendor services, and legal assistance programs.
0:08 All electronics good afternoon
0:08 and welcome to the New York
0:11 City Council hearing for
0:14 . The small business committee
0:17 at this time please put all
0:20 electronic devices on silent
0:22 at no time anyone is too
0:24 approach the disk if you want
0:26 to testify or have any
0:27 questions please see one of
0:28 the sergeant of arms chair you
0:37 begin.
0:37 Chanel Thomas Henry and
0:40 before we begin I want t
0:43 oacknowledge the tragic
0:44 collision at laguardia airport e
0:50 passengers crew their families
0:51 and the first responders as a
0:54 representative of this
0:55 community that's his hits
0:57 close to home and we are
0:59 holding everyone impacted in
1:02 our prayers moments like this
1:03 remind us how deeply connected
1:05 our communities are and how
1:06 important it is that we show
1:07 up for one another not just in
1:10 crisis but in how we build
1:12 stability and opportunity
1:17 every day
1:17 . Welcome to today's hearing
1:19 on the fiscal.
1:20 20 27 Preliminary budget for
1:23 the department of small
1:26 business services.
1:26 I am honored to serve as
1:28 chair of the council's
1:29 committee on small business
1:30 small businesses are the
1:32 backbone of our economy and
1:34 give our neighborhoods their
1:36 unique identities it is
1:37 crucial that New York City
1:39 continues to support its
1:41 diverse universe of small
1:43 businesses I am excited t
1:44 ohear from the agency about how
1:48 this preliminary plan responds
1:49 to the needs of our small
1:50 business community and how the
1:51 resources will be utilized for
1:57 context seven budget as
1:59 presented in the preliminary
2:02 financial plan totals $115.3
2:07 million with or 36% supporting
2:13 397 budgeted full time
2:15 employees this budget is or 3
2:20 3and a half percent less than
2:22 the fiscal 20 26 adopted
2:24 budget of $173 million of the
2:29 total budget for the agency or
2:36 62.2% supports operations.
2:37 The remaining of the budget
2:39 is passed through funding for
2:42 the New York City economic
2:45 development corporation and y
2:46 c tourism and conventions
2:48 brooklyn navy yard and the
2:50 trust for governors island.
2:51 One of the issues continues
2:54 to struggle with is as
2:56 extremely high number of
2:58 vacancies which is currently
2:59 at 23% despite this the
3:03 preliminary plan includes an
3:04 increase of 30 budgeted
3:08 positions for business
3:09 development program area it
3:10 will be important for the for
3:11 the committee to understand
3:13 what steps the agency has
3:15 taken to fill vacancies t
3:16 ohelp carry out its mission it
3:18 is the council's
3:19 responsibility to ensure that
3:20 the city's budget is fair and
3:23 and accountable to New York
3:25 er's this includes equity and
3:26 funding and assistance plays a
3:30 key role in critical
3:33 initiatives from supporting
3:34 and uplifting minority and
3:36 women owned businesses the
3:38 invaluable work that workforce
3:41 one centers do connecting New
3:42 yorkers with jobs however this
3:44 committee would also like to
3:47 understand the quality of jobs
3:47 that the department is
3:49 connecting these job seekers
3:51 with furthermore small
3:53 businesses need to effectively
3:56 distribute loans technical
3:57 support and cut red tape I
3:58 look forward to hearing from
4:00 the department on all these
4:01 issues and more I would like
4:04 to both congratulate and thank
4:06 the New commissioner kenny
4:09 minaya first deputy
4:10 commissioner michael forte and
4:11 chief of staff harris kahn for
4:15 testifying today I would also
4:15 like to thank both my staff
4:18 and the staff of the finance
4:20 and legislative divisions for
4:21 their help in preparing for
4:24 this hearing glenn dan shaymen e
4:28 committee staff will now
4:29 administer the oath.
4:32 Panelists please raise your
4:33 right hand do you affirm t
4:35 otell the truth the whole truth
4:36 and nothing but the truth
4:38 before this committee and t
4:39 orespond honestly to council
4:40 member questions I do too you
4:45 begin.
4:45 Thank you chair good
4:50 afternoon everyone chair
4:51 Thomas Henry members of the
4:52 New York City Council
4:54 committee on small businesses
4:56 my name is kenny man ii and
4:57 I'm the commissioner of the
4:58 New York City department of
5:00 small business services I am
5:02 joined here today by first
5:04 deputy commissioner michael
5:06 forte and chief of staff
5:08 harris conn an in spirit with
5:11 over 300
5:12 . Czars who are out there
5:14 serving New York er's as we
5:16 speak I am pleased to appear
5:17 fiscal year 20 27 preliminary
5:22 budget and begin the first of
5:25 many conversations
5:26 . On how we can partner
5:27 together to support New York
5:28 city's small businesses last
5:30 Monday I took office as the
5:33 first dominican american to
5:35 serve as commissioner this
5:37 once in a generation
5:38 opportunity to deliver for
5:40 small businesses under Mayor
5:41 man donny is deeply meaningful
5:43 to me my family has owned and
5:45 operated a bakery for the past
5:47 42 years and I grew up
5:49 watching my parents hustle and
5:51 wear many hats they were the
5:53 accountant the chef the front
5:56 of the house and hr all rolled
5:59 into one as commissioner my
6:02 job is simple make it easier
6:04 for small businesses like
6:06 theirs to open operate and
6:09 succeed Mayor mamdani has made
6:10 clear that supporting small
6:12 businesses is central to his
6:15 affordability agenda just 1
6:17 4days into the administration
6:18 he issued executive order 11
6:21 to cut red tape and help
6:22 businesses open faster that
6:25 commitment reflects a simple
6:29 truth when businesses thrive
6:30 small businesses thrive they
6:32 create jobs and strengthen our
6:36 neighborhoods to support z's
6:38 charter responsibilities and
6:40 Mayor mamdani is affordability 2
6:44 7preliminary budget stands at a
6:47 hundred $85.5 million with an
6:48 authorized head count of 397
6:53 employees approximately 38% or
6:56 represents pass through
6:57 funding for other City
7:00 entities including the New
7:01 York City economic development
7:02 corporation at and why see
7:06 tourism and conventions at and
7:10 the trust for governors island
7:11 at we serve as a funding
7:15 conduit to these other City
7:18 entities and thus do not spend
7:20 or manage any of those funds
7:22 the remaining hundred or 62%
7:26 of the fiscal year 2
7:29 7preliminary budget is
7:32 allocated for let me tell you
7:33 about some of the small
7:34 businesses we have helped gina
7:38 and giselle cheung had long
7:41 had entrepreneurial
7:42 aspirations the two sisters
7:44 started out by operating an
7:47 empanada business in queens
7:48 taking online sales and
7:49 marketing through whatsapp but
7:51 like many businesses picking
7:53 up traction and a loyal
7:54 customer base they wanted t
7:56 oexpand and grow with a
7:58 storefront but did not know
7:59 the next steps to take s b s n
8:06 y best stepped in and helped
8:09 giselle review her business
8:10 model learn about the required
8:13 permits applied for her food
8:15 service establishment permit
8:17 and once she secured the
8:19 location receive an a grade
8:20 from the department of health
8:22 through coordinated guidance
8:23 and continued follow up in
8:25 less than four months nanite
8:27 aas opened its doors in
8:30 woodside with all required
8:31 permits since our inception
8:34 since its inception our best
8:35 team has saved small
8:37 businesses more than $60
8:40 million in fines and fees
8:44 through compliance education
8:44 and in the last two years
8:46 alone s b s has connected
8:49 small businesses to over $120
8:53 million in financing to help
8:54 grow their businesses on my
8:57 second day as commissioner I
8:57 was proud to announce the
9:00 citywide launch of our
9:02 revamped future fund program
9:04 that will provide $80 million
9:07 in financing to support nearly
9:10 100 small business annually
9:11 this one of a kind loan
9:13 program is designed for
9:15 seasonal businesses with
9:16 revenue based repayments so a
9:18 tough winter doesn't have to
9:19 put a small business under but
9:23 financing alone isn't enough
9:25 entrepreneurs also need fair
9:26 access to opportunity at we
9:30 support minority and women
9:33 owned business enterprises
9:35 local business enterprises and
9:37 emerging business enterprises
9:39 grow grow through
9:40 certification support
9:42 technical assistance levels
9:44 legal services and and
9:48 capacity building we first met
9:50 cathy chan in 20 18 when she
9:52 wanted to grow her business
9:54 studio v design and planning
9:57 she identified City
9:59 contracting as her next growth
10:01 opportunity and joined our
10:02 mentorship program to gain the
10:03 know how needed to compete
10:05 after winning her first
10:07 subcontract kathy continued t
10:11 oattend of our quickbooks for
10:14 construction clinic t
10:15 ostrengthen her firm's
10:16 financial management the
10:18 results speak for themselves
10:19 in fiscal year 25 alone the
10:21 City awarded $6.9 billion I
10:25 ncontracts to certified firms
10:26 like kathy's with a
10:28 utilization rate of 36.4% the
10:32 highest in program history and
10:35 75% of those firms used
10:38 services to successfully
10:40 successfully navigate the
10:41 procurement process
10:42 . Our work to connect
10:43 entrepreneurs to these
10:45 opportunities happens year
10:48 round through webinars.
10:49 Activations of our mobile
10:50 outreach unit and large scale
10:52 events like the contracting
10:55 summit where we brought small
10:57 businesses particularly m dubs
11:00 and contracting agencies under
11:01 one roof s b s also plays a
11:03 crucial role in connecting New
11:05 York er's took good quality
11:08 jobs one such newyorker
11:11 contacted for help after
11:12 giving birth to her third
11:14 child connie wanted to re the
11:16 workforce in a role that would
11:17 provide her the flexibility
11:19 and wages to care for her
11:22 children s helped her train
11:24 certify and apply for roles as
11:25 a home health aide when she
11:28 was unable to complete the
11:29 computer based trainings at
11:32 home s z's work force one
11:34 career supplied her her with
11:37 space and due to these efforts e
11:40 we are proud to have enabled
11:42 connie and so many New yorkers
11:44 like her to achieve their
11:45 career goals and support their
11:49 families through our 18 work
11:50 force one career centers
11:52 across the five borough
11:55 soffers job seekers employment
11:58 opportunities career coaching
11:58 and free job training in the
12:01 last two fiscal years has
12:03 placed nearly 45000 New
12:06 yorkers in jobs and enrolled
12:10 14000 in job trainings with a
12:11 focus on high demand
12:13 industries the hires include
12:17 13000 individuals with
12:17 also make sure we are meetings
12:23 job seekers where they are
12:25 through our jobs hiring halls
12:28 s b s delivers monthly hiring
12:30 halls in neighborhoods with
12:32 high unemployment rates to
12:33 reach underserved New yorkers
12:35 since the start of 20 24 has
12:38 served more than 16000 New
12:40 yorkers at 55 hiring halls
12:43 across all five boroughs this
12:46 effort has resulted in over
12:50 5200 on site interviews and
12:53 2600 conditional job offers
12:54 this week we are hosting a
12:56 career panel and jobs on March
13:02 27 in queens and we'll be
13:04 hosting focused hiring hall on
13:06 March 31 to hire for our soon
13:08 to be expanded New York City
13:11 business express service team
13:12 and other supportive units
13:15 beyond entrepreneurship and
13:17 employment supports
13:19 neighborhood vitality through
13:20 our oversight of New York
13:22 city's 78 business improvement
13:24 districts or bids which are
13:26 which collectively deliver
13:27 more than $216 million I
13:31 nservices annually across
13:32 nearly 300 of commercial
13:35 corridors in all corners of
13:36 the City this past joined
13:40 Mayor mamdani Council Member
13:42 Kayla sanz to sue oh so and
13:45 the for coney island t
13:47 ocelebrate the formation of the
13:48 New coney island bit the bids
13:50 creation culminates a decade
13:52 long effort in the
13:53 neighborhood to foster
13:55 neighborhood stewardship and
13:56 local organizing through more
13:58 than $850000 in grants since
14:02 fiscal year 20 25
14:04 . Has dispersed nearly $20
14:06 million in grants to fund
14:08 similar merchant organizing
14:10 bid formation and community
14:15 revitalization initiatives
14:16 . S p s grants have also
14:16 supported efforts to beautif
14:17 ynew York city's public realm
14:20 their creative neighborhood
14:21 way finding innovative
14:23 lighting fixtures and other
14:24 activities to increase foot
14:25 traffic in our commercial
14:28 corridors and Council Member
14:30 murano tze district the south
14:32 shore bid used its fiscal year t
14:35 it's sold out taste of the
14:39 town's restaurant restaurant
14:40 crawl event for the eighth
14:42 consecutive year and council
14:43 members salam's the harlem's
14:46 congregation for community
14:47 improvement leveraged a three
14:51 year avenue grant
14:51 . To create the brad hurst
14:54 summer festival.
14:54 Bringing together local
14:55 vendors and community members
14:58 to celebrate the neighborhood
14:59 and its small businesses we
15:01 are excited to release
15:02 applications for our next
15:03 round of grants in the coming
15:05 weeks we look forward to
15:07 partnering with you to not
15:09 only share these grant
15:10 opportunities with local
15:11 stakeholders but also to
15:14 continue supporting
15:14 neighborhood development
15:15 projects
15:15 . That create economic
15:17 opportunities for businesses
15:19 and communities in closing we
15:20 are excited to continue
15:23 building our partnership with
15:23 the City Council to support
15:25 small businesses job seekers
15:27 and commercial corridors in
15:28 the coming months we are
15:30 excited to expand business
15:34 express service team and build
15:35 our New office of street
15:37 vendor services.
15:38 Just this over the weekend
15:42 announced the appointment
15:43 . Of karina kaufman Gutiérrez
15:48 formerly corman co director of
15:49 the st vendor project
15:50 . As the inaugural executive
15:52 director of the office of st
15:54 vendor services her
15:55 appointment comes four months
15:57 ahead of schedule because we
15:59 know our street.
16:00 Vendors the smallest of
16:01 small businesses cannot wait
16:04 any longer.
16:04 We also look forward to
16:06 advancing economic justice for
16:08 small businesses through Mayor
16:10 mondaini executive order 1
16:11 1which created the first ever
16:13 comprehensive inventory of
16:15 small business fines and fees