Committee on Technology

Monday, March 2, 2026, 10 a.m. (New York City time), 250 Broadway - 8th Floor - Hearing Room 2

Committee: Committee on Technology

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Committee on Technology held an oversight hearing on facial recognition technology and the collection of biometric data, and heard two bills: Intro 213 (sponsored by Council Member Hanif), prohibiting places of public accommodation from using biometric recognition technology, and Intro 428 (sponsored by Council Member Sanchez), limiting facial recognition in residential buildings. Testimony came from the Office of Technology and Innovation (OTI) and HPD, the Public Advocate, civil liberties and public defense organizations (who supported the bills and urged a broader government ban), and industry representatives (who opposed both bills). No votes were taken; the bills were discussed. The chair pressed OTI for data on which agencies collect biometric information, said the committee would send a letter requesting specific data sets, and asked that the chief technology officer and chief privacy officer appear at future hearings.

Transcript

0:13 Quiet down please good morning

0:13 and welcome to today's New

0:15 York City Council hearing for

0:19 the committee on technology if

0:21 you will like to testify you

0:23 must fill our witness slip

0:24 with one of the sergeant at

0:25 arms even if you signed up

0:27 online already at this time

0:30 please silence all electronic

0:32 devices please silence all

0:34 electronic devices and no 1

0:35 approach a dais at any time

0:37 chair we are ready to begin

0:40 good morning and welcome t

0:42 oour first hearing I'm

0:44 councilmember Carmen De La

0:45 Rosa chair of the committee of

0:47 technology thank you for

0:49 joining us for today's

0:50 oversight hearing on facial

0:52 recognition technology and the

0:52 collection of biometric data

0:56 we will hear two bills

0:57 proposed in show 213 sponsored

0:59 by Council Member haneef in

1:02 relation to the prohibition

1:05 prohibiting places or

1:06 providers of public

1:07 accommodations from using

1:09 biometric recognition

1:10 technology and protecting any

1:12 biometric identifier

1:14 information collected at inch

1:16 o 428 sponsored by council

1:18 member purina Sanchez in

1:18 relation to limiting the use

1:20 of facial recognition

1:21 technology and residential

1:22 buildings this is my first

1:24 hearing as a chair of the

1:26 committee on technology and

1:27 I'm very excited to start this

1:29 session with this important

1:32 topic facial recognition

1:33 technology was introduced

1:34 years ago and since then it

1:37 has advanced rapidly in both

1:38 accuracy and accessibility it

1:41 is without question an

1:41 impressive and innovative tool

1:44 . Today it allows individuals

1:45 to unlock their phones

1:47 instantly secure access t

1:49 odevices and sensitive files

1:51 and enhance certain security

1:53 systems.

1:54 Use responsibly and with

1:56 appropriate safeguards facial

1:58 recognition technology offers

1:59 convenience and efficiency.

2:00 However like many powerful

2:03 technologies its impact

2:04 depends entirely on who is

2:04 using it and how it is used

2:07 some argue that facial

2:09 recognition is necessary for

2:11 public safety.

2:11 Cameras are now present on

2:14 many street corners and public

2:16 accommodations transportation

2:17 systems retail stores and even

2:20 residential buildings and yet

2:22 the widespread widespread

2:23 presence of cameras and facial

2:26 recognition systems has not by

2:26 itself eliminated crime

2:28 . Retailers argue that facial

2:30 recognition helps come back

2:33 and organized retail theft

2:35 however long term theft

2:36 statistics in New York City

2:38 from 20 from from 2006 2 24

2:41 show that overall trends have

2:43 generally increased

2:44 . With temporary declines

2:46 during the 20 20 lockdown and

2:48 slight decreases in 20 23

2:51 . Technology alone has not

2:51 proven to be the comprehensive

2:55 solution

2:55 . Additionally no technology

2:58 is perfect facial recognition

3:00 systems still misidentify

3:02 individuals according t

3:03 otesting by the national

3:04 institute of standards and

3:05 technology error rates can be

3:07 below 1% when analyzing high

3:10 quality controlled images such

3:12 as mug shots however when

3:13 images are less clear such as

3:16 those captured by surveillance

3:17 cameras in real world

3:19 conditions the error rate can

3:22 increase significantly in some

3:23 cases approaching 20%

3:24 . Even if accuracy could be

3:26 perfectly improved.

3:27 Serious concerns still

3:28 remain

3:29 . What happens when a person

3:30 is wrongfully flagged as a

3:32 criminal because he or she is

3:35 standing near someone else

3:37 resembles another individual

3:38 or were mistakenly included in

3:40 a database.

3:40 What recourse does that

3:41 person have to correct

3:44 inaccurate information is

3:45 there a transparent process

3:46 for review and removal

3:48 . Consider another scenario a

3:50 person who once committed a

3:52 minor offense

3:52 . Out of necessity or under

3:55 duress or by accident.

3:56 Should that individual be

3:58 permanently barred from

3:59 entering grocery stores or

4:00 denied housing because of

4:02 biometric data is stored in a

4:04 private system without clear

4:05 standards and due process

4:07 protections private entities

4:09 impose penalties without

4:10 transparency or an opportunity

4:12 for appeal

4:12 . We have already seen this

4:14 technology used beyond

4:17 traditional security context

4:18 madison madison square garden

4:20 made headlines for using

4:22 facial recognition technology

4:24 to deny entry to certain

4:25 attorneys involved in

4:26 litigation against the company t

4:29 question

4:30 . Where are the boundaries

4:32 could this technology be used

4:34 to exclude individuals based

4:35 on profession could it be

4:36 misused to discriminate based

4:38 on political views skin tones

4:40 backgrounds or other

4:42 characteristics.

4:42 The risk become even more

4:44 significant when facial

4:45 recognition is combined with

4:47 artificial intelligence and

4:48 other data sets could facial

4:50 recognition data be linked t

4:52 ofinancial records credit

4:54 scores tax information

4:55 purchasing history or family

4:57 status could individuals be

4:59 excluded based on income level

5:01 . Could different services be

5:03 provided based on data that

5:06 has been aggregated about a

5:08 customer customer these

5:09 concerns are no longer the art

5:11 theoretical.

5:12 And one more thing unlike a

5:13 password or a credit card a

5:15 face cannot be easily changed

5:18 once biometric data is

5:19 captured the risk could be

5:21 permanent.

5:21 Unfortunately the law often

5:23 lags behind technological

5:25 advances

5:25 . This is why thoughtful

5:27 action is necessary now

5:29 innovation should not come at

5:31 the expense of fundamental

5:32 rights clear guardrails are

5:34 essential transparency is how

5:35 is how systems operate

5:38 meaningful consent limits on

5:41 data retention and sharing

5:44 strong anti discrimination

5:45 protections independent

5:47 oversight and accessible

5:47 mechanisms to correct errors.

5:49 Facial recognition

5:50 technology is not inherently

5:52 good or bad it is a powerful

5:54 tool but its impact depends

5:56 not only on how it's designed

5:57 but also on how it is used and

6:00 for what

6:00 . Purpose because of its powerl

6:02 governance and clear

6:04 boundaries are responsibility

6:05 is to ensure that technology

6:07 evolves as technology evolves

6:09 it does not do so in a way

6:12 that protects it it does so in

6:12 a way that protects privacy

6:16 prevents discrimination

6:17 safeguards due process and

6:18 maintains public trust the

6:20 goal is not to slow innovation t

6:24 innovation innovation serves

6:26 people without compromising

6:28 their rights.

6:28 Today I want an honest

6:31 answers from multi I from

6:33 businesses and real estate

6:34 owners and from residents

6:36 themselves about the real

6:37 benefits and dangers of

6:39 technology finally I'd like t

6:41 othank technology committee

6:43 staff attorney irene bye bosco

6:46 lab yassky we're going to get

6:47 that we're going to get that

6:48 don't.

6:48 Worry and policy analyst

6:50 Eric brown that my chief of

6:53 James burke and frei familia

6:54 for the tremendous work on

6:56 putting these hearings

6:57 together I also want t

6:59 orecognize committee members

7:00 council members honeys and

7:02 council members Sanchez who

7:03 are here.

7:03 And I'll now turn it t

7:06 ocouncil member haneef for

7:06 bill thank you cheer De La

7:10 Rosa for holding today's

7:12 important hearing and for

7:13 including my bill in 213 on

7:16 today's agenda I am proud that

7:17 14:00 members of the council

7:20 currently sponsor this bill in

7:22 200 and would prohibit

7:23 businesses and other places of

7:25 public accommodation from

7:27 using facial recognition and

7:28 other forms of biometric

7:30 surveillance to verify or

7:32 identify a customer this is a

7:34 matter of basic privacy people

7:36 have a right to access

7:38 essential places like grocery

7:40 stores without having their

7:43 personal biometric information

7:44 like the shape of their face

7:45 and the way they walk

7:48 collected used or sold for

7:50 targeted advertising or other

7:52 purposes

7:52 . This hearing comes at an

7:54 important time earlier this

7:56 year New York er's learned

7:57 that wegmans has begun

7:58 collecting biometric data from

8:01 customers entering its

8:03 supermarkets that means that

8:05 shoppers have their facial

8:07 features eye scans or voice

8:10 data captured without a clear

8:11 understanding of how that

8:14 information is stored used or

8:16 shared what happens if that

8:18 data is breached many of us

8:19 know the feeling of

8:21 discovering our credit card

8:22 information has been stolen

8:25 it's invasive and frightening

8:26 but you can cancel a credit

8:28 card and get a New one you

8:30 cannot cancel your face you

8:33 cannot replace your iris you

8:34 cannot change your gait

8:36 biometric data is permanent

8:38 when it is compromised the

8:40 harm is lasting that's why

8:41 this issue demands urgent

8:44 attention intro to that 13 I

8:45 sa critical measure to combat

8:46 at wrongful discrimination

8:49 facial recognition tools have

8:50 repeatedly been shown to

8:52 produce significantly higher

8:53 inaccuracy rates for people of

8:55 color and women those

8:57 inaccuracies are not abstract

8:58 they have resulted in real

9:01 people being falsely accused

9:03 of wrongdoing and denied

9:04 access to public spaces the

9:08 federal trade commission found

9:09 that right ade used facial

9:11 recognition technology in a

9:13 way that falsely and

9:16 disproportionately identified

9:16 thousands of people of color

9:18 and women as likely

9:21 shoplifters including in New

9:22 York City stores the described

9:25 what followed quote acting on

9:26 false positive facial

9:30 recognition matches employees

9:32 followed customers around its

9:34 stores search them ordered

9:36 them to leave call the police

9:40 to confront or remove

9:42 customers consumers and

9:44 publicly accused them

9:45 sometimes in front of friends

9:46 or family of shoplifting or

9:49 other wrongdoing end quote in

9:51 one case an 11 year old

9:52 . Girl was wrongly stopped and

9:54 searched because of a false

9:56 match I urge everyone here t

9:59 oimagine how dehumanizing that

10:01 experience would be it's

10:03 reported that madison square

10:04 garden entertainment used

10:06 facial recognition technology

10:08 to identify individuals and

10:11 deny certain people entry

10:12 based on their employer that

10:13 is a deeply troubling use of

10:16 surveillance

10:16 . Technology discrimination

10:17 harm caused by biometric

10:19 surveillance is not a paranoid e

10:23 off incident it is happening

10:25 now while writing is

10:26 prohibited from using

10:28 biometric surveillance for

10:29 five years we shouldn't have

10:31 to rely on federal

10:33 investigations and lawsuits t

10:35 oprevent other businesses from

10:37 repeating the same harm

10:37 against New York er's I also

10:39 want to be clear this bill

10:40 takes a measured approach it

10:42 does not ban all uses of

10:45 biometric technology customers

10:46 would still be able to opt in

10:50 to technologies pay by palm at

10:52 checkout or biometric identity

10:55 verification at airports

10:57 businesses that genuinely

10:59 require biometric tools t

10:59 ocarry out core functions such

11:01 as a custom running shoe store

11:04 that uses gait analysis would

11:06 be permitted to do so this

11:10 legislation advances basic

11:12 consumer protections not

11:15 ideological absolutism and

11:15 this bill does not affect

11:17 standard security tools like

11:20 video monitoring I share

11:21 concerns about retail theft

11:23 and repeat offenders and I

11:24 support funding for

11:26 infrastructure upgrades that

11:27 help small businesses but as a

11:29 rite aid case demonstrates

11:32 biometric surveillance is not

11:34 an effective solution and in

11:35 many cases it makes New

11:36 yorkers less safe.

11:37 I reject the premise that

11:39 facial recognition is an

11:42 essential security measure as

11:43 a muslim newyorker who grew up

11:44 in the post 9 11 era I know

11:47 firsthand the consequences of

11:49 allowing fear to justify

11:51 excessive and biased

11:52 surveillance I want to thank

11:53 the band the scan coalition

11:54 who rallied with us earlier

11:55 today and our here to testify

11:57 in support of intro to 13

12:00 thank you cher dela Rosa thank

12:02 you Council Member haneef will

12:03 now hear from Council Member

12:04 purina Sanchez on her bill

12:07 thank you chair and good

12:07 morning everyone when you come

12:09 home at night you're building

12:10 should be a place of safety

12:13 not surveillance I

12:14 reintroduced introduced into

12:17 428 because biometric

12:18 recognition technology systems y

12:21 can collect and can store

12:24 deeply personal information

12:25 . Your face your gait your

12:26 movement patterns and this

12:27 information can track who you

12:28 are where you go and who you

12:30 meet

12:31 . We know these technologies

12:32 are still flawed and racially

12:33 biased as my colleagues have

12:35 highlighted study after study

12:37 shows that they misidentify

12:38 black and brown people at

12:40 disproportionately higher

12:42 rates housing is an area of

12:45 profound power imbalance and

12:46 you're landlord in particular

12:47 should not have automatic the

12:50 automatic ability to build a

12:52 biometric database of you as a

12:53 tenant and your guests intro 4

12:56 28 is simple it expands upon

12:58 local law 63 of 20 21 which

13:01 placed tenant protections with

13:02 respect to property owners

13:03 that utilize smart access or

13:06 keyless systems in show

13:07 hundred 28 limits what smart

13:09 access systems can collect and

13:11 prohibits biometric

13:12 recognition technology in

13:13 multiple dwellings without

13:14 explicit consent we care about

13:17 buildings and their security

13:19 of course just not at the cost

13:20 of tenant privacy and civil

13:22 liberties.

13:22 I also want to thank the

13:24 band scan coalition for your

13:26 collaboration on this bill

13:27 before I was a sponsor because

13:29 we agree that New York er's

13:31 deserve their privacy thank

13:32 you so much thank you so much

13:35 councilmember Sanchez we are

13:37 expecting the public advocate

13:39 soon but we're going to go

13:42 ahead and hear testimony from

13:46 a and b we also have some

13:49 written testimony from w

13:53 covering want to welcome alex

13:54 ford the executive director of

13:56 research and collaboration

13:58 under and lucy joffee of hpd

13:59 . Thank you chair and before

14:02 we begin with your testimony I