Parks reports zero drownings with lifeguards on duty, but says it can't staff a longer beach season
At Friday's Council hearing, the department said beaches and pools cost about $2.5 million a week to run and that it does not track drownings after lifeguards go home. All four bills were laid over.
The Parks Department told the City Council on Friday, Nov. 13, that no one drowned at a city beach or pool this summer while lifeguards were on duty, and that the city certified 1,174 lifeguards, its most in four years. It also said it could not hire enough staff to keep beaches and pools open longer, as one of the bills before the committee would require.
The Committee on Parks and Recreation, chaired by Ty Hankerson, laid over all four water safety bills it heard, which means no vote was taken. This follows our preview of the hearing.
Why it matters to residents: Parks counts only drownings during supervised hours. Members asked about people who swim after the lifeguards leave, and the department said those deaths are tracked by the NYPD and the Health Department, not by Parks.
What Parks reported
First Deputy Commissioner Mark Focht said the 2026 beach season ran 114 days, the longest in a decade, and that lifeguards made more than 200 rescues (13:49, 14:36). He said no one died or drowned while lifeguards were on duty in their chairs at any city beach or pool (15:21).
Advertisement
Under questioning, officials said:
- About 480 lifeguards worked beaches and about 680 worked pools (24:28). The Council's Finance Division, using fiscal 2026 figures, counted about 440 and 630.
- Starting pay is "just below $23 an hour," plus a $1,000 bonus for first-year guards who stay through Labor Day (25:13).
- 79% of the summer 2025 lifeguards came back in 2026, up from about 70% in past years (32:05).
- The goal is about 1,400 lifeguards, the pre-pandemic level (15:21).
The registration portal for next summer's lifeguard qualifying tests opens Sunday, Nov. 15, and the first tests are Dec. 1, Focht said (16:07). The qualifier is a 50-yard swim in 45 seconds, and 605 people passed it last year (35:51).
The bills
- Int. 262, from Shekar Krishnan, would open beaches and outdoor pools from the second Saturday in May to the second Sunday in October, from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., and keep indoor pools open 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. Focht said most seasonal staff are teachers and students who would not be available, and that lifeguards cannot see swimmers after dusk (16:52). He said 12-hour days would mean "almost" doubling the number of lifeguards and that beaches and pools cost "about two and a half million dollars a week" to operate (41:15, 42:48). The Finance Division's fiscal impact statement calls the cost "indeterminable."
- Int. 957, from Selvena N. Brooks-Powers, would require rip current signs in English, Spanish and at least two other languages at every beach entrance, lifeguard chair and jetty. Her statement, read into the record, said Rockaway Beach accounted for more than a third of 203 water emergencies at city beaches and pools in the most recent year of department data (10:45).
- Int. 1163, from Hankerson, introduced the day before the hearing, would require digital signs with audio warnings at beach entrances. Focht said there are more than 200 entrances across eight beaches and that the signs would be costly to maintain in sand and salt spray (21:25).
- Int. 1164, from Krishnan, would have Parks identify city-owned pools where nonprofits could offer swim lessons. Focht said the department lacks the expertise to judge pools it doesn't run.
Parks said only Rockaway is a true ocean beach with rip currents, and that it already posts federal rip current posters in restrooms at all eight beaches.
Drownings after hours
Frank Morano asked how many people drowned at city beaches outside lifeguard hours. Focht said Parks does not track those deaths (39:45). If someone drowns at 6:30 p.m., after the lifeguard has left at 6, Morano said, he was "not sure the family is going to take a great deal of comfort" in the department's statistics (40:30). Mercedes Narcisse asked what the city can do to reduce those deaths (32:50); Parks said its message is to swim only when a lifeguard is in the chair (33:35).
Advertisement
Kayla Santosuosso, whose district includes Coney Island, asked for a permanent plan to staff the beach's west end, which she said had gaps this summer (51:55).
Witnesses from the Water Safety Coalition asked for a city Office of Water Safety, swim education in schools and a follow-up hearing with more notice.
What's next
Hankerson apologized for the short notice and said the committee would hold a follow-up hearing, without giving a date (1:27:56). The four bills stay in committee.