On My Block · NYC Politics

City CouncilSchools

The Council files its reply in Mamdani's suit over $10,000 paraprofessional payments. The law's first pay period ends Saturday

Local Law 129, which passed unanimously, calls for payments in four installments, the first due Jan. 1 for work through Nov. 14. The administration says it bypasses collective bargaining; the Council and the teachers union asked the court Tuesday to dismiss the suit.

The City Council on Tuesday filed its legal reply in the lawsuit Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration brought to block Local Law 129, which requires one-time payments of up to $10,000 to school paraprofessionals, according to the Council's announcement. The United Federation of Teachers, a co-defendant, filed its own papers the same day seeking dismissal with prejudice, the release says. The Council posted its filing on the state court system's site.

Why it matters to residents: paraprofessionals are the classroom aides who work mostly with students with disabilities and young children. The Council says more than 1,000 of the jobs were vacant as of March, and families of students who don't get mandated services can sue the city for private placements.

What the law requires

The bill, Int. 692, from Carmen N. De La Rosa, has 51 sponsors in our records. The Council passed it on July 16 and sent it to the mayor July 20. He neither signed nor vetoed it, and it took effect Aug. 18, our records show. The administration sued in state Supreme Court in Manhattan on Aug. 19, amNY reported.

According to the Council's fiscal impact statement, the Department of Education would pay eligible paraprofessionals in four non-pensionable installments, pro-rated by days on payroll:

  • by Jan. 1, 2027, for work from Sept. 1 through Nov. 14, 2026
  • by March 1, for Nov. 15 through Jan. 31
  • by June 1, for Feb. 1 through April 14
  • by Aug. 1, for April 15 through June 30

The law expires once every payment is made, or sooner if a union contract raises paraprofessionals' total pay by at least as much. The Finance Division estimated the cost at $243.7 million this fiscal year and $81.2 million next.

Paraprofessionals start at $32,098 and reach $54,541 after 15 years under the current contract, City & State reported.

The two sides' arguments

The administration argues the law sets "terms and conditions of employment" that state law, the Taylor Law, leaves to collective bargaining between the city and its unions, City & State reported. The Council's filing says the administration could settle the dispute itself through bargaining, that the Taylor Law does not stop the Council from improving public workers' pay or conditions, and that a one-time emergency payment is not a term of employment.

"We remain confident in the Council's authority to enact this law and will continue to vigorously defend it in court," Speaker Julie Menin said in the release.

What the administration told the Council in March

At the Committee on Civil Service and Labor's March 9 hearing, chaired by Shirley Aldebol, an administration witness, Daniel Pollack, was asked what proposals the city had made to raise paraprofessional pay. "We have not made any proposals as of this time," he said (15:41). He said the city was "more than willing to sit down and talk" with the union before the next bargaining round (17:02) and that "there are lots of the employees that I would love to see paid more," pointing to "fiscal realities" (17:38).

A separate review

Paraprofessional hiring drew new attention this week for a different reason. On Monday, Mamdani said he had directed a full review of how a substitute paraprofessional charged in a fatal stabbing on the Shore Parkway Greenway in Bath Beach was hired by the Department of Education, amNY reported. Council Members Kayla Santosuosso and Frank Morano have called for an investigation of the department's screening, according to amNY. The charges are allegations.

What's next

The court has not ruled on the motions, and no hearing date was listed in the Council's announcement. Unless the court blocks the law, the first payment period closes Saturday, Nov. 14.

Support NYC Politics

Keep NYC Politics free for everyone

NYC Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime